Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    It wasn't the Christians who declared war on them.



    The Muslims declared war on Israel. They lost. Too bad, so sad. Israel after the partition of the British Mandate did allocate half the land to the Palestinians. They, (and Egypt and Syria) decided they wanted all the land not just half. They declared war on Israel and lost.

    Right of defensive conquest is not a bad thing, and this is the same here. It wasn't that the Christians declared war on Islam, rather Islam had declared war on them.



    Given that the Jewish kingdom predated the Arab conquest of 600 AD, I cannot see how one can argue that they had more of a right to the land than the Jews. Also, Israel has way more people now than they had during the Ottoman period.
    And this is, obviously, because you equate the ordinary people living within a territory with the state they are living in ...
    and make no distinction between an ordinary farmer who just lives within the territory because he was born and raised there and someone who actively is involved in the matters of the state he lives in, for example as a warrior or someone of the ruling political party.

    Which, in my eyes, is a black-white view of the world, that modern 21st century humans should try to get rid of

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Since you punks have already responded to BK, I suppose there's no further harm done in pointing out what I've read from multiple books on Spanish history: that, after the expulsion of the moriscos (not necessarily because of it), Spain was agriculturally and economically retarded for centuries. Enormous swathes of land owned by monasteries or absentee noble landlords would just lie fallow, even in times of famine. There was also a prevailing culture that glorified indolence or even banditry--a legacy of the Reconquista--and what agriculture did exist tended to focus on pastures and raising sheep for wool at the expense of more efficient cereal crops. IIRC the wool merchants even had special privileges granted by the Crown to protect them. And the endless flow of young people to the New World caused a labor shortage, even as loads of silver pouring back led to inflation but was mostly wasted on extravagance.

    The history of those centuries makes for depressing reading: "In this decade, things sucked in Spain. Geez, did things suck. We moderns really cannot comprehend the sheer degree of suckage going on. And in the next decade, they sucked worse. This guy tried to improve things, but they called him a Jew and drove him out of the country. In the following decade, new factors increased the amount of suck going on by roughly a third, as exports declined and the King created a new fashion of feeding silver directly to pigs so the feces strewing the streets would be more attractive . . ."

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    [aside] Why the fvck does Ben insist on quoting without the link to the original post every time? [/aside]
    Eh, force of habit. Easier to type "[quote]/[quote]" around the part I am quoting.

    Leave a comment:


  • ricketyclik
    replied
    [aside] Why the fvck does Ben insist on quoting without the link to the original post every time? [/aside]

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    My theory is that you're a racist, and think kicking farmers off their land is good as long as the farmers aren't white.
    There are plenty of African countries that have done well after taking control of their own future. Zimbabwe has not.

    Why? Well, geez. Perhaps I can attribute it to Robert Mugabe and his incompetent rule. But, I guess that's racist to criticize Mugabe for turning Zimbabwe into a ****hole.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Your theory is that Spain under the Catholic Monarchs was similar in economic production to Zimbabwe under Mugabe?
    My theory is that you're a racist who thinks kicking farmers off their land is good as long as the farmers aren't white.

    Was there a food production problem? No.
    In areas it decimated the local economy.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    In some areas with significant moorish populations, they did do a lot of farming. In other provinces they were such a tiny minority it made no difference. So yes, food production was trashed in some provinces when they were expelled.
    Except that's not what we see under the Catholic monarchs. Economic production as a whole (as well as the population), increased. I can totally see the theory you're advancing, but it doesn't bear any connection to the reality of a Spain that rather quickly became THE European superpower after the union of Castile and Aragon.

    Leave a comment:


  • ricketyclik
    replied
    Us and them.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Driving muslim farmers out of formerly conquered land they had in possession for centuries is just as wrong as driving the christian families out of that land during the initial conquest.
    It wasn't the Christians who declared war on them.

    There actually is an equivalent in nowadays world ... and that is the treatment of Palestinians by Israelis upon founding of the Israeli state.
    The Muslims declared war on Israel. They lost. Too bad, so sad. Israel after the partition of the British Mandate did allocate half the land to the Palestinians. They, (and Egypt and Syria) decided they wanted all the land not just half. They declared war on Israel and lost.

    Right of defensive conquest is not a bad thing, and this is the same here. It wasn't that the Christians declared war on Islam, rather Islam had declared war on them.

    The many palestinians that were driven out by the Israelis (or fled and were prevented to return) lived on their soil for countless centuries and surely had more right to this soil (or at least a proper compensation) than the israelis that the soil was subsequently given to, after annexing it
    Given that the Jewish kingdom predated the Arab conquest of 600 AD, I cannot see how one can argue that they had more of a right to the land than the Jews. Also, Israel has way more people now than they had during the Ottoman period.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    which must have been difficult to foresee for the original conquerors
    Eh, they needed taxes and they needed slaves, and once stopped they couldn't get enough from the Christians to sustain their state. So they decided, why not take them from the Berbers?

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    And we're just supposed to ignore the Christians who had their land taken away?
    One wrong doesn´t correct another wrong ... especially a christian should be aware of that

    Driving muslim farmers out of formerly conquered land they had in possession for centuries is just as wrong as driving the christian families out of that land during the initial conquest.

    There actually is an equivalent in nowadays world ... and that is the treatment of Palestinians by Israelis upon founding of the Israeli state.
    The many palestinians that were driven out by the Israelis (or fled and were prevented to return) lived on their soil for countless centuries and surely had more right to this soil (or at least a proper compensation) than the israelis that the soil was subsequently given to, after annexing it

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    They definitely could have ... the army that was defeated by Karl Martell at Tours (which aimed at raiding Tours, deep within the heart of nowadays France) was far stronger than anything the Visigoth kingdom in southern france could muster. And even Karl Martells army was numerically inferior to the muslim one and he was only able to defeat them because his troops had undergone long training in the years before and were disciplined/trained enough, to use Phalanx tactics (which were extremly useful against the heavy cavalry of the muslims)
    Yep. Professional army, supply lines, and forcing the Muslims to choose the battlefield they had prepared. Negated their prime cavalry advantage.

    However, the thing that saved Asturias was the massive Maghreb revolt. The Arabic muslims decided to inflict the Jizya on non-Arab muslim converts, as well as enslaving them and they revolted. They very nearly took over Carthage and kicked out the Arabs. The only way the arabs were able to save themselves is by drawing on most of their garrison in Spain, and by drawing on Syrian recruits. Even then, they were outnumbered against the Berbers and it was a close shave.

    Had they lost in Carthage, they would have lost everything in Spain in a generation, and there was nothing they could do about it. They couldn't supply Spain from Egypt.

    After that, they just weren't the same and were always on the defensive. They never regained most of North Africa. Asturias expanded south and the Reconquista began.

    Arabs had the habit of posting Berbers as the front line throughout all their battles in Spain, and saving the core of their Arab troops as a reserve.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I'm sure Ben understands that farmers being kicked off their farms is going to hurt agricultural production. It's just his hatred for non-whites clouding his judgement. If you say "Zimbabwe" he'll quickly realize how detrimental to the economy it is to kick farmers off their farms. Until you start talking about non-white farmers again of course.
    Your theory is that Spain under the Catholic Monarchs was similar in economic production to Zimbabwe under Mugabe?

    Umm, no. Just no. Spain did very well under the Catholic monarchs, it was probably their economic peak between then and most of the 17th century.

    Was there a food production problem? No. Because the Christians who settled there knew how to farm. They did that in pretty much every area of Spain. It was their land, Aeson. That is why it is the RE conquista.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    But muslims had lived in Spain for many generations, particularly in the south which first to be conquered and last to be reconquered. That would be about 700 years equating to very roughly 28 generations, or more. I reckon after 28 generations your family has long since become native.
    And we're just supposed to ignore the Christians who had their land taken away?

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    The peculiar thing about Spain is that the previous regime was not completely extirpated by the Muslims, only shoved up into some northern mountains and then ignored. A fatal mistake in the long run; if they'd treated the Christians there the way they'd treated the ones in North Africa, Spain would have been considered a permanent part of "the Muslim world" instead of contested ground for seven centuries. Albeit the neighboring Christians might have driven them out anyways, once they got powerful enough. The Umayyads were rather vulnerable out there so far from the core of Muslim civilization.
    They definitely could have ... the army that was defeated by Karl Martell at Tours (which aimed at raiding Tours, deep within the heart of nowadays France) was far stronger than anything the Visigoth kingdom in southern france could muster. And even Karl Martells army was numerically inferior to the muslim one and he was only able to defeat them because his troops had undergone long training in the years before and were disciplined/trained enough, to use Phalanx tactics (which were extremly useful against the heavy cavalry of the muslims)

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X