Stalin monument to be built??

[Pekka]

"What difference does that make to my point, Pekka? I don't care is my answer.

My point is, Finland helped the Germans starve Leningrad."

It makes all the difference in the world. We were in that location for justified reason.

And justr because we were there, doesn't make it a fact that we starved Leningrad, or even helped it at all.

[chequita guevara]

Originally posted by Pekka
Now, the part is that we were in geographical location near Leningrad. Please expalin how we starved Leningrad, not cutting the support lines?

You cut off supply from the North and reduced the city's supply to one narrow life line. Sure, you say you could have cut it off, but if it were so easy, I guess the Germans could have done it also. They were 100 times more powerful than you, and they didn't do it either. I mean, it's just a matter of walking across the ice, right?

[Pekka]

Duh, look at the map, Germans would have had to come through our areas of responsiblity, which we disagreed on. They wanted to, we didn't allow it. Are you really THIS simple?

The support line was easily cuttable. This isn't usually even a subject of debate. It wasn't even consideration on how much it would cost us to cut it in terms of cutting it in action, but it was a question of getting into something that wasn't our goal, wasn't part of our battle and wouldn't have helped us. But would have made it worse of course and owuld have been criminal to do so. Something Stalin knows a lot about.

Now, please, explain how should have we let the support go through lands we were dug in already? Please do explain it. We were at WAR.

And we just covered, that you don't care why we were at the locations we were but I still explained it. Now, how should have we arranged it, for your pleasure, to cross inside our defensive zones? Being reasonable, like Stalin? We were reasonable, we let the road of life live, and Leningrad survive after it was all over. You should in fact say thanks instead of anything else.

[chequita guevara]

Originally posted by Pekka
It makes all the difference in the world. We were in that location for justified reason.

Only to Finns (re: it making all the difference in the world).

And justr because we were there, doesn't make it a fact that we starved Leningrad, or even helped it at all.

You cut off supply from the North. You helped starve the city.

[Pekka]

Read my previous post.

[chequita guevara]

Originally posted by Pekka
Duh, look at the map, Germans would have had to come through our areas of responsiblity, which we disagreed on.

The map doesn't show German areas of occupation, which was the southern shores of Lake Ladoga. They wouldn't have had to enter from Finland. They could have walked across the ice, just like the Soviet trucks did.

[chequita guevara]

Originally posted by Pekka
Now, please, explain how should have we let the support go through lands we were dug in already? Please do explain it. We were at WAR.

So you're admitting you cut them off. Thank you.

You are now PWN3d!!111!!

[laurentius]

I blame Neptunus for cutting Soviet supplies from the West.

[Pekka]

Of course, german troops in there, would have been a task to actually cut it, because the whole German army wasn't there. But of course our whole Amry was very much weaker. Do you even realize, that it wasn't in ther intentions to concentrate to the support line area? Of course you didn't know it, because you don't know anything about this whole ordeal.

You're basically saying, that we starved a city, because we were in the location where we were.. I'm sure you understand nations in war do not create free entry zones for each other in their defensive zones? Do I need to repeat. DEFENSIVE ZONES. Go figure.

[Sava]

Pekka supports Hitler.

[Pekka]

Che, are you republican? You are not refuting 99% of my arguments, and then you take that out of the context and scream pwned like a little princess?

We didn't have to cut anything, because they were already our zones. IN ORDER NOT TO CUT IT, ACCORDING TO YOU, we should have retreated and leave all our positions, because it was in YOUR best interest (whcih was usually the opposite for us?).

Are you stupid or do you have a short memory? We didn't cut the road of life, which you say was too much of a mission? World laughs at you.

[laurentius]

We all secretly worship Hitler in Finland.

[Pekka]

Hey, even the nuremberg courts disagrees with you Che. Mannerheim wasn't there, as a war criminal for crimes against what ever. Nothing supports you.

Do you realize, that your argument is basically we should have let our enemy support work behind our lines? crazyness!

[chequita guevara]

Originally posted by laurentius
I blame Neptunus for cutting Soviet supplies from the West.

That would be Nazi mine layers and Finnish subs.

[Pekka]

Finnish subs Clueless Che is on a rampage tonight!