Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Column: #15 -- The Debate

Collapse
X
Collapse
  •  

  • The Column: #15 -- The Debate

    By Andrew Hoekzema
    November 14th, 1998

    note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us.

    CivII is now more than 2 1/2 years old, CiC is about 1 1/2 years old, and FW is 1 year old. Many people have argued that the two add-on packs are a waste of money, but I would disagree. Personally, I find scenarios the most interesting aspect of Civilization 2. Both of these add-ons provided very useful tools for scenario designers. The CivII designers created a semi language in order to vastly expand the capabilities of scenario designs, expanded the amount of units and techs available as well as providing plenty of good graphics and handy editors for scenario designers to use. But I can see why people think that FW and CiC were just wastes.

    PREVIOUS ARTICLES
    #13 APOLYTON CS: THE FUTURE
    Jaspers ponders upon the future of our site...
    #14 WORTH THE WAIT
    Sean defends MicroProse against some recent criticisms!
    COLUMN ARCHIVE

    The problem NOW is that I think the designers have finally realized that multiplayer is the end of the line for this particular game. They of course COULD add more capabilities, but that would be unwise since interest would not be large enough to support many more products for a two and a half year old game. We, the CivII community, too must realize that multiplayer will be as far as CivII goes. As far as I can tell, games like CTP, TOT, and Rise of the Nations are completely new strains of the CivII genre and structure, but not at all the same design.

    Interest in the original version of CivII and scenarios, of course, would remain after these games come out, but not for too long. Consider that not only will it be competing with games which are clones, but of much, much better quality, but will also be competing with fantastic games of other types of strategy, such as Caesar 3, Sim City 3000, and Tiberian Sun.

    Unfortunately, it seems these are the final days of the CivII edge on the rest of the strategy world. The worst part about the whole thing, though, is that these greatly improved games will be practically impossible to convert into scenarios. They will be so complicated and intricate that scenarios and modifications would be very rare finds indeed.

    The scenario ideas themselves are running pretty low now, too. While there certainly are good scenarios ideas out there, how many World War 2 or Age of Discovery scenarios can be done and still be original?

    We are in the final days of CivII's reign as the king of video games. Multiplayer will certainly be fun for ALL of the CivII community, but it will not be able to last forever. We should enjoy the novel ideas that are coming about now, such as e mail games, tournaments, and scenario league.


    Andrew is 16 years of age, lives in Highland Park, New Jersey, USA. He is a high school sophmore and is an aspiring History buff (especially regarding the Imperial Age of the Crimean War through WW1).

    The opinions expressed on this page doesnt necessarily express Apolyton CS or GameStats.
    It is just the personal opinions of the writer.

      Posting comments is disabled.

    Article Tags

    Collapse

    Latest Articles

    Collapse

    • The Column: #20 -- MGE: Why NOT Bother?
      by reismark
      By Reismark I December 19th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. The CivII world recently received an enormous boost with the release of MGE. It has been accompanied by both positive and negative feedback. This column published some negative feedback last week; this week, it's time for the positives. ...
      December 18, 2012, 21:03
    • The Column: #19 -- MGE: Why Bother?
      by dracon
      By Dracon December 12th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. When I first heard about CivII: MGE, I thought, why bother? I mean, we're talking about a game that came out in '96, and in the gaming world, that's ancient history. MGE is basically Civ2 with multiplayer, big deal! What they should've done is made it an expansion pack. It's using old gaming technology in today's gaming world. I mean, why get MGE, when you can wait a little longer, and get the latest in civilization gaming, SMAC and CTP. Both come with multiplayer, and up-to-date gaming technology. ...
      December 18, 2012, 20:59
    • The Column: #18 -- All I Want For Christmas Is Gaming Goodness
      by DanQ
      By Daniel Quick December 5th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. It's what, 7am Christmas morning and you've already raided your stockings, presents, fridge (opps, how'd that get in there? ) and you're already entrenched in your most favourite new toy (forgive this grammar, I'm Canadian eh?). That's right, a computer game! You're all so excited, knowing all the hype the game had received in the months gone by has been well worth your time... the equivlent of the must-have action figure for a 10-year-old. You begin to remember to that cool, autumn day when you far from vaguely hinted to your relatives of a particular game you have been eyeballing forever. And now, it's finally here! You enthusiastically scream "YES!!" at the top of your lungs, which interrupts your neighbours' slumber and they begin to wonder whether the world's newest millionaire is finally moving far, far way... but I digress. ...
      December 18, 2012, 20:49
    • The Column: #17 -- Unconventional Reality
      by MarkG
      By Markos Giannopoulos November 28th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. INTRO The last 5-6 months, since we started hearing about CTP, Activision's version of civ, the most discussed new features were the unconventional units, like the Park Ranger and the Lawyer. Many players found these units to be silly or at least unreal. I will try to answer to these "accusations" for some of the units. ...
      December 18, 2012, 20:45
    • The Column: #16 -- The Art Of Being Late
      by MarkG
      By Markos Giannopoulos November 21th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. INTRO Waiting for a flight that I never took due to it's excessive delay, I was thinking about the delays of the three games that we're waiting(civ2:mge, smac and ctp) and how we were informed of them. At the end, I found logical reasons for all of the delays, except of my flight's ...
      December 18, 2012, 20:40
    • The Column: #15 -- The Debate
      by Martin Gühmann
      By Andrew Hoekzema November 14th, 1998 note: This is The Column, a part of Apolyton where mainly Markos and Dan write whatever we want . Well, not just the two of us. The Column is open to everyone. If you feel like writing submit your article to us. CivII is now more than 2 1/2 years old, CiC is about 1 1/2 years old, and FW is 1 year old. Many people have argued that the two add-on packs are a waste of money, but I would disagree. Personally, I find scenarios the most interesting aspect of Civilization 2. Both of these add-ons provided very useful tools for scenario designers. The CivII designers created a semi language in order to vastly expand the capabilities of scenario designs, expanded the amount of units and techs available as well as providing plenty of good graphics and handy editors for scenario designers to use. But I can see why people think that FW and CiC were just wastes. ...
      December 18, 2012, 20:34
    Working...
    X