Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    I'm afraid you're offering tid bits of information, useful on a trivia pursuit game, and then expect me somehow to expand them and cover the whole with them?

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    And yes, of course the Muslims played their part in the birth of modern Europe. It started far sooner than most people appreciate; the turn-of-the-millennium Pope Sylvester II was educated in Muslim Spain. But all that is completely irrelevant to my argument. You seem to be assuming that, because I have expressed distaste for Islam in the past, I must be trying to pin everything on them now. And then not reading what I say, which is somewhat frustrating.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    most of the population in southern spain were muslim until at least the 15th century. the muslims, together with the jews, were then forced to convert or expelled in the late 15th and early 16th centuries.
    Not unless by 'Southern Spain', you mean Granada.

    And the Christians of Southern spain were forced to convert in the mid 7th century. But I guess they don't matter.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    1. The medieval civilization was largely based on ancient Greek ideas, if it comes to that. So much that half the work of the Enlightenment was demolishing Scholasticism, the Church's muddled synthesis of various pagan thinkers with Christianity. Galileo died under house arrest for contradicting Aristotle and Ptolemy, not the Bible. Well, and for insulting the Pope in print.

    2. What? The Enlightenment was largely a northern European phenomenon; Spain and Italy remained overpoweringly Catholic for some time. Are you thinking of the Renaissance? It sounds like it.

    3. No, WAR had to be far away, not Muslims. Or rather, persistent external threats (I specifically enumerated Vikings, Lombards, and Magyars, but cf. Huns, Vandals, Alans, Avars, Saxons, Goths, Franks, Jutes, etc., who in various times and places were pushed away or else gradually assimilated only to be invaded by someone else). This is simplifying a bit, of course, but generally I'm appealing to the Civ-player truism that you don't get much research done during wartime. Especially not when you're losing.

    1. What?!

    I'm sure medieval europe was all about democracies, indivinduality and using reason as a tool for reaching a course of action. Right...

    2. erm, how exactly was northern europe even remotely involved in either the birth of renesscance or the enlighment?


    3. Fine. War. Not muslims. I'm afraid scientific progress doesn't really happen like in a game of civ. I'm sorry to break it to you, but for example the biggest advances in science (or societal engineering) were done during war, exactly because there was a need.

    The constant strife gives birth to all sort of things. After all it's common knowledge that some parts of europe managed to rape the entire planet simply because they had so much practise between themselves, for centuries

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post
    Elok,
    you have made the assumption that it was some degree of peace and stability in europe which allowed for the manifestation of the englightment. You also tried to paint muslims as some sort of "evil" which had to be far away for europe to clear itself free from the christian fundamentalist yoke.

    I present you two facts that say the opposite and put muslims in the core of the englightment debate:

    1. Englightment was heavily based on ancient greek ideals. Everyone knows that. You too, I'd assume.
    There would be no such tranfer of knowledge without the arabs. Those kept copies and saved the ancient scriptures. Not medieval europe.

    Thank the arabs, everyday, for the enlighment. Or don't. I don't think you're a proponent.

    2. The englighhment started on the borders of "War with the mooslims" namely on the city states of italy. A concrete push were also byzantine scholars who fled en mass to venice.

    War and the muslims, created the englightment.
    On the borders, during war and thanks to them.
    The Enlightenment produced the French Revolution. Why are you glorifying it? Do you believe in Enlightenment philosophies?

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    1. The medieval civilization was largely based on ancient Greek ideas, if it comes to that. So much that half the work of the Enlightenment was demolishing Scholasticism, the Church's muddled synthesis of various pagan thinkers with Christianity. Galileo died under house arrest for contradicting Aristotle and Ptolemy, not the Bible. Well, and for insulting the Pope in print.

    2. What? The Enlightenment was largely a northern European phenomenon; Spain and Italy remained overpoweringly Catholic for some time. Are you thinking of the Renaissance? It sounds like it.

    3. No, WAR had to be far away, not Muslims. Or rather, persistent external threats (I specifically enumerated Vikings, Lombards, and Magyars, but cf. Huns, Vandals, Alans, Avars, Saxons, Goths, Franks, Jutes, etc., who in various times and places were pushed away or else gradually assimilated only to be invaded by someone else). This is simplifying a bit, of course, but generally I'm appealing to the Civ-player truism that you don't get much research done during wartime. Especially not when you're losing.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Elok,
    you have made the assumption that it was some degree of peace and stability in europe which allowed for the manifestation of the englightment. You also tried to paint muslims as some sort of "evil" which had to be far away for europe to clear itself free from the christian fundamentalist yoke.

    I present you two facts that say the opposite and put muslims in the core of the englightment debate:

    1. Englightment was heavily based on ancient greek ideals. Everyone knows that. You too, I'd assume.
    There would be no such tranfer of knowledge without the arabs. Those kept copies and saved the ancient scriptures. Not medieval europe.

    Thank the arabs, everyday, for the enlighment. Or don't. I don't think you're a proponent.

    2. The englighhment started on the borders of "War with the mooslims" namely on the city states of italy. A concrete push were also byzantine scholars who fled en mass to venice.

    War and the muslims, created the englightment.
    On the borders, during war and thanks to them.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    BE: You have heard of a necessary but not sufficient condition? A basic level of peace and stability (not total, but not a war every five years) is a NBNSC for real social advancement. So, no, the absence of Turks didn't "cause" the Enlightenment, that was two hundred years in coming after the Reformation--but Europe was able to shake off the last vestiges of Medieval power structures in part because the incessant external threats and instability which brought them into being had largely ceased. Of course there were other factors, including the growing (massive) centralization of state power.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post
    You telling complete lies about history is irrelevant? Well yes, if you have no interest in honesty then I guess it would be.
    Where did I say Ottoman's didn't have European allies ? Who is lying?

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post

    My second cousin who is 17 posted something on facebook about Americans being the real terrorists. I was obviously disturbed so I gave him some education. My sister, who is liberal, and even more insane than Patty Cakes, got onto me about trying to brainwash him or whatever.
    i'm not surprised your family thinks you're full of **** as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    Totally irrelevant.
    You telling complete lies about history is irrelevant? Well yes, if you have no interest in honesty then I guess it would be.

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    most of the population in southern spain were muslim until at least the 15th century. the muslims, together with the jews, were then forced to convert or expelled in the late 15th and early 16th centuries.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dinner
    replied
    Originally posted by giblets View Post
    In 1492 Granada had been controlled by Muslims for over 700 years. How long do you have to control something before it stops being "Christian land"?
    What you ignore is that most of the population in those areas remained Christian despite having rulers who were muslim.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post
    Please don't talk utter bollocks all the time. You know that for long periods various Christian nations in Europe allied with the Ottomans against other Christian nations right? Trying to take Europe in the 20th century? That's Ben Kenobi levels of ridiculous, nonsensical revised history bull****.

    Please either read a book or shut the **** up.
    Totally irrelevant.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied


    My second cousin who is 17 posted something on facebook about Americans being the real terrorists. I was obviously disturbed so I gave him some education. My sister, who is liberal, and even more insane than Patty Cakes, got onto me about trying to brainwash him or whatever.

    How could he fall for Islamic propaganda like that? Because of the school system. The conquest of the Americas is treated as an evil deed comparable only to the Holocaust, while the brutal Muslim conquests are treated as glory for brown people and their Muslim God.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X