Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
It sure looks like a battle by battle account. Do you want to try and answer again? (The territorial changes don't mean anything)Originally posted by C0ckney View Posti mean that it's not a battle by battle account and furthermore that the territorial changes it shows are often incorrect.
If he can't be trusted then why don't you prove that he's lying, because that's your accusation. All of the battles are well documented and undisputed. So how many were there COckney? Don't you know?you are making the claim and therefore you need to prove it. i have explained why your source can't be trusted.
The Bible doesn't say anything about attacking Muslims or anyone else. Where do you think the Crusaders got the idea of Holy War? Hint: It wasn't the Bible.so every time christians attack muslims is a crusade?
It was jihad, but not relevant to the discussion.also, was the muslim conquest of persia, for example, not jihad. why not?
Leave a comment:
-
i mean that it's not a battle by battle account and furthermore that the territorial changes it shows are often incorrect.Originally posted by Kidicious View PostWhat do you mean it's not a battle by battle account?
you are making the claim and therefore you need to prove it. i have explained why your source can't be trusted.Why? Do you dispute his claim? Why? How many times did Muslims attack Christians during that period?
so every time christians attack muslims is a crusade?Let's just say Muslims attacking Christians.
also, was the muslim conquest of persia, for example, not jihad. why not?
Leave a comment:
-
Do you teach the little children this crap in Greece?Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Postwell I don't think muslims do jihads.
They are too civilized for that.
Probably christians do jihads.
Like in Cuba
Leave a comment:
-
What do you mean it's not a battle by battle account?Originally posted by C0ckney View Postno he doesn't. he claims that it's a battle by battle account; it plainly isn't. he also fails to accurately show how territory changes hands and gets whole large regions completely wrong.
Why? Do you dispute his claim? Why? How many times did Muslims attack Christians during that period?sure, but since you're making the claim, it's up to you to prove it.
Let's just say Muslims attacking Christians.you might also want to define jihad while you're at it.
Leave a comment:
-
well I don't think muslims do jihads.
They are too civilized for that.
Probably christians do jihads.
Like in Cuba
Leave a comment:
-
no he doesn't. he claims that it's a battle by battle account; it plainly isn't. he also fails to accurately show how territory changes hands and gets whole large regions completely wrong.
sure, but since you're making the claim, it's up to you to prove it. you might also want to define jihad while you're at it.There were about 550 battles of jihad over about a 900 year period. Can you dispute that?
Leave a comment:
-
He does a pretty good job of doing what he said he would do, which is show how wrong the commonly used narrative is. There were about 550 battles of jihad over about a 900 year period. Can you dispute that?Originally posted by C0ckney View Posthe fails to do what he sets out to do and makes a boatload of factual errors, whether through ignorance or dishonesty, and therefore any analysis or conclusions based on it can't be taken seriously.
Leave a comment:
-
he fails to do what he sets out to do and makes a boatload of factual errors, whether through ignorance or dishonesty, and therefore any analysis or conclusions based on it can't be taken seriously.
Leave a comment:
-
The point that the person who created the video is making is true.Originally posted by C0ckney View Postyes, and it's still wrong in every way that i described and others besides. one of the reasons you're so bad at history is that you're prepared to uncritically accept any old rubbish as long as it supports your views.
Leave a comment:
-
yes, and it's still wrong in every way that i described and others besides. one of the reasons you're so bad at history is that you're prepared to uncritically accept any old rubbish as long as it supports your views.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostIf you watched the video, you'd notice that they updated the colors every fifty years.
in this case, the guy tries to present his video as a battle by battle account of the expansion of islam and compare that with the crusades. he gets it wrong and totally wrong in many places, and yet you're lapping up because it supports your own view. i feel for your students.
Last edited by C0ckney; January 18, 2016, 07:30.
Leave a comment:
-
*Popcorn*
Wow, Kid and Ben's utter moronic stupidity is such a wonder to behold!
Leave a comment:
-
Well, or course, that makes no sense. The only reason for the Crusades was the constant aggression of the Muslims in the first place.Originally posted by kentonio View PostIt's a little rich to whine about the Muslims taking Constantinople, when the only reason they were able to is because the Catholics sacked the place and left Byzantium a faded wreck that never recovered properly.
Leave a comment:
-
«Κρειττότερόν εστιν ιδέναι εν μέση τη πόλει φακιόλιον βασιλεύον Τούρκων ή καλύπτραν λατινικήν""
Kritoteron estin idenai en mesi ti Poli fakiolion basileuon toukron i kalyptran latinikin
It is better that a turkish cap reigns on the City than a latin hood
Duke Notaras 1400-62
That pretty much sums it up about who was the monster and who was not
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: