that map is rather inaccurate in terms of both territory and time. the historical analysis is as terrible as one might expect.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
If we're going to count the Ottoman Empire as "jihad" shouldn't we count all of the Christian empires that conquered the Aztecs, Incas, India, etc. as "crusades"?
Leave a comment:
-
-
Given that it was a sex joke.Well to be fair, you didn't blow up at someone in a quite spectacular fashion. I'd say it was high praise.
Leave a comment:
-
And only really kicked into high gear after Muslim Spain was dead, IIRC.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by Elok View PostThis sharply contradicts most of what I've read (that their economy was built on international commerce and sundry commodities, and slave raids on the infidels, while profitable, were more of a prestige thing); may I ask where you read this?http://www.encyclopedia.com/topic/Barbary_States.aspxThe booty, ransom, and slaves that resulted from attacks on Mediterranean towns and shipping and from occasional forays into the Atlantic became the main source of revenue for local Muslim rulers.
Leave a comment:
-
Now, the Visigoths were supposed to be heavily involved in the slave trade--but Visigothic Spain was a ****hole.
Leave a comment:
-
yeah, you can't base an economy, at least of a civilised place, on slave raiding. they were wealthy because they had a money based economy, meaning that more resources could be concentrated centrally, and because they had well organised and productive agriculture and industry. i have a friend who owns a smallholding in northern portugal and the people there are still using irrigation channels cut into the hills by the muslims over a 1000 years ago.
Leave a comment:
-
This sharply contradicts most of what I've read (that their economy was built on international commerce and sundry commodities, and slave raids on the infidels, while profitable, were more of a prestige thing); may I ask where you read this?Originally posted by Dinner View PostI read that a lot of their economy was based upon the slave trade and that yearly raids for slaves in Europe (they even had an outpost on the French Italian border for a while) was a big part of their economy. After Europeans became strong enough to end those raids their economy went into steep decline.
Leave a comment:
-
I read that a lot of their economy was based upon the slave trade and that yearly raids for slaves in Europe (they even had an outpost on the French Italian border for a while) was a big part of their economy. After Europeans became strong enough to end those raids their economy went into steep decline.Originally posted by C0ckney View Postyes, but it's fairly understandable. why spend months fighting in the endless mountains and forests of galicia and asturias when the rich lands of southern france are there for the plundering. also, the muslims only became vulnerable when their state broke up into several petty kingdoms, which must have been difficult to foresee for the original conquerors. plus of course, the christian kingdoms played their hand well, with just the right combination of obsequiousness and stiff resistance that allowed them to survive.Last edited by Dinner; January 16, 2016, 00:11.
Leave a comment:
-
Damning with faint praise I see.I think the answer to the question ken asked is, "Longer than Sava."
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: