Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
    Exactly this ... theory doesn´t matter all too much, but rather the actual practice of faith ..
    No. Actual practice doesn't count, because Christians do not always follow the Bible. So you can blame Christians, but you can not blame the Bible or God.
    for example the islam doesn´t actually tell women to wear a full body covering ...
    nevertheless it is/was practiced in many countries like Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan and is enforced by religious guards.

    The Quran also doesn´t forbid women to drive cars ... but again this is enforced by religious guards.
    So this is religious reality for people living in those countries.
    But the Koran does say that women have to submit to men, and if they do not, for their husbands to beat them. So how are men sinning against the Koran by not letting women drive cars?
    Similarly for the christians in europe it was religious reality that the pope was the representative of god on earth ...
    similar to Moses in the old testament ... and therefore, who else than him (aside from god himself) would have the authority to star a religous war
    (and, as I mentioned, god in the old testament never was shy of ordering the israelites to have other tribes killed)

    Similarly it was religious reality for people of this time that Satan exists and that he corrupts women (and sometimes men) into becoming witches ... and that, if you burn them on a pyre, this is actually a nice thing to do to them, as it drives out Satan of their body and therefore the soul of the poor witch goes to heacven instead of the eternal fires of hell)
    But God does not give Christians any authority to do those things, not in the Bible. He gave the ancients that authority. There's a difference between twisting the Bible and what the Bible actually means.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ming View Post
    But it's the accepted doctrine of the church that launched the Crusades... so they were sanctioned and ordered by God.
    Exactly this ... theory doesn´t matter all too much, but rather the actual practice of faith ..
    for example the islam doesn´t actually tell women to wear a full body covering ...
    nevertheless it is/was practiced in many countries like Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan and is enforced by religious guards.

    The Quran also doesn´t forbid women to drive cars ... but again this is enforced by religious guards.
    So this is religious reality for people living in those countries.

    Similarly for the christians in europe it was religious reality that the pope was the representative of god on earth ...
    similar to Moses in the old testament ... and therefore, who else than him (aside from god himself) would have the authority to star a religous war
    (and, as I mentioned, god in the old testament never was shy of ordering the israelites to have other tribes killed)

    Similarly it was religious reality for people of this time that Satan exists and that he corrupts women (and sometimes men) into becoming witches ... and that, if you burn them on a pyre, this is actually a nice thing to do to them, as it drives out Satan of their body and therefore the soul of the poor witch goes to heacven instead of the eternal fires of hell)

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    You have not demonstrated that you are familiar with either the Bible or the Koran. Everyone who understands the Bible sees what a ignorant blow hard you are, but you just don't care.


    i think my irony meter just exploded.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post
    Neither of which actually matter. The point is that both the bible and the koran have been used for most of their existences as an excuse or pretext for war. You can try and make up some fluff about how the koran is evil and the bible isn't, but everyone here is familiar with the OT so its not like we don't know some of the nasty **** that's in there.
    You have not demonstrated that you are familiar with either the Bible or the Koran. Everyone who understands the Bible sees what a ignorant blow hard you are, but you just don't care.

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post
    You can try and make up some fluff about how the koran is evil and the bible isn't, but everyone here is familiar with the OT so its not like we don't know some of the nasty **** that's in there.
    everyone except kid, you mean.

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    You're ignoring two facts...

    1) Those verses were severely twisted. They don't, in anyway, mean that.
    2) The Christians had been attacked for 400 years before that and were taking a serious ass beating.
    Neither of which actually matter. The point is that both the bible and the koran have been used for most of their existences as an excuse or pretext for war. You can try and make up some fluff about how the koran is evil and the bible isn't, but everyone here is familiar with the OT so its not like we don't know some of the nasty **** that's in there.

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    That's because jihad is Muslims attacking non-Muslims you ****! I'm sorry if the definition of words is 'inconsisent' with your retarded leftist narrative.
    you seem to have avoided actually addressing the point. what a surprise.

    I did back them up. You haven't done anything to dispute my claims.
    no, you didn't. please stop lying.

    i see you have conceded the points. thanks for playing.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ming View Post
    But it's the accepted doctrine of the church that launched the Crusades... so they were sanctioned and ordered by God.
    I said The BIBLE does not give them that authority.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post
    You seem to be a little confused about how life works. You said the bible wasn't an inspiration for the crusades, I've linked you to some evidence that various passages were indeed used to justify the crusades. You then just saying "No. I am not wrong." isn't really that compelling an argument. Neither would another version of One True Scotsman be either FYI.
    You're ignoring two facts...

    1) Those verses were severely twisted. They don't, in anyway, mean that.
    2) The Christians had been attacked for 400 years before that and were taking a serious ass beating.

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    No. I am not wrong.
    You seem to be a little confused about how life works. You said the bible wasn't an inspiration for the crusades, I've linked you to some evidence that various passages were indeed used to justify the crusades. You then just saying "No. I am not wrong." isn't really that compelling an argument. Neither would another version of One True Scotsman be either FYI.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ming
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    Not in the Bible
    But it's the accepted doctrine of the church that launched the Crusades... so they were sanctioned and ordered by God.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ming View Post
    But what about Papal infallibility...
    Not in the Bible

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by C0ckney View Post
    rubbish; i've ridiculed your source.

    you've made some claims and need to back them up. that's how it works. if you won't then it's because you can't and i'll take it that you concede the points.
    I did back them up. You haven't done anything to dispute my claims. Evidently you have no idea how many battles there were and you are too stupid to learn.
    i think ricketyclik put it very well. but also, the point is that your definition seems to be that every time muslims attack non-muslims, it's jihad, a religiously motivated conquest, yet when non-muslims attack muslims, it's not religiously motivated. that seems very inconsistent.
    That's because jihad is Muslims attacking non-Muslims you ****! I'm sorry if the definition of words is 'inconsisent' with your retarded leftist narrative.

    that's what the guy says during the video so anyone who watched the video will have heard it. did you even watch the video you're failing so hard to defend?
    That's right. It did. It explains that that's not even all of the battles. The ball is clearly in your court. If you chose not to return I will consider this issue closed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ming
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    No. The Bible does not clearly give the Pope that authority. Show me that in the Bible.
    But what about Papal infallibility...

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
    The bible (Old Testament) is full of stories of the Israelites attacking infidels on the order of god (and slaughtering aöll of them, including their cattle).

    And at the time of the crusades the pope was seen as the representative of god by almost all of european christianity (except for a few tiny sects that usually were persecuted by the catholic church (like the Cathars, which would themselves become target of a crusade) and the orthodox church).

    So the bible clearly gives the church the ability to start religious wars because, which true medieval christian wouldn´t see the word of the pope to be as authoritative as if it would have been spoken by god himself (and therefore the crusades be equivalent to the wars of the israelites against the tribes of the holy land)
    No. The Bible does not clearly give the Pope that authority. Show me that in the Bible.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X