boy, 15, rapes his mother

[Tiamat]

Lister only loved Kachansky smeghead

Bigger picture....the mother. Can you imagine the guilt she must feel. Even if she did nothing to cause it, we as mother's tend to feel guilty for our childs actions. She must be going through a horrible time let alone the embaressment of living in a town where everyone knows your son raped you.

[Winston]

That's it. No supper for you, young man!

[monkspider]

Originally posted by Winston
That's it. No supper for you, young man!

[Kuciwalker]

Originally posted by Winston
That's it. No supper for you, young man!

ewwww

[Drake Tungsten]

This assault is clearly all Eminem's fault.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Oh, and add me to the chorus that says the best thing to do is to execute the ****er.

[Enigma_Nova]

Originally posted by Ben Kenobi
So why rehabilitate anyone? Why not just hang 'em all and be done with it?

Understanding is Superior to Ignorance.
You may learn useful stuff and people are less pissed of if they're understood rather than ignored.

Wasn't there this Oedipus dude?
There's been plenty of Matricide throughout history... some people are annoyed at their parents for some reason.
The only way I can see this happening is if the kid wanted revenge for being sexually abused (not nescesarily by same mother).

[Enigma_Nova]

Originally posted by Shi Huangdi
unless they have actually done the ultimate crime and murdered someone and have thus proven that they are a severe danger to society.

Considering some of the idiots out there, I think the danger to society would be to let them live!
Murder isn't bad if you kill those who do not deserve to live.

[Kuciwalker]

Wasn't there this Oedipus dude?

Yeah, but in his case it was completely unwitting, so go easy on him.

[Kuciwalker]

Originally posted by Enigma_Nova
Considering some of the idiots out there, I think the danger to society would be to let them live!
Murder isn't bad if you kill those who do not deserve to live.

like this guy

[centrifuge]

This person is no good to society in general, rehab will do sh#t to correct the situation, I don't believe that killing him is the answer, but damn what other option is there? He can live the rest if his life in a hole in the ground and come out even more deranged, or he can be shot which will do nothing to get to the root of the problem but will leave us with one less ****ing loser piece of filth to deal with.
Where would God stand... the answer can only be conjecture.

[St Leo]

Originally posted by Enigma_Nova Considering some of the idiots out there, I think the danger to society would be to let them live!
Murder isn't bad if you kill those who do not deserve to live.

Nah, I'd rather keep conservatives alive. If anything, we are going to need cannon fodder when the Moon Rises Again.

[Dr Strangelove]

Since he had recently been in detention I'd wonder if something might have happened while he was in there. The things that happen to a kid who "drops the soap in the shower" can do enough psychological damage to make him do something crazy.

[GePap]

Neither rape, incest nor assault (the three crimes commited here) are capital crimes today, so no, the kid does not "deserve" death.

Interestingly, in a society so obcessed with "vctims rights" or what the victim thinks, I see so many willing to utterly ignore the whishes oif the victim as to the outcome- just keep this in mind for later.

The kid should recieve the punishement someone would get for violent rape of a person- the fact he did it vs his mother shows that some high level of metal disturbance was present, which might mean once out of prison he would have to go to some mental institution for serious treatment.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Neither rape, incest nor assault (the three crimes commited here) are capital crimes today, so no, the kid does not "deserve" death.

Is and should are different inquiries.