Originally posted by Ming
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
First of all, that's non-sense, and propaganda that just keeps getting repeated. Second, this country war founded on Christian principles which are good for a society.
-
Islam is a religion that encourages it's followers to terrorize non-believers. Why are you not against that?Originally posted by Aeson View PostSome people respond to Ben, some people hold similar prejudices as Ben and Kid in regards to Muslims. We all have our faults ...
Leave a comment:
-
Women weren't disallowed because of their gender either. They were disallowed because they were uneducated, just like the men who didn't have the right to vote.Originally posted by Aeson View PostThe simple reality is that women could not vote for over a century because they were women.
Men who weren't allowed to vote were not disallowed because of their gender.
Leave a comment:
-
The simple fact is that women were not allowed to vote because of their gender. It is by definition sexist.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAnd so were most men. If the franchise were sexist why did it bar men too?
There are plenty of examples of royal incestuous marriages.No, it's not true.
Leave a comment:
-
And so were most men. If the franchise were sexist why did it bar men too?The simple reality is that women were not allowed to vote because of their gender. It is by definition sexist.
No, it's not true. I'm sorry Aeson. I realize that you've been taught it your entire life, but it's a myth. The European nobility was not, as a rule, inbred.You responded to that statement and claimed that it was false. It was clearly true. You are wrong.
Leave a comment:
-
I suggest you read some of the rather odious accounts of him and his wife after they had a child. Prejudice at it's finest.all james II's good breeding didn't stop him from alienating almost everyone and then running away in the face of william and mary (who were cousins).
Leave a comment:
-
all james II's good breeding didn't stop him from alienating almost everyone and then running away in the face of william and mary (who were cousins).
Leave a comment:
-
The simple reality is that women were not allowed to vote because of their gender. It is by definition sexist.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostFor nearly a century, neither could men. In fact, the time before universal male suffrage, was longer than the time between universal male suffrage and the introduction of female suffrage.
I made a statement about hereditary rule in general. You responded to that statement and claimed that it was false. It was clearly true. You are wrong.Uh, given the context of the American revolution and the Glorious Revolution, James VI/I is the relevant example.
Leave a comment:
-
And there are over 30 thousand names in my database. If we accept your bold assertion as 200 marriages that is less than a percent of the total.There were not 3 examples, there were hundreds.
So that would mean that 99+ percent of the European nobility was not inbred.
The actual data doesn't back up your claim.The major royal families of Europe are incredibly inbred and always were
As I already stated, the British line was a combination of Scottish noble lines, English Plantagenets and a little bit of Dutch and French. Of the 16 lines, 15 were distinct at the time of James VI, with the only duplication being the one Plantagenet line., because they followed the practice of marrying into other royal or noble lines, and that gives you a very limited genetic pool to choose from.
You are right that noble families did intermarry, but there are more families than you might expect, particularly in Germany. That, combined with outcrossings about every third generation prevented inbreeding.
Yes, and there's also a reason he's a notable exception to the general rule.There's a reason why the Spanish Habsburg line ended with the infertile and mentally and physically disabled Charles II.
Well, it wholly destroys your argument. I selected James VI/I because he was the founder of the Stuart dynasty, not because I had to cherry pick. Should I go on? I have a database of over 30k royal marriages in the period.No-one gives a **** about James II, stop building up strawmen you can knock down to try and make yourself feel smart.
And, from what I see, the vast majority of those were not inbred because of the Papal restrictions on 4th order intermarriage.
I have the data, it doesn't back up your claim.
Leave a comment:
-
For nearly a century, neither could men. In fact, the time before universal male suffrage, was longer than the time between universal male suffrage and the introduction of female suffrage.The simple reality is that women could not vote for over a century because they were women.
The franchise at that point wasn't based on your sex.Men who weren't allowed to vote were not disallowed because of their gender.
Leave a comment:
-
Uh, given the context of the American revolution and the Glorious Revolution, James VI/I is the relevant example.No. That was you cherry picking examples in response to a generalized statement about hereditary rule.
And your general statement is wrong. Are you seriously asserting that the majority of European nobility in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries was inbred?
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: