boy, 15, rapes his mother

[Kuciwalker]

Originally posted by MrWhereItsAt
This is ONE step from being Dave Lister.

[MichaeltheGreat]

Originally posted by St Leo

Originally posted by Sava
you don't need to be a repuke to want sick criminal ****s put to death

Nah, any emotionally unstable idiot can do that.

We'll just send 'em all to your house, and you can deal with 'em.

[MichaeltheGreat]

Originally posted by Sava
or someone who is realistic about where society should spend it's resources and who it should bother to try to rehabilitate... there is no worse a violent and disturbing crime than rape, add to the mix the victim was his mother... and you got one ****ed up piece of **** kid. The money spent on years of prison/institutional help could be better served helping the poor or other mentally disturbed individuals who aren't violent criminals.

Stop being reasonable, Sava - it'll be a disturbing trend if you keep it up.

[Imran Siddiqui]

MtG: Yeah, that's seriously freaky .

[Space05us]

or someone who is realistic about where society should spend it's resources and who it should bother to try to rehabilitate... there is no worse a violent and disturbing crime than rape, add to the mix the victim was his mother... and you got one ****ed up piece of **** kid. The money spent on years of prison/institutional help could be better served helping the poor or other mentally disturbed individuals who aren't violent criminals.

[St Leo]

Originally posted by Sava
or someone who is realistic about where society should spend it's resources and who it should bother to try to rehabilitate... there is no worse a violent and disturbing crime than rape, add to the mix the victim was his mother... and you got one ****ed up piece of **** kid. The money spent on years of prison/institutional help could be better served helping the poor or other mentally disturbed individuals who aren't violent criminals.

And so you condemn another human to death. Congratulations.

[Ben Kenobi]

where society should spend it's resources and who it should bother to try to rehabilitate

So why rehabilitate anyone? Why not just hang 'em all and be done with it?

[MichaeltheGreat]

We might get something useful out of those we rehabilitate.

[Agathon]

Weird.

I read somewhere that incest between biological parents and children who were adopted out is not uncommon when they meet again in adult life. Scary stuff.

This kiddie probably needs to be locked up for his own good.

[Shi Huangdi]

Killing this kid would be a sick and obscene idea. Anyone who would do something like this very likely has severe psychological problems that would limit his culpability.

The classical arguments for DP don't really apply well. Detterance? Raping your mom is such a rare crime we don't need to be concerned about that? Reperations for the victim? The mom herself said she wants to see her son get treatment.

That leaves protection for society. Well, there alot of sick people we arrest that are likely to be long term problems, potentially violent problems, for society. But we don't kill them just on potential- unless they have actually done the ultimate crime and murdered someone and have thus proven that they are a severe danger to society.

Killing this kid would show an absolute and total disrespect for the value of life in society.

[Agathon]

The death penalty doesn't work. It doesn't deter criminals and it relies on an infallibility in the Justice system which is unattainable.

More to the point, whatever the morals of putting criminals to death it is certainly bad for the community as it appeals to the lowest most vengeful human instincts.

[Space05us]

And so you condemn another human to death. Congratulations.

thank you

So why rehabilitate anyone? Why not just hang 'em all and be done with it?

damn straight!

Killing this kid would show an absolute and total disrespect for the value of life in society.

because raping your mother is so much more respectful. Besides society is for pussies and women

[Lefty Scaevola]

Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
So why rehabilitate anyone?

The why is easy. The how to is the problem. Rehabilitation efforts have been the most futile and wasteful part of any criminal justice system I have knowledge of,

[St Leo]

Originally posted by Lefty Scaevola
The why is easy. The how to is the problem. Rehabilitation efforts have been the most futile and wasteful part of any criminal justice system I have knowledge of,

What you said, except replace "rehabilitation" with "punishment".

[Zero]

great, I think Im gonna have problem getting a hard on for weeks....

damn 15 raping a 36 yr old alone is pretty ****ed up.