eye for an eye

[Kidlicious]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski

How can I answer that i havent done either of the above
A story in the paper prompted me to ask this cause a father went off and did the same punishment to the guy who killed is little girl the father is now serving life in prision

How do you know the guy killed his little girl?

[Mrs. Tuberski]

he was on trial for murder with dna evidence proving he raped her.

[C0ckney]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski
I was also trying to find out if you guys believe in eye for eye as forms of punishment as well. I.E you have a crimminal that rapes and kills a kid. Do you think it is right for the criminal to sufer the same punishment or just give him lethal injection. For me Lethal injection is the easy way out on this scumbag. Give him the same form of torture that he give that kid

the problem with that sort of thing is that it's a bit of sod when the guy turns out to be innocent after all.

for once, kid is spot on here.

[General Ludd]

So who gets to kill him, now that he killed his daughter's killer?

[Kidlicious]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski
he was on trial for murder with dna evidence proving he raped her.

Then killing him was immoral and he should have been given a fair trial and sentence. The father is guilty.

[St Leo]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski
Do you think it is right for the criminal to sufer the same punishment or just give him lethal injection.

Twenty years WITHOUT daily hate and brutality. There is no justice in making a hell.

For me Lethal injection is the easy way out on this scumbag.

For me, hate and retribution are the easy way out for us.

[Ben Kenobi]

I wouldn't fight back unless I knew I would get away with it.

Hardly an argument endorsing either position.

If you believe it is wrong to retaliate, it will be wrong whether or not someone sees you do so.

[Mrs. Tuberski]

Kid the father is guilty of murder. But had the first guy not killed his little girl he wouldnt have been in that position.

[Pekka]

So? Kill someone, you go to jail. Can't do the time, don't do the crime. Period.

Is it understandable? Sure. Makes no difference.

[Verres]

Originally posted by Azazel

Having been a victim of so called 'violent' crime on one occassion

Wha?

Fine, you want me to get graphic? It was rape. Not violent as some of you no doubt see it, but violent to me - ok?

[Mrs. Tuberski]

Verres been there too thats why i feel as i do. I had nothing but hate for the ass that did that wanted him to feel my pain too

[Verres]

No hate. No desire for pain. Just answering a question to some faceless bots on the internet. C'est finis.

[Mr. Harley]

Veres - hope you end up OK. I would have been married to a different lady than my current wife except 20 years ago she was raped on campus. She wouldn't even report it because she said if her dad or I found out who did it, we would kill the S*B.

What was sad I knew jack about the effects on women - I just knew something was very wrong, because we were just on the edge of being intimate, it had gotten very hot a few times, and suddenly she was like a zombie. I wish now I knew what I didn't then, with counseling and the like we might have made it. I succumbed to her withdrawal and finally gave up. :sad: I hope you are getting counseling and have good support.

[Kidlicious]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski
Kid the father is guilty of murder. But had the first guy not killed his little girl he wouldnt have been in that position.

I'm sure all of us prefer to live in a society where people can't go around punishing people however they see fit. If the court was corrupt I could feel sorry for the guy, but this person was going to get fair punishment for his crime and the father had no right to do what he did.

[Ben Kenobi]

I hardly think making a woman confess a horrible incident is acceptable. The fact that she said violent crime should have been enough. Most of you men can't fathom what this lady has been through. Verres you have a lot strength may you continue with this strength and get the help you may need.