Originally posted by Kidicious
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
It's a little rich to whine about the Muslims taking Constantinople, when the only reason they were able to is because the Catholics sacked the place and left Byzantium a faded wreck that never recovered properly.Originally posted by Kidicious View PostIsn't it amazing how kentonio is so outraged when Catholics kill Orthodox Christians, but doesn't care at all when Muslims do the same thing?
Leave a comment:
-
I very much enjoy the way that despite the actual figure being at most probably 60,000, you started at 80,000 and have now reached 'nearly 100,000'. I'm sure by this afternoon we'll be listening to you whine about the tens of millions of innocent Catholics slaughtered.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd? Point is made that there were nearly a hundred thousand Catholics slaughtered just for the crime of 'being Catholic'. Nobody here seems to give a damn.
Leave a comment:
-
I understand why you wouldn't want people to believe the truth.Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View PostBTW that video was a piece of ****. Totally unaccurate. Might as well be about the marsian invasions
Leave a comment:
-
BTW that video was a piece of ****. Totally unaccurate. Might as well be about the marsian invasions
Leave a comment:
-
Excellent.
After cheering for people being thrown out of helicopters, Ben cheerleads the murder and rape of innocent people.
I haven't seen anyone more.... "christian"
Leave a comment:
-
So when your chosen Pope Innocent III damns the rape and murder you're trying to justify, you just dump him and run?Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd? Point is made that there were nearly a hundred thousand Catholics slaughtered just for the crime of 'being Catholic'. Nobody here seems to give a damn.
You're trying to justify the Sack of Constantinople. So of course people are going to point out that the Sack of Constantinople was horrific, and that you're trying to justify mass rape and murder.
If you or someone else were to try to justify the rape and murder of Catholics, they'd get the same treatment. But no one is doing so, which is why no one is getting berated for doing that thing which no one is doing.
Leave a comment:
-
If you watched the video, you'd notice that they updated the colors every fifty years. But then that would require actually examining the source.apparently the turks didn't cross the bosporus nor take constantinople until 1500.
One down.
Not sure what you're watching, but the borders expand.no muslim conquest of sicily, byzantine attempts to the retake it and the subsequent conquest by the normans (a fascinating conflict all round), together with that of malta. cyprus and crete are never taken.
Which lasted about 40 years, during the devastating Seljuk invasion.nothing about the conquests of georgia and its subsequent emergence as an independent christian kingdom.
Again, your issues seem to be that you don't understand what the source is showing. The source is making the decision to show conquests that are kept and held for longer than 50 years rather than those which flow back and forth.according to the video, the crusaders didn't set up any states in the middle east, the whole of which stays green on the map throughout it; and while we're on the subject, where is lesser armenia? spain and portugal are just completely wrong, as is india, and don't get me started on africa. there are a lot crusader battles missing, among the most important being constantinople and nicopolis.
The source brutally exposes your 'argument' about the crusades which is why you're nitpicking here.there are plenty of other problems besides, which you'd know about if you weren't the worst history teacher on planet earth
Anybody who watches it is struck by how Islam expands and that Christianity really hasn't recovered much of anything that was taken. But, that's inconvenient history.Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 18, 2016, 03:02.
Leave a comment:
-
And? Point is made that there were nearly a hundred thousand Catholics slaughtered just for the crime of 'being Catholic'. Nobody here seems to give a damn.Sized: author has been lucky to never meet BK.
Leave a comment:
-
We call it selective outrage.Isn't it amazing how kentonio is so outraged when Catholics kill Orthodox Christians, but doesn't care at all when Muslims do the same thing?
Leave a comment:
-
You mean this?Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostIt is easy with the gaze of the 21st century to condemn the actions of 12th century Catholics. Personally, I would rather quote Innocent III who was there.
Bold: "BK is a moron" - Innocent IIIOne would be hard-pressed to find a Catholic historian (or any Catholic who learns the details) who would defend what took place in this abominable, reprehensible catastrophe. Warren Carroll, one of the best orthodox Catholic historians of our time, candidly admits in his major series of volumes, A History of Christendom:
The sack that followed was one of the worst in all of history. . . No man, woman or child was safe from the ravagers. Robbery and rape were almost universal, mindless destruction widespread. Westerners . . . killed indiscriminately, without mercy or restraint . . . For this to have been done by crusaders - men actually wearing the Cross of Christ - was an ineffaceable disgrace . . . The Greeks never forgot the sack of Constantinople in 1204; its memory, more than anything else, has prevented the healing of the Greek schism from that day to this, despite several major efforts at reunion.
{The Glory of Christendom, Front Royal, VA: Christendom Press, 1993, p. 157-158}
So the first thing to be noted is that this horrific event is morally indefensible, and that Catholics know and accept this. Secondly, and most importantly, the pope at the time, Pope Innocent III, neither knew about nor sanctioned in the least this massacre and sacrilegious pillage. In fact, he had forbidden the Crusaders, on pain of excommunication, to attack Byzantium, instructing the leader, Boniface of Montferrat, that: «The crusade must not attack Christians, but should proceed as quickly as possible to the Holy Land.» He only found out the full horror of what had happened more than eight months later, and wrote to Cardinal Peter Capuano, denouncing the sack in no uncertain terms:
These «soldiers of Christ» who should have turned their swords against the infidel have steeped them in Christian blood, sparing neither religion, nor age, nor sex... They stripped the altars of silver, violated the sanctuaries, robbed icons and crosses and relics... The Latins have given example only of perversity and works of darkness. No wonder the Greeks call them dogs!»
{cited in Carroll, ibid., p. 158; from Mann, Popes of the Middle Ages, vol. 12, pp. 266-267}
Sized: author has been lucky to never meet BK.
Leave a comment:
-
Isn't it amazing how kentonio is so outraged when Catholics kill Orthodox Christians, but doesn't care at all when Muslims do the same thing?
Leave a comment:
-
You fascist fuck, they slaughtered thousands of innocent people, raped nuns on the altars of churches and tore apart religious and cultural sites that had stood for centuries, until the streets ran deep in blood. Even the heads of your own religion say it was a terrible act, but you have to try and play the role of apologist for rapists and murderers. You're a disgusting little prick and we're done here.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostIt is easy with the gaze of the 21st century to condemn the actions of 12th century Catholics. Personally, I would rather quote Innocent III who was there. But that doesn't serve your narrative that the culpability was on the Catholics who had a rather restrained response.
Leave a comment:
-
apparently the turks didn't cross the bosporus nor take constantinople until 1500. no muslim conquest of sicily, byzantine attempts to the retake it and the subsequent conquest by the normans (a fascinating conflict all round), together with that of malta. cyprus and crete are never taken. nothing about the conquests of georgia and its subsequent emergence as an independent christian kingdom. according to the video, the crusaders didn't set up any states in the middle east, the whole of which stays green on the map throughout it; and while we're on the subject, where is lesser armenia? spain and portugal are just completely wrong, as is india, and don't get me started on africa. there are a lot crusader battles missing, among the most important being constantinople and nicopolis.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostWell, I'm not surprised you didn't list them.
there are plenty of other problems besides, which you'd know about if you weren't the worst history teacher on planet earth.Last edited by C0ckney; January 17, 2016, 23:02.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: