I'm not Kidicious. I'm born again. And even though I am born again the sinful nature sometimes makes me do that which I do not want to do. So, my body deteriorates and dies, and I do that which I do not want to do. Do you really want to compare me to the Catholic Church?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
Well then, I don't see why you hold a position for which you have no evidence to support.I don´t see how I would need to cite anything for this.
Leave a comment:
-
Your argument rests on the fault premise that the early Christians did not have bishops. St. Clement of Rome lived during the apostolic era. Given that everyone argues that the Apostles lead the early church, that doesn't leave any wiggle room here.Therefore beliefs that Christians hold today can not be true if they contradict the beliefs of the early church unless you want to claim that the early church did not believe correctly.
Because they were created by God.How could gentiles ever be Christians then?
Leave a comment:
-
Btw. ... those early catholics surely loved their love-feasts ... you could get declared anathema, if you refused an invitation to them
Canon 11, Council of Gangra (340 AD)
If anyone shall despise those who out of faith make love-feasts and invite the brethren in honour of the Lord, and is not willing to accept these invitations because he despises what is done, let him be anathema.
Leave a comment:
-
I don´t see how I would need to cite anything for this.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostGot any evidence to support this position? I cited evidence for my position of continuity.
The christian faith is built around the belief that Jesus is god himself.
That Jesus therefore for a christian should be the highest authority ... far higher than any priest that came after him stands out of question ...
and that therefore anything that twists the words of Jesus arouind (or falsely interprets them) detracts from the christian religion for me also doesn´t need any explanation.
(also if books get chosen to be left out of the bible for wrong reasons (for example if they actually contain teachings of Jesus, but get left out, because their teachings don´t fit the line the church wants to proceed ... or if books get put into the bible (despite doubts of their veracity) because they support certain opinions by church fathers)
For example the first council of Nicaea, which had the Trinity doctrine on its Agenda and declared Arianism to heterodox, becxause they had a different belief about this.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd which synods were these and when did they occur, and what did they teach?
Leave a comment:
-
Shouldn't your time be spent more productively like speculating about star wars?
Seems to make as much sense and it's also a nice hobby
Leave a comment:
-
I'm not Kidicious. I'm born again. And even though I am born again the sinful nature sometimes makes me do that which I do not want to do. So, my body deteriorates and dies, and I do that which I do not want to do. Do you really want to compare me to the Catholic Church?Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostIndeed, you are a new man. And yet you are still Kidicious. That is my point. Yes, the Church does change in it's constituent parts, but the identity does not change. You have a soul that does not change, that has been given to you by God, while the Church has Christ as it's head.
Leave a comment:
-
If you mean that God does not call evil good, and good evil, then true. Then that which was good can never become evil. Therefore beliefs that Christians hold today can not be true if they contradict the beliefs of the early church unless you want to claim that the early church did not believe correctly.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd God does not contradict himself.
This is ridiculous. How could gentiles ever be Christians then?You understand your ndentity through genetics, which is simply the sum of your inheritance from your forefathers. If you don't understand your history you do not understand who you are.
Leave a comment:
-
Indeed, you are a new man. And yet you are still Kidicious. That is my point. Yes, the Church does change in it's constituent parts, but the identity does not change. You have a soul that does not change, that has been given to you by God, while the Church has Christ as it's head.But I'm not what I used to be. I have some health problems, and it's not going to get any better.
Leave a comment:
-
But I'm not what I used to be. I have some health problems, and it's not going to get any better.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd the cells of your bodies change, but you are still Kidicious.
Leave a comment:
-
And God does not contradict himself.The only way you can understand God's truth is by the Holy Spirit. You can't comprehend it because you aren't divine. Only the Holy Spirit can make you understand it. This is how the apostles understood God's truth.
Indeed it does.Your claim that your history tells you who you are is ridiculous.
You understand your ndentity through genetics, which is simply the sum of your inheritance from your forefathers. If you don't understand your history you do not understand who you are.If that were true we would all be dead, and as far as you think you can understand God's truth by looking at your history you are dead.
Leave a comment:
-
Got any evidence to support this position? I cited evidence for my position of continuity.Nope ... the earliest church surely is a group of jewish hippies, running around as appendage to this Jesus-guy.
We can answer definitively that by 90 AD that there were priests, bishops and deacons, then as now.What came after that ... i.e. whether the philosophy/religious ideas of Jesus are well represented by that, which became the catholic church ... or whether they got twisted by them for one reason or the other (after all, humans are fallible ... and the people that make up the catholic church are no less humans than anyone else) cannot be answered (by someone else than Doctor Who ... or some other person in possession of a time machine).
And which synods were these and when did they occur, and what did they teach?Perhaps some of the other early christian sects represented the original christian faith better ... but their ideas were rejected at the synodes in the eastern roman empire (for example for power political interests or because the followers of such ideas weren´t well liked among the members of the synodes)
Leave a comment:
-
And the cells of your bodies change, but you are still Kidicious.The catholic church has changed over the centuries and continues to change.
Leave a comment:
-
False. St. Clement spoke of it, saint and Pope.This is true. No one in the church spoke of a bishop being in the place of God until the beginning of the Catholic Church which was during the second century.
First century, direct quote from St. Clement of Rome. He goes on to say in his 1st Epistle...And we, too, being called by His will in Christ Jesus, are not justified by ourselves, nor by our own wisdom, or understanding, or godliness, or works which we have wrought in holiness of heart; but by that faith through which, from the beginning, Almighty God has justified all men; to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen.
Your argument is thusly, that the Church originated in the 1st century sometime around 90 AD.The apostles have preached the gospel to us from the Lord Jesus Christ; Jesus Christ [has done so] from God. Christ therefore was sent forth by God, and the apostles by Christ. Both these appointments, then, were made in an orderly way, according to the will of God. Having therefore received their orders, and being fully assured by the resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ, and established in the word of God, with full assurance of the Holy Ghost, they went forth proclaiming that the kingdom of God was at hand. And thus preaching through countries and cities, they appointed the first fruits [of their labours], having first proved them by the Spirit, to be bishops and deacons of those who should afterwards believe. Nor was this any new thing, since indeed many ages before it was written concerning bishops and deacons. For thus says the Scripture in a certain place, “I will appoint their bishops in righteousness, and their deacons in faith.”
In contrast, we have Justin the Martyr who is the first to cite the Apocalypse as a canonical book, in the middle of the second century.
Bishops, priests, deacons all predate the closure of the Canon.
Leave a comment:
-
This is true. No one in the church spoke of a bishop being in the place of God until the beginning of the Catholic Church which was during the second century.Originally posted by Proteus_MST View PostNope ... the earliest church surely is a group of jewish hippies, running around as appendage to this Jesus-guy.
What came after that ... i.e. whether the philosophy/religious ideas of Jesus are well represented by that, which became the catholic church ... or whether they got twisted by them for one reason or the other (after all, humans are fallible ... and the people that make up the catholic church are no less humans than anyone else) cannot be answered (by someone else than Doctor Who ... or some other person in possession of a time machine).
Perhaps some of the other early christian sects represented the original christian faith better ... but their ideas were rejected at the synodes in the eastern roman empire (for example for power political interests or because the followers of such ideas weren´t well liked among the members of the synodes)
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: