World War One PBEM Playtest

[Nilat]

Russian Navy

There is no russian navy anymore...

[Palaiologos]

Originally posted by FiGu
Entente Turn
MAJOR VICTORY FOR Royal Navy! The German fleet bayed at Antwerpen along with the Antwerpen Garrison is completly destroyed! Le Havre Bombarded also by Navy Units. Hamburg Garrison Completly destroyed!
French Forces made a major counter attack against the German Forces in the Northern France, which ended up in Numerous casaulties to the German forces!
Oh and London Recaptured. Vive la Allies!

Italian Turn
ITALY DECLARES WAR ON AUSTRIA, GERMANY AND THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE!

AUSTRIAN NAVY COMPLETLY DESTROYED!

Italian forces moves in the Alps to meet the Pitty Austrian resistance!

Crap!

Dude i had 6 infantries and a cav garissoned in Antwerpen!

Fu_ck!

Could you be more specific about that "offensive in northern france that ended in numerous casualities"?

[FiGu]

Just a stack destroyed in the offensive in northern france.. it had.. 2-4 units. don't remember..

[Nilat]

And when you attacked english navy, FiGu had hided his navy and then I attacked your navy by suprise and attacked the cities!

Good work my mighty ally!

[academia]

Well, it seems the war is over. The allies will easily kick german/austrian/turkish butts.
Surrender while you have time to negotiate.

[Nilat]

And if you want to negoatiate, you have 1% chance to get peace

[Palaiologos]

This war is far from over i assure you. The Kriegsmarine still has about 10 ships and is ready to die fighting.

As for your offensive in Northern france, i checked my turn. the only unit not in trenches was an infantry in hills south of Le Havre(You attacked infantry in hills?How many men did you loose?).

Propaganda revealed!

Stalin dude play your turn.

[Palaiologos]

Originally posted by Stalin II
And when you attacked england navy, FiGu had hided his navy and then I attacked your navy by suprise and attacked the cities!

Good work my mighty ally!

?

Last time i checked the Russian navy was wiped out, the RN crippled and no German cities were captured.

On the other hand: Le havre and Verdun have been taken, London and Leicester raided and German forces have penetrated deep into French territory.

We have even kicked your ass in Africa as the colonial British forces are in full retreat.

Not to mention the capture of Skopje by our Ottoman allies.

[Nilat]

You right that there is no Russian navy, and soon there wont be any German navy

[Nilat]

War against Germany

The russian army has killed 3 german army units around Königsberg. One german army unit and one 3.7 Field gun unit.
We are closing up on Königsberg quickly!

War against Austria-Hungary

The third Austrian army unit has been killed in this war! All three have been annihilated by russian forces! (the 2 in the first turn and one in this turn) Austrian Artillery disabled near Lemberg.

War against the Ottomans

The first ottoman troops land troops have been destroyed in this war! (3.7 Field gun) Its the beginning of the end of the ottomans


Russian casualties have been very low! The germans have the most BWAAAHAHAHHAHA



P.S Happy new year!

[Palaiologos]

If the Russians were men enough to atack Koenigsburg itself they wouldn't be talking about light casualities.


Do i take it that the German army and 3.7 field gun are the units south of Warsaw?

Now i am pretty sure that a German infantry defending a stream is quite indomitable.You must have lost at least 3-4 units yourself in the proccess.

Propaganda revealed!



P.S BTw i would suggest to the allied General staffs that they start bragging when they ACTUALLY capture a city.

[Palaiologos]

We are still allowed to comment on the scenario, right?

More proposals: The 3.7 inch gun is worthless.It is suited neither for attack nor defence. If you meant it as a tactical support artillery that would kill infantry in tactical situations(i.e not in cities) then raise its HPs by 2(at least) and its attack.

If this is not what you meant it for, then i suggest you ditch it. Replace with either Austrian or Italian cavalry.

That brings us to another point. Cavalries in the scenario are quite impotent(as they were in real WW1).Now i say you give them the 2 space visibility flag to better suit the reckon role they eventually degenerated into.

Moreover the Submarine warfare is not simulated well enough. Not only the Germans do not start with any subs whatsoever(i guess the allies too) but the ones they can build are crap. A coastal submarine unit is not really needed(it can barely win a fight against destroyers) plus a generic sub unit could easily count for both types(High seas and Coastal).

Also the Sub hunter unit is not something people would regulary build.The destroyer is twice as good and they fullfill the same role.

[jim panse]

Thank you for those comments, Pericles. I will take some notes for the next version!

[Nilat]

Originally posted by Palaiologos
If the Russians were men enough to atack Koenigsburg itself they wouldn't be talking about light casualities.


Do i take it that the German army and 3.7 field gun are the units south of Warsaw?

Now i am pretty sure that a German infantry defending a stream is quite indomitable.You must have lost at least 3-4 units yourself in the proccess.

Propaganda revealed!



P.S BTw i would suggest to the allied General staffs that they start bragging when they ACTUALLY capture a city.

The german army unit and the 3.7 field gun (south of Warsaw) were killed without casualties! I had artillery in Warsaw.

I have been VERY lucky in two PBEMs now:

This PBEM, cause I have killed units without heavy casualties (And Im not reloading my turns!)

And 2194 days of war at CDG, cause I keep on finding U-boats

[Nilat]

And I agree with Palaiologos with the 3.7 field gun thing.
MG positions are too cheap!