World War One PBEM Playtest

[Nilat]

You can say its balanced, cause Austria has an upper hand against Russia

[Galvatron]

I vote on continuing this game, to me this scen seems balanced and ready for multiplayer despite some facts academia pointed out in the beginning but they're already solved

So I would say, let's continue

[academia]

A new version won´t change anything.
Turns speed depends on the commitment of the players to the game. And the more players we have, the slower the PBEM will move.

If you start a new pbem, count me out.

[Historical Atze]

Alright

[Nilat]

Just call me Mikko

I just take some leader names

[Historical Atze]

Originally posted by Palaiologos
I can't see why turns will be faster when playing he new version....

I don't either, but maybe Stalin ... err Hirohito ... is right.

[Palaiologos]

Frankly i am not interested in starting a new game again.

Moreover in a few weeks i must leave for six months in Athens to work for the Olympics and am'not sure what the civ2 situation will be there(if i'll have access to a PC at all) so if you dudes believe that opening a new game is the thing to do simply count me out.

[Nilat]

People arent interested in playing the old version..

[Palaiologos]

I can't see why turns will be faster when playing he new version....

[Historical Atze]

Well, this could help. Yet, I didn't mean to say I would want to stop playing with my last post. It's just that some people need 4 bumps and 2 weeks to move 20 units. I can't understand why ... ok, vacations but else? If a new pbem starts with the same scen, I would be interested in Italy again ...

[Nilat]

you know what we could do?

We could start again with the normal version, v2

same civs?

[Palaiologos]

Okay i'll withdraw my troops you can retake the city next turn.

Truth is i would like to continue playing too.I think this scenario is very playable especially in PBEM.

But as things go if people aren't having fun there is simply no point in continuing.

Lets have a vote: Stalin,Atze: no
Academia, Palaiologos:yes

what do the rest think?

[Nilat]

yeah..

[Historical Atze]

Well ... the turns last awfully long, this sucks

[Nilat]

There was coastal defences!! Im not so dumb...

And this scenario version is a bit old and...not very playable IMO.