Why does BK participate in gay topic threads?

[loinburger]

1, he could be lying about the statement that he was serious. If he's an inveterate liar, then both statements would be lies, and you now have zero reliable information.

Then this would make him a liar. David Floyd is a racist and/or liar.

2, your entire case revolves around him telling the truth about both. Arguing that he's an inveterate liar AND that the statement, "I was serious", doesn't fly.

What case? The case is that he is a racist and/or a liar. All you have done is to argue that he might be a liar but not a racist, which does not negate the statement that David Floyd is a racist and/or a liar. You do understand what "and/or" means, right?

[Ben Kenobi]

I don't know - maybe if you spoke plainly instead of making page after page of insinuations then you wouldn't have to keep making page after page of insinuations.

1, I've already PM him. That should say the following, that I don't feel that the discussion between me and Lori merits public discussion.
2, I've already stated that what Lori has posted about the PM isn't the full picture.

If I'm sticking to one, then posting everything doesn't really help me, now does it?

logical conclusion is that there are no crucial facts that magically change the contents of the PM

You fail logic forever. There's a simple logical answer to all of this, Loin. Maybe you'll figure it out.

while at the same time forbidding him from posting the contents of the PM to clear his name.

Again, I don't feel that the PM merits public discussion. Posting the entire contents of the PM defeats that statement.

[kentonio]

K.

1, he could be lying about the statement that he was serious. If he's an inveterate liar, then both statements would be lies, and you now have zero reliable information.
2, your entire case revolves around him telling the truth about both. Arguing that he's an inveterate liar AND that the statement, "I was serious", doesn't fly.

Jesus christ you're dumb Ben. If he was lying then the 'and/or a liar' becomes 'or a liar' making half the statement positive.

[loinburger]

Here, maybe this will help. David Floyd is a racist and/or liar means:
David Floyd is a racist and a liar
OR
David Floyd is a racist
OR
David Floyd is a liar

Does that clear things up?

[Ben Kenobi]

What case? The case is that he is a racist and/or a liar. All you have done is to argue that he might be a liar but not a racist, which does not negate the statement that David Floyd is a racist and/or a liar. You do understand what "and/or" means, right?

I do, and I'm stating that you cannot obtain any reliable information from what he's said here, unless you assume he's telling the truth.

[loinburger]

That should say the following, that I don't feel that the discussion between me and Lori merits public discussion.

...and yet you've made a very public issue of the PM, dropping hints about its contents, for several pages.

You fail logic forever. There's a simple logical answer to all of this, Loin. Maybe you'll figure it out.

You are a liar, and you are violent to boot. The simple logical answer is that you threatened violence in the PM and are lying about it now.

[Ben Kenobi]

Loin:

David Floyd is not a racist and a liar, must also be an option. If he's lying about: "I am a racist", and lying, "this thread is serious", he could very well not be a racist at all, and lying about being one.

I believe they call that trolling, and I figured you'd be familiar with it.

[loinburger]

I do, and I'm stating that you cannot obtain any reliable information from what he's said here, unless you assume he's telling the truth.

THEN HE IS A LIAR! Goddamn how can you be so stupid.

[loinburger]

Loin:

David Floyd is not a racist and a liar, must also be an option. If he's lying about: "I am a racist", and lying, "this thread is serious", he could very well not be a racist at all, and lying about being one.

I give up. How did you ever graduate college

[Kidlicious]

Loin:

David Floyd is not a racist and a liar, must also be an option. If he's lying about: "I am a racist", and lying, "this thread is serious", he could very well not be a racist at all, and lying about being one.

I believe they call that trolling, and I figured you'd be familiar with it.

[Ben Kenobi]

The simple logical answer is that you threatened violence in the PM and are lying about it now.

Oh, I assure you that neither myself nor Lori has lied. This is a logic puzzle, Loin. Logic puzzles only work with reliable information.

[kentonio]

How did you ever graduate college

QFT

[loinburger]

Oh, I assure you that neither myself nor Lori has lied. This is a logic puzzle, Loin. Logic puzzles only work with reliable information.

Sure, I'm going to play a logic game about the truth with somebody who doesn't understand logic and doesn't tell the truth. I'll let you know as soon as I've solved the puzzle!!!

[Ben Kenobi]

Whether he's serious or not doesn't matter. If he intentionally posted something that was not true then he is lying. If he did so only in jest then his lie was not malicious, but it was still a lie.

Indeed. He can be a liar OR a racist. He cannot be both.

[Lorizael]

BK, I honestly have no idea what you were trying to communicate in your PM because none of your sentences were grammatically correct. That said, you did give the name and address of a church.