Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post
    Actually taxing them was the very thing that saved them from going to wars (except for those that wanted to do that and converted)
    The koran forbids "unbelievers" to fight.

    So the drafts of the ottoman empire concerned only muslims. Christians payed taxes and avoided going all together

    (and many times managed not to pay a single dime in taxes or they chased the sultan's army away or simply moved all their livehoods to the mountains)
    So instead of killing other Christians they only had to pay the tax. The truth is most people converted. Stop justifying that.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    You also don't know that during the early stages of the ottoman empire the (still in dark ages western europe) thought of it as a supreme way of governing. There was palpable admiration.
    It became " the ill man of europe" after it started to decay (1600~).

    The real violent things started when christian nation states adopted the western idea of nationality (and the turks did too subsequently)

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    The koran says to make war against them and enslave them.
    Don't know about that. I'm saying what the koran says about "unbelievers" who lived under muslim rule

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Actually taxing them was the very thing that saved them from going to wars (except for those that wanted to do that and converted)
    The koran forbids "unbelievers" to fight.

    So the drafts of the ottoman empire concerned only muslims. Christians payed taxes and avoided going all together

    (and many times managed not to pay a single dime in taxes or they chased the sultan's army away or simply moved all their livehoods to the mountains)

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post
    they chopped them up like lampchops.

    I'm not saying that christians or jews had it sooo much better under muslims. There were many wrongs and many many regressive things when western europe was finally getting out of the dark ages (which led to the revolution that burried the ottoman empire) - I'm just saying that they were respected because the koran said they should be

    x - post
    The koran says to make war against them and enslave them.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
    I´d call the reconquista of the iberian peninsula "retaking Christian lands".
    The crusades against the Levant (and subsequent formation of the crusader states) however I cannot put under this label.
    The levant and the northern african lands had only been for a relatively short time under the control of the christianized roman empire ... most of the time (after the pagan roman empire broke down) those lands were under the control of non christian rulers (like the Sassanids) ... therefore the christians had not more rights on these lands than the muslims had
    Considering that Jerusalem, Antioch and Alexandria are all very important to Christians and the Muslim rulers weren't completely removed on the Iberian Peninsula I find it unreasonable to blame the Christians for conquering Muslims lands. If the Muslim rulers were tolerant of Christians I could see your point, but they were not. Taxing people because of their religion is not tolerance.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    I could be wrong, but I believe that Christians were pretty tolerant of Jews until the Muslim invasions. Invading other lands is not respecting other religions. That's bull**** you only here from Muslims and liberals.
    The jews in european countries were actually pretty oppressed ...
    they were limited to certaion districts in the cities and also weren´t allowed to take most jobs.
    Which actually is the reason why so many jews became great geld lenders / bankers ... as thi9s was one of the few jobs they were allowed to do (and a job the christians actually couldn´t do, because they were disallowed from doing so by the rules of the catholic church)

    Their situation worsened however during the crusades, as many of the crusaders formed mobs in europe and, as their first atrocities, even before leaving christian europe, targeted the jewish districts in christian european cities

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    they chopped them up like lampchops.

    I'm not saying that christians or jews had it sooo much better under muslims. There were many wrongs and many many regressive things when western europe was finally getting out of the dark ages (which led to the revolution that burried the ottoman empire) - I'm just saying that they were respected because the koran said they should be

    x - post

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    But retaking Christian lands from invaders who are oppressing Christians? That's not conquering people.
    ...
    I´d call the reconquista of the iberian peninsula "retaking Christian lands".
    The crusades against the Levant (and subsequent formation of the crusader states) however I cannot put under this label.
    The levant and the northern african lands had only been for a relatively short time under the control of the christianized roman empire ... most of the time (after the pagan roman empire broke down) those lands were under the control of non christian rulers (like the Sassanids) ... therefore the christians had not more rights on these lands than the muslims had

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post
    The muslims were more religion free than medieval europe because the koran told them to respect all religions that were in the koran (that included christians and jews but not really anyone else, so the rest were a bit screwed)
    I could be wrong, but I believe that Christians were pretty tolerant of Jews until the Muslim invasions. Invading other lands is not respecting other religions. That's bull**** you only here from Muslims and liberals.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by rah View Post
    Not every muslim scholar believes that.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
    Noone claims that they forced to people to convert because of the crusades.

    What I wanted to say is that christians weren´t better than muslims with regards to conquest ... and in contrast to muslims, christians often didn´t just demand additional taxes from infidels they conquered, but rather gave them only the choice to convert, or be put to the sword (just remember the colonization of america ... but also the christianization of europe often was done via the sword (for example the northern crusades))
    But retaking Christian lands from invaders who are oppressing Christians? That's not conquering people.

    Yes, Christians have don't horrible things for money and racism though.

    Leave a comment:


  • rah
    replied
    It was created to get them to kill unbelievers.
    Not every muslim scholar believes that. And Christianity has it's fair share of blood on it's hands also.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    The muslims were more religion free than medieval europe because the koran told them to respect all religions that were in the koran (that included christians and jews but not really anyone else, so the rest were a bit screwed)

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by rah View Post
    So what. Most religions were created to control the peons or just to have control. It's what they evolve into that's important. I'll agree that some of the evolution is not good, but not all muslims are like that. And I refuse to condemn a millions of peaceful muslims because of a subset. Just like I refuse to condemn millions of christians because of a subset.
    So much wrong with that. Probably the biggest thing is that Islam wasn't just created to oppress the peons. It was created to get them to kill unbelievers.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X