Another victory for the ZOG: doctored documents "prove" Liberty attack to be an error

[GePap]

Hmmm....

So the only Aerican recorsd of the whole insident are tapes from one spy plane that arrived at the scene after the whole attack was over, that then hears what the Israelis are syaing after the attacks, and not prior or during?

Wow, I can see how this will end all the stoires since it's such definitive proof....

[Az]

What more do you need?

It WAY more proof than the other side of the debate has. But I guess that some people will never be satisfied.

[GePap]

Well, explinations to some of the questions DD asks: for example, was a large US flag on display or not? The best people to say this would be the crew. Why, even after the attacks, would the helicopter pilots say it was an egyptian warship, and then a freighter? Are the profiles so similar? Did none of the atatcking pilots ever say: hmm, this doesn't look like..x and x?

Oh, and this one single question is enough to keep the conspiracies rolling: did the Irealis know, or guess, that a US spy plane would come to monitor things after the attack?". I hope you can see how such single question can continue to feed the issue.

So don;t get your hopes up about this theory going away.

[Az]

Hey, if some people believe in God, I sure don't think that lack of evidence will dissuade them this time.

[Edan]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
I had no idea that the Israeli military was so stupid and incompatent then.

Heh. Israel had a number of friendly fire inciidents against it's own military in that war. But, then, so did the US in vietnam (something like 5000+ deaths by friendly fire).

[DinoDoc]

Originally posted by Edan
Heh. Israel had a number of friendly fire inciidents against it's own military in that war.

Why does everyone automatically leave the part about the attack lasting 2 1/2 hours in thier response to me? I guess it would ruin the tone of the response.

[Sava]

I don't understand how a helicopter can fly around a ship at close range... machine gunning the crew, and not realize it's American... something fishy is going on.

[DinoDoc]

On Monday, the NSA gave him a transcript
of conversations held by two Israeli Air Force
helicopter pilots who were hovering over the
Liberty as it was sinking

Who does the Haaretz's fact checking? The Liberty didn't sink.

[Arrian]

I think I dealt with that objection, DD. You continue to harp on it as if it alone proves Israeli intent.

I agree that it is odd, and therefore warrants some additional suspicion. But that doesn't prove the conspiracy theory that the Israelis sunk our ship to prevent us from stopping their move vs. Syria.

-Arrian

[DinoDoc]

Originally posted by Arrian
I think I dealt with that objection, DD. You continue to harp on it as if it alone proves Israeli intent.

I keep harping on it because people keep quoting that post where I described the IDF as being stupid and incompetent and bringing up other incidents that don't even approach the same level of stupidity. The closest anyone came was you with the Giving Speed to Pilots example.

[Az]

And how would you prevent it?

It's not as if you agreed to the general attack, anyway.

[chequita guevara]

The Liberty didn't sink, though you sure gave it your best shots.

[Panag]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
I had no idea that the Israeli military was so stupid and incompatent then.

hi ,

sure , whatever you say , ........ ever been in the military , .... or in a warzone , ..... cause if you would have , you would know that things kind a get confusing , thats the least to say , ......



its intresting to point out some facts everyone keeps forgetting , .....

1 ) the americans believed they where under attack by egyptian torpedo boats

2 ) the Israeli's tought it was an egyptian ship

3 ) the egyptians had just shelled the shores

4 ) the liberty was warned , ...... wtf was it doing in a warzone , why did med fleet command not send protection , ......

5 ) why did they not answer to leave the waters and identify themselfs , ......

have a nice day

[Drake Tungsten]

I'm glad I never bought into the conspiracy theory. Luckily, I knew the ZOG would eventually bribe some U.S. official into covering up the whole thing.

[Panag]

Originally posted by chegitz guevara
The Liberty didn't sink, though you sure gave it your best shots.

hi ,

no we did not , the orders where to stop the ship , troops where on the way to enter it , .......

have a nice day