Originally posted by kentonio
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
The Crusaders were trapped there, out of finances. There wasn't any order to slaughter, but it unfortunately happened anyway.
-
While leaving out the culpability of Alexios IV in keeping them there? You're aware that even after the coup, he kept the Crusader army there for months afterwards because he needed troops that would prop him up after he lost the support of the people of Constantinople?You moron, it absolutely astounds me that you have the sheer arrogance to think you know more about the culpability of the Catholic church than John Paul II did.
It is easy with the gaze of the 21st century to condemn the actions of 12th century Catholics. Personally, I would rather quote Innocent III who was there. But that doesn't serve your narrative that the culpability was on the Catholics who had a rather restrained response.
Again, the Crusade would have either fizzled out or ended up in Egypt without the intervention of Alexios IV. That much is certain. Alexios IV promised to pay them, but he did not keep his promises.
That does not change the fact that the Venetians in particular still possessed a Casus Belli against the Emperor, even if they did not exercise it. It wasn't even the Venetians that directed the Fourth Crusade to Constantinople, it was Alexios IV.As for casus belli, the crusade got themselves horribly in debt to the Venetians and then ran completely out of control against the wishes of the pope. They also had absolutely no authority from anyone to declare war on Byzantium or act on any such casus belli even if one had existed.
Indeed, which is a rather measured response. Did the Patriarch excommunicate those who slaughtered the Latins 20 years before, or did they crown them?The pope excommunicated them for ****s sake, and only lifted it after they convinced him into thinking the Venetians had blackmailed them into it.
Curious. I'm still waiting for your acknowledgement that the slaughter of 80k Catholics in Constantinople, where the perpetrators received no punishment is an atrocity. I guess to you they are just a statistic.Now as you're completely at odds with at least two popes now, would you like to retract your stupid and callous previous statements?
Leave a comment:
-
You moron, it absolutely astounds me that you have the sheer arrogance to think you know more about the culpability of the Catholic church than John Paul II did.
As for casus belli, the crusade got themselves horribly in debt to the Venetians and then ran completely out of control against the wishes of the pope. They also had absolutely no authority from anyone to declare war on Byzantium or act on any such casus belli even if one had existed.
The pope excommunicated them for ****s sake, and only lifted it after they convinced him into thinking the Venetians had blackmailed them into it.
Now as you're completely at odds with at least two popes now, would you like to retract your stupid and callous previous statements?
Leave a comment:
-
Yes, the slaughter of 80k Catholic civilians in Byzantium, including the sick.Casus belli? For one of the most opportunistic and vile acts of villany in Catholic history? You talk an amazing amount of pure unadulterated bull****.
Perhaps I should say the same for you, in outright dismissing what happened to the Catholics. 80k, Kentonio.Pretty ****ed up even for you to be trying to defend an outrage which involved thousands of senseless murders and the mass rapes of countless women including nuns.
London itself had only 20k then.
IF the slaughter of 80k Catholics without provocation is not a Casus Belli, then I'm not sure what would consist of provocation.
In any case, Venetian response was justified.
If we want to get into Papal judgment, Innocent III refused to give his blessing to a Crusade against the Byzantine Empire in response to the slaughter of the Catholics. Not because such was not justified, but because he wanted to end the cycle of vengeance before it lead to greater damage.
Had Alexios IV, not offered the Crusaders payment to reach Constantinople, the Fourth Crusade would not have ended up in Constantinople in the first place. In short, the Byzantines destroyed themselves. The Fourth Crusade is a sad story, but there were many points where things would have worked out differently.Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 17, 2016, 18:51.
Leave a comment:
-
Casus belli? For one of the most opportunistic and vile acts of villany in Catholic history? You talk an amazing amount of pure unadulterated bull****.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostYou mean Emperor Alexios III Angelos? You might want to read up on him a bit before blaming the Catholics for the destruction of the Empire. The Latin Crusaders had only 20k men. Isaac II Angelos had just cause against his brother. None of the Angelos were porphyrogennetos.
Then you have the massacre of the Latins in 1182. 80k killed by Andronikos Komnenos.
Anyway you slice it the Venetians and the Latins had a casus belli.
Or we could listen to the words of an actual pope, despite your apparent belief that you know better.Originally posted by WikiThe Library of Constantinople was destroyed.[9] Despite their oaths and the threat of excommunication, the Crusaders systematically violated the city's holy sanctuaries, destroying or stealing all they could lay hands on; nothing was spared, not even the tombs of the emperors inside the St Apostles church. The civilian population of Constantinople were subject to the Crusaders' ruthless lust for spoils and glory; thousands of them were killed in cold blood. Women, even nuns, were raped by the Crusader army, which also sacked churches, monasteries and convents. The very altars of these churches were smashed and torn to pieces for their gold and marble by the warriors who had sworn to fight in service of the Pope without question.
Originally posted by Pope John Paul II"It is tragic that the assailants, who set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret."Pretty ****ed up even for you to be trying to defend an outrage which involved thousands of senseless murders and the mass rapes of countless women including nuns.Originally posted by Pope John Paul II"How can we not share, at a distance of eight centuries, the pain and disgust?"
Leave a comment:
-
You mean Emperor Alexios III Angelos? You might want to read up on him a bit before blaming the Catholics for the destruction of the Empire. The Latin Crusaders had only 20k men. Isaac II Angelos had just cause against his brother. None of the Angelos were porphyrogennetos.The Catholics? Yes good point, it most certainly was the Catholics who stabbed their fellow Christians in the back and after an ogry of bloodletting and theft in Constantinople left the city so weakened that the Ottomans were able to finally conquer it. Glad to see you supporting some actual history for once.
Then you have the massacre of the Latins in 1182. 80k killed by Andronikos Komnenos.
Anyway you slice it the Venetians and the Latins had a casus belli.Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 17, 2016, 17:37.
Leave a comment:
-
It's a lot more Christian the England.Originally posted by kentonio View PostAh yes, the Barbary States. Particularly relevant to you I imagine because of the Treaty of Tripoli which once and for all proved that 'the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion'.
Leave a comment:
-
Ah yes, the Barbary States. Particularly relevant to you I imagine because of the Treaty of Tripoli which once and for all proved that 'the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion'.Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
Leave a comment:
-
No. It doesn't surprise me that you don't get the point. Hint: The Muslim conquests of Western Africa and Asia aren't included either.Originally posted by giblets View PostIf we're going to count the Ottoman Empire as "jihad" shouldn't we count all of the Christian empires that conquered the Aztecs, Incas, India, etc. as "crusades"?
Leave a comment:
-
The Catholics? Yes good point, it most certainly was the Catholics who stabbed their fellow Christians in the back and after an ogry of bloodletting and theft in Constantinople left the city so weakened that the Ottomans were able to finally conquer it. Glad to see you supporting some actual history for once.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostDid you miss the part where they rolled over Constantinople, the same place that Islam tried to conquer for 700 years!
Leave a comment:
-
Well, I'm not surprised you didn't list them.i'm not surprised you didn't spot the errors.
Leave a comment:
-
Did you miss the part where they rolled over Constantinople, the same place that Islam tried to conquer for 700 years!If we're going to count the Ottoman Empire as "jihad" shouldn't we count all of the Christian empires that conquered the Aztecs, Incas, India, etc. as "crusades"?
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: