Brett Kavanaugh, great justice or greatest justice?

[Aeson]

If my friend was accused of being a gang rapist and then behaved belligerently to the authorities when questioned, lied under oath ... I wouldn’t want him on SCOTUS.

[Kidlicious]

More or less, but not by Dr. Ford.
I would think it is important for a judge not to mix cases ... and especially not carry the ire, he may feel about one case, over to another separate case

He did not accuse NPCs of being co-conspirators. That would be foley.

[Proteus_MST]

If I didn't know you better I would have thought you were starting to say that he wasn't accused of being a gang rapist. But of course he was.

More or less, but not by Dr. Ford.
I would think it is important for a judge not to mix cases ... and especially not carry the ire, he may feel about one case, over to another separate case

[Kidlicious]

Dr. Ford didn't accuse Kavanaugh of being a gang rapist (she didn't even accuse him of raping her ... "just" of attempting to do so) ... and the hearing was only about Dr. Ford, not about any other accusations like the one brought forth by Arvenattis client

If I didn't know you better I would have thought you were starting to say that he wasn't accused of being a gang rapist. But of course he was.

[Proteus_MST]

If your friend got accused of being a gang rapist would you accuse him of being unreasonable and all of that? Don't talk to me about being impartial.

Dr. Ford didn't accuse Kavanaugh of being a gang rapist (she didn't even accuse him of raping her ... "just" of attempting to do so) ... and the hearing was only about Dr. Ford, not about any other accusations like the one brought forth by Arvenattis client

[Kidlicious]

I am a scumbag for thinking a Supreme court nominee should be honest, reasonable, impartial, and dignified

If your friend got accused of being a gang rapist would you accuse him of being unreasonable and all of that? Don't talk to me about being impartial.

[Aeson]

I am a scumbag for thinking a Supreme court nominee should be honest, reasonable, impartial, and dignified

[Proteus_MST]

She did exactly what she was paid for

(a very ambivalent sentence ... although I am sure that Kid & Co won't see it this way )

[Berzerker]

the senate investigator listened to one side and ignored the other...so professional

[Ming]

And you are a scumbag. So is Aeson for attacking him for defending himself. So is Every one else here that I've seen make comments about this besides BK.

What part of my earlier post did you not understand...
I can see you aren't long for this site.

Keep it up and you are indeed toast

[Giancarlo]

Again Mitchell = partisan hit piece with partisan biases. This is what happens when you let biases filter into any sort of analysis.

Now he's calling people on here scumbags... well now. 3... 2...

[Berzerker]

I'm telling you just one more time, what Mitchell said has to be taken in it's entirety. Letting you criticize a professional with 25 years experience in only parr of what she said is just a waste of time.

That's all I am going to say. And you are a scumbag. So is Aeson for attacking him for defending himself. So is Every one else here that I've seen make comments about this besides BK.

Where is her analysis of Kavanaugh's testimony?

[Kidlicious]

Quote her analysis - simple. One step at a time. Pick out the most damning evidence against Ford's story and I'll address it. I'm not going to repeat my effort to post a rebuttal to every claim made by the prosecutor. Most of it is irrelevant to the facts we have - Ford said at least 4 boys attended a party at which Kavanaugh attacked her. She named 3 of them and Kavanaugh's calendar shows the same group of boys at a party within the time frame.

Furthermore, we have Judge's claim he took a job to pay for football camp. That started in late August. She said it was 6-8 weeks after the attack that she saw him at the store working. So 6-7 weeks after July 1st is mid August. Bingo!



If I behaved the way Kavanaugh did I would be a scumbag.

I'm telling you just one more time, what Mitchell said has to be taken in it's entirety. Letting you criticize a professional with 25 years experience in only parr of what she said is just a waste of time.

That's all I am going to say. And you are a scumbag. So is Aeson for attacking him for defending himself. So is Every one else here that I've seen make comments about this besides BK.

[Giancarlo]

Oh I get it, just like your avatar, holarious.

How is my avatar a personal attack? My avatar seems to have struck a nerve with you... Feeling a bit insecure?

[Giancarlo]

If I behaved the way Kavanaugh did, I'd be sitting in jail. I don't have the rich white kid defense.