Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    This is what you don't understand. Their jihad has nothing to do with Crusades or anything else they use for propaganda. They started by forcing others to join their religion or pay taxes, by the sword, not because of Crusades.
    Noone claims that they forced to people to convert because of the crusades.

    What I wanted to say is that christians weren´t better than muslims with regards to conquest ... and in contrast to muslims, christians often didn´t just demand additional taxes from infidels they conquered, but rather gave them only the choice to convert, or be put to the sword (just remember the colonization of america ... but also the christianization of europe often was done via the sword (for example the northern crusades))

    Leave a comment:


  • rah
    replied
    This is what you don't understand. Their jihad has nothing to do with Crusades or anything else they use for propaganda. They started by forcing others to join their religion or pay taxes, by the sword, not because of Crusades.
    So what. Most religions were created to control the peons or just to have control. It's what they evolve into that's important. I'll agree that some of the evolution is not good, but not all muslims are like that. And I refuse to condemn a millions of peaceful muslims because of a subset. Just like I refuse to condemn millions of christians because of a subset.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    I don't know.
    Kind of looks like half of europe




    Certaintly is more than that if you include the iberian peninsula

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post
    There were two big incursions of "mooslims" to europe.

    One was the moors in the iberian peninsula. (which btw after the reconquista, the "christians" had so much spare soldiers wreaking havoc in their own lands that they sent them to the new world to pillage and burn there)

    the other were the ottomans. while the byzantine empire was in a long process of decomposition long before, the crusades gave it the final hit and opened up wide the way for the "mooslims" to advance to vienna.

    Also under the ottoman empire the farmers, notoriously were better off (at least financially, the taxes were low because the ottomans couldn't enforce their dominion in plenty of places - unlike the nation states that ensued. but still struggle )
    The Balkans aren't quite half of Europe.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by rah View Post
    There's a big difference claiming that they are the victims than saying that both side contributed to the prolonged hostilities.
    Not everything is black and white.
    Not every Muslim is a war hunger zealot. Most are peaceful.
    Not every Christian is all flowers and hugs.
    This is what you don't understand. Their jihad has nothing to do with Crusades or anything else they use for propaganda. They started by forcing others to join their religion or pay taxes, by the sword, not because of Crusades.

    Leave a comment:


  • rah
    replied
    There's a big difference claiming that they are the victims than saying that both side contributed to the prolonged hostilities.
    Not everything is black and white.
    Not every Muslim is a war hunger zealot. Most are peaceful.
    Not every Christian is all flowers and hugs.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ming View Post
    You never have time for something when you are wrong
    No. Because it doesn't get more ridiculous than claiming that a people who we the aggressors for 400 years are the victims. Islam is a history of persecuting other peoples from day one. The religion probably didn't even start until they had already conquered Jerusalem. It's a religion started by bloodthirsty murderers..

    Leave a comment:


  • Ming
    replied
    You never have time for something when you are wrong

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Oh brother. I don't have time for this. I suppose you think the Native Americans conquered the Christians too.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    I assume you are aware that the Muslims had been attacking Christendom for over 4 centuries, slaughtering and enslaving women and children, and taxing Christians to death before a Pope ever even mentioned the word crusade.
    There have been both ... muslim conquests as well as christian conquests before the first crusade ...
    after Karl Martells victory over the muslim armies at Tours, actually the Reconquista began, the reconquest of the spanish peninsula from muslim reign (well, actually it may have begun a little bit earlier, but Karl Martells victory was an important stepstone ... weakening the muslim leadership and armies).
    Meanwhile in the east (the byzantine empire) the muslim conquests went on (and actually were the reason for the first crusade ... the request for help by the byzantine empire ... unfortunately the christian armies in their bloodthirst went further than requested by the byzantine emperor and also attacked the muslim allies of the byzantine empire ... not only the turkmens against which the help was requested)
    (actually one later crusade finally was among the reasons why the byzantine empire finally fell to the turks ... when the greediness of the christian crusader armies knew no end and they conquered constantinople instead of traveling further to the intended target of the crusade ... weakened the byzantine so that Sultan Suleiman few centuries later had an easy time conquering all the rest ... all in all the crusades rather were a burden for the byzantine empire, than a help)

    Also ... taxing christians ... how evil ... not
    Imposing additional taxes for other faiths was more civilized than slaughtering people of other faiths within the own country, as happened in the medieval christian europe (I agree btw. that enslaving christians was another matter ... but those AFAIK were done by muslim pirates ... not by the muslim states themselves)

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    There were two big incursions of "mooslims" to europe.

    One was the moors in the iberian peninsula. (which btw after the reconquista, the "christians" had so much spare soldiers wreaking havoc in their own lands that they sent them to the new world to pillage and burn there)

    the other were the ottomans. while the byzantine empire was in a long process of decomposition long before, the crusades gave it the final hit and opened up wide the way for the "mooslims" to advance to vienna.

    Also under the ottoman empire the farmers, notoriously were better off (at least financially, the taxes were low because the ottomans couldn't enforce their dominion in plenty of places - unlike the nation states that ensued. but still struggle )

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View Post

    what?

    the crusades directly led to half of europe going to the muslims.
    Go watch those videos please.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied

    what?

    the crusades directly led to half of europe going to the muslims.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
    They surely were ...
    and then, in the centuries after Karl Martell managed to stop the muslim incursions, the chrstians themselves became bloodthirsty warmongers, who took part in wars of conquest on the order of their highest priest and gods representative on earth.
    (and slew the unbelievers in Jerusalem, till they waded to the ankles in blood (cannot blame them, if their priests had read to them Deuteronomy 17 prior to the attack on the city))
    I assume you are aware that the Muslims had been attacking Christendom for over 4 centuries, slaughtering and enslaving women and children, and taxing Christians to death before a Pope ever even mentioned the word crusade.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    No. The Muslims were extremely aggressive. Stop making them out to be victims. You are defending bloodthirsty warmongers.
    ...

    They surely were ...
    and then, in the centuries after Karl Martell managed to stop the muslim incursions, the chrstians themselves became bloodthirsty warmongers, who took part in wars of conquest on the order of their highest priest and gods representative on earth.
    (and slew the unbelievers in Jerusalem, till they waded to the ankles in blood (cannot blame them, if their priests had read to them Deuteronomy 17 prior to the attack on the city))

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X