As far as gameplay is concerned, Civ 3 is the best yet. As far as Scenario/Mod making is concerned, it is the worst yet, although this patch will help significantly. Here a few things I would LOVE to see:
1. Mini-map - this is ESSENTIAL. I have gone back to Civ2 because of this. This alone is worth more than this last patch. Add it and I will return to Civ 3.
2. Event Editor (like Civ2 Gold) - not essential, but I LOVE it! Really lets you customize the game. Helped inspire me to be a programmer...
3. Unique Terrain/Landmarks (Like SMAC/X) - Adds more variety to the game.
4. Random Events - Earthquakes, Major volcaninc eruptions, meteor strikes, Christina Aguilera..... gotta love it!
5. Date editing ability - necessary for time-specific scenarios. Also would like to be able to extend gameplay to last forever.....
6. Ability to add unlimited techs/buildings/units. At least let us increase them substancially.....
7. The ability to add negative defense bonuses for certain terrain (in Civ 2 you could do this)
8. At least 3 levels of mines/roads/farms - like CTP 1/2.
9. Oceanic cities/farming/mining.
10. Starting locations/units would be nice, too, but sometimes I LIKE not knowing where I will start. Necessary for 'true-to-life' scenarios though.
11. A dino mod. I know it will never happen, but I loved the Civ2 dino mod and was really looking forward to Sid's ill-fated dino game...
There are more, but I forget...
Look, I love the genre, I love Firaxis, and this game plays very well. But as a previous poster said, this game should have at least included everything civ2 had and at least some of what SMAC had. Civ 2 gold had the best scenario making tools of all the other games out there. And I still prefer it.
This patch is a step in the right direction, but there is alot more to go. Heck, I would gladly shell out $40 to buy an add-on pack that just includes the changes above. So if you don't want to waste time and money on releasing patches, make an add-on. As it is, Civ 3 is an awesome incomplete game.
-Justin
1. Mini-map - this is ESSENTIAL. I have gone back to Civ2 because of this. This alone is worth more than this last patch. Add it and I will return to Civ 3.
2. Event Editor (like Civ2 Gold) - not essential, but I LOVE it! Really lets you customize the game. Helped inspire me to be a programmer...
3. Unique Terrain/Landmarks (Like SMAC/X) - Adds more variety to the game.
4. Random Events - Earthquakes, Major volcaninc eruptions, meteor strikes, Christina Aguilera..... gotta love it!
5. Date editing ability - necessary for time-specific scenarios. Also would like to be able to extend gameplay to last forever.....
6. Ability to add unlimited techs/buildings/units. At least let us increase them substancially.....
7. The ability to add negative defense bonuses for certain terrain (in Civ 2 you could do this)
8. At least 3 levels of mines/roads/farms - like CTP 1/2.
9. Oceanic cities/farming/mining.
10. Starting locations/units would be nice, too, but sometimes I LIKE not knowing where I will start. Necessary for 'true-to-life' scenarios though.
11. A dino mod. I know it will never happen, but I loved the Civ2 dino mod and was really looking forward to Sid's ill-fated dino game...

There are more, but I forget...
Look, I love the genre, I love Firaxis, and this game plays very well. But as a previous poster said, this game should have at least included everything civ2 had and at least some of what SMAC had. Civ 2 gold had the best scenario making tools of all the other games out there. And I still prefer it.
This patch is a step in the right direction, but there is alot more to go. Heck, I would gladly shell out $40 to buy an add-on pack that just includes the changes above. So if you don't want to waste time and money on releasing patches, make an add-on. As it is, Civ 3 is an awesome incomplete game.
-Justin
Comment