And another Banana message... They don't seem to give up about point #2.
duration : not needed, as this is not an "obligatory" agreement where everybody *has* to trade techs if possible. It's just a set of "default rules" by which we conduct trade on this continent. When/if trades are done is not covered by this document, that's something to be agreed upon on a per-case basis between the teams.
I only now noticed their second point has two changes :
=> It only prevents retrading techs to non-member parties
=> It is only for tech acquired from one of the members, not for techs acquired by one of us from a 4th team.
I disagree with the first point, but agree with their second point. So, my proposal for #2 is :
2. each of the three civs agrees not to retrade any technology acquired in trade from one of the three; without prior agreement of the researching nation.
Friends,
Concerning point #2.
Our thoughts were that there might be a situation where a 4th nation would have something to offer 1 of us which in turn would benefit all 3 of us. We would hate to be in a situation where we 3 nations could not benefit from a trade due to our own treaty. Team Banana agrees that no party to this treaty should exclusively benefit from tech trades to a 4th party, but that we as partners should keep the option open as long as all 3 of us agree to the trade with the 4th party.
That said, I would find it very rare that a 4th nation would have anything to offer 3 nations who co-ordinate tech research and have an agreement as ours.
Do all three nations agree to the 5 terms that Team Banana offered?
1. Technology trades will be based on beakers with equality being the goal.
2. each of the three civs agrees not to retrade any technology to a non-member party acquired in trade from one of the three; without prior agreement of all three member nations.
3. trades arranged are kept even if a tech to be traded for is acquired by other means
4. each of the three teams agrees to an embargo on the team known as Vox. Technology will never be traded with Vox and borders with them will remain closed forever.
5. tech trade arragements among member nations will be common knowledge to member nations - ie. when a trade deal is finalized all 3 members will be notified even if only 2 parties are involved in the trade.
Do we need a 6th point that defines the duration of the agreement, or is this for all time? Someone pick a date, age or tech far in the future. This is not a sticking point but it is something that should be defined.
Something like:
6. Upon this world's entry into the MODERN ERA, the members of 3T will renew 3T as is, with modifications, or dissolve Tech Trade Treaty amicably.
or
6. Upon discovering and successfully trading FISSION to 3T members, the members of 3T will renew 3T as is, with modifications, or dissolve Tech Trade Treaty amicably.
Again, someone fill in the date or technology and Team Banana will most likely agree to it.
That should cover it for us.
Team Banana looks forward to 3T being signed so that our nations grow strong together in peace.
The Diplomatic Banana
Concerning point #2.
Our thoughts were that there might be a situation where a 4th nation would have something to offer 1 of us which in turn would benefit all 3 of us. We would hate to be in a situation where we 3 nations could not benefit from a trade due to our own treaty. Team Banana agrees that no party to this treaty should exclusively benefit from tech trades to a 4th party, but that we as partners should keep the option open as long as all 3 of us agree to the trade with the 4th party.
That said, I would find it very rare that a 4th nation would have anything to offer 3 nations who co-ordinate tech research and have an agreement as ours.
Do all three nations agree to the 5 terms that Team Banana offered?
1. Technology trades will be based on beakers with equality being the goal.
2. each of the three civs agrees not to retrade any technology to a non-member party acquired in trade from one of the three; without prior agreement of all three member nations.
3. trades arranged are kept even if a tech to be traded for is acquired by other means
4. each of the three teams agrees to an embargo on the team known as Vox. Technology will never be traded with Vox and borders with them will remain closed forever.
5. tech trade arragements among member nations will be common knowledge to member nations - ie. when a trade deal is finalized all 3 members will be notified even if only 2 parties are involved in the trade.
Do we need a 6th point that defines the duration of the agreement, or is this for all time? Someone pick a date, age or tech far in the future. This is not a sticking point but it is something that should be defined.
Something like:
6. Upon this world's entry into the MODERN ERA, the members of 3T will renew 3T as is, with modifications, or dissolve Tech Trade Treaty amicably.
or
6. Upon discovering and successfully trading FISSION to 3T members, the members of 3T will renew 3T as is, with modifications, or dissolve Tech Trade Treaty amicably.
Again, someone fill in the date or technology and Team Banana will most likely agree to it.
That should cover it for us.
Team Banana looks forward to 3T being signed so that our nations grow strong together in peace.
The Diplomatic Banana
I only now noticed their second point has two changes :
=> It only prevents retrading techs to non-member parties
=> It is only for tech acquired from one of the members, not for techs acquired by one of us from a 4th team.
I disagree with the first point, but agree with their second point. So, my proposal for #2 is :
2. each of the three civs agrees not to retrade any technology acquired in trade from one of the three; without prior agreement of the researching nation.
Comment