Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Well, his theory of the primacy of primary historical sources is still dominant today. We are taught exactly what he taught about the nature of source materials. Uh, probably the most enlightening would be the architectural digs in the Valley of the Kings. You might as well cite every historical discovery since 1875 as partially due to him.

    Empiricism? Absolutely, at least within the realm of natural sciences.

    If you're talking theologically, well that brings in folks like Aquinas. I'm not sure if there's really anything newer than Aquinas that has had a significant positive impact.

    Yes Hegel has quite a few followers. I'm not one of them. If you want to get technical, a modified dialectic works just fine if one understands it's limitations. But then, I guess my point is that if you modify the dialectic, then it's not really Hegel anymore. The platonic forms are more compelling, like I said, that man is discovering what was always there.
    None of that has anything to do with human consciousness, which is what we were talking about. I didn't mean to say that studying history is not beneficial to society. I wasn't arguing against scientific history. You said that I need to study history to 'know who I am.'

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    So what absolute truth do we know because of von Ranke?
    Well, his theory of the primacy of primary historical sources is still dominant today. We are taught exactly what he taught about the nature of source materials. Uh, probably the most enlightening would be the architectural digs in the Valley of the Kings. You might as well cite every historical discovery since 1875 as partially due to him.

    Empiricism? Absolutely, at least within the realm of natural sciences.

    If you're talking theologically, well that brings in folks like Aquinas. I'm not sure if there's really anything newer than Aquinas that has had a significant positive impact.

    Yes Hegel has quite a few followers. I'm not one of them. If you want to get technical, a modified dialectic works just fine if one understands it's limitations. But then, I guess my point is that if you modify the dialectic, then it's not really Hegel anymore. The platonic forms are more compelling, like I said, that man is discovering what was always there.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    I'm the wrong person to ask because of my philosophical tradition as a Neo-Platonist. For me, there hasn't really been a significant and compelling philosophy since von Ranke's empiricism as applied to History. Hegel has nothing significant, IMO.
    So what absolute truth do we know because of von Ranke?
    Empiricism of Bacon, Locke and Hobbes.
    Empiricism is an absolute truth? Are you sure about that?

    Empiricism: the theory that all knowledge is derived from sense-experience.

    Still sure about that?
    Because I study the history of philosophy and the history of science.
    Well so did Hegel. He was a pretty smart guy too. He also has a ****e load of followers.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Please explain to me how dialectical reasoning eliminates good ideas.
    In an example? Uh, I would go with mendelian inheritance. For 35 years it contributed nothing because the biology of the time did not understand it. Thankfully it was not lost. There are many such examples. Cavendish's discovery of thermodynamics, which was lost.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    You haven't answered the question. What good ideas do we have because of Hegel?
    I'm the wrong person to ask because of my philosophical tradition as a Neo-Platonist. For me, there hasn't really been a significant and compelling philosophy since von Ranke's empiricism as applied to History. Hegel has nothing significant, IMO.

    What good ideas are dominant today that are closer to absolute truth, or are absolute truth that people didn't have 2,000 years ago?
    Empiricism of Bacon, Locke and Hobbes.

    Also, how do you know which ideas that have run out of fashion to believe in because you have studied history?
    Because I study the history of philosophy and the history of science.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    My observations of science and the history of science seem to suggest that a balanced perspective is the correct approach. Whether it is 6 or 9 of 12, I do not know. But I do believe that we have already acquired universal truths.
    Please explain to me how dialectical reasoning eliminates good ideas.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    As a process of how ideas come about it is not a bad one, but it has it's limitations. Synthesis is not always more correct than the constituent parts. Sometimes truth changes are revolutionary, in which neither the thesis or it's antithesis is correct. Examples abound, probably the most recent is the advent of Quantum mechanics. Sometimes the truth is best not subsumed in the process, and we have to go back. Inquiry is not always directly progressive. Errors abound in correction and must be eradicated as well. Sometimes it is best to go to the older understanding, which the dialectic does not do well.
    You haven't answered the question. What good ideas do we have because of Hegel? What good ideas are dominant today that are closer to absolute truth, or are absolute truth that people didn't have 2,000 years ago?

    Also, how do you know which ideas that have run out of fashion to believe in because you have studied history?
    The biggest problem however is the materialist approach. I found Platonic forms to be far more compelling - the idea that there are no new ideas, but rather forms which have always existed. Insofar as the only thing which changes is our perception, not the ideas in and of themselves, and that the errors are found through our imperfect understanding of these forms. Hegel has a grindstone which polishes and shapes. This is more akin to wearing glasses.
    Ok, so you believe in Plato's philosophy and he lived a very long time ago. So what good is all of the history since then?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Why?
    My observations of science and the history of science seem to suggest that a balanced perspective is the correct approach. Whether it is 6 or 9 of 12, I do not know. But I do believe that we have already acquired universal truths.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Now all you have to do is tell me why that is so, because nothing that you've shown me makes that argument.
    Well, I don't really make that argument. I see history as an extension of empiricism in general and that in order to obtain reliable knowledge of the world around us, that it's a component of understanding and should be harmonious with the other components.

    I would argue that philosophy in general is the best way to obtain understanding of absolute truth, in the sense that it provides an operant method by which to obtain reliable knowledge. IE, it answers the question as to why we OUGHT to use empiricism and what is empiricism and how it works.

    Why should we use empiricism? Because it is reliable and in short, because it works. As for history, the best way to obtain reliable knowledge is through primary sources.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    How has Hegel's philosophy improved our understanding of the absolute truth?
    As a process of how ideas come about it is not a bad one, but it has it's limitations. Synthesis is not always more correct than the constituent parts. Sometimes truth changes are revolutionary, in which neither the thesis or it's antithesis is correct. Examples abound, probably the most recent is the advent of Quantum mechanics. Sometimes the truth is best not subsumed in the process, and we have to go back. Inquiry is not always directly progressive. Errors abound in correction and must be eradicated as well. Sometimes it is best to go to the older understanding, which the dialectic does not do well.

    The biggest problem however is the materialist approach. I found Platonic forms to be far more compelling - the idea that there are no new ideas, but rather forms which have always existed. Insofar as the only thing which changes is our perception, not the ideas in and of themselves, and that the errors are found through our imperfect understanding of these forms. Hegel has a grindstone which polishes and shapes. This is more akin to wearing glasses.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Ok, so he was opposed to Hegel's philosophy yet he still believed in studying history as the best method for knowing absolute truth. Now all you have to do is tell me why that is so, because nothing that you've shown me makes that argument.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    The problem is that if knowledge is fully progressive, we cannot be certain that if anything we know presently is true.
    Well of course not. You can't ever know if what you believe is an absolute truth without simply abandoning all objective reasoning and having complete faith in what you believe. You can't even know how close you are to the truth. So you've made a good point. However, you have to say that about all objective truth seeking.
    This is contrary to Objectivism which states that truth is absolute and attainable, ie, one can obtain absolute truth.
    Not through studying historical events. That is not Objectivism. According to Objectivism absolute truth is not determined by the way we understand history.
    Say I have 12 ideas. How the dialectic works, is that eventually, all 12 will be replaced. My view is that 6 would be replaced and 6 would remain.
    Why?
    I would argue that yes, 2000 years has brought us closer to the sum total of absolute truth, but also that there are some ideas which have not and will not change.
    Ok. How has Hegel's philosophy improved our understanding of the absolute truth?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    This doesn't tell me anything relevant. What does this have to do with his philosophy of history?
    Have a look-see here.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Short answer, Ranke is not a follower of Rousseau, but of Hobbes. He is a conservative German monarchist protestant. You might like him. He's a bit out of favor with me now, I found his history of the Catholic church was not that well done. There are better histories, and his is not bad if you have a can of white-out handy.
    This doesn't tell me anything relevant. What does this have to do with his philosophy of history?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    No. You are confusing the current state of progress with his absolute truth.
    The problem is that if knowledge is fully progressive, we cannot be certain that if anything we know presently is true. This is contrary to Objectivism which states that truth is absolute and attainable, ie, one can obtain absolute truth.

    Say I have 12 ideas. How the dialectic works, is that eventually, all 12 will be replaced. My view is that 6 would be replaced and 6 would remain.

    He believed that progress is leading us to the absolute truth. And that's the same way anyone believes that believes studying history objectively gives us absolute truth, because as time passes more data is accumulated. As time passes philosophers and theologians can think of concepts that more accurately represent absolute truth. But it doesn't work that way. A person in the first century can know the absolute truth to the same degree that a person living in this century can know the absolute truth. 2,000 years of history has not brought us to know the absolute truth more.
    I would argue that yes, 2000 years has brought us closer to the sum total of absolute truth, but also that there are some ideas which have not and will not change.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X