Best LucasArts Adventure Game?

[Guynemer]

Best part of this poll? No wrong answers. Some are more right than others, but no wrong answers.

[Guynemer]

I ultimately go with Grim Fandango, as I think it is the most fully realized game as far as plot, atmosphere, writing, and gameplay go. However, I could be convinced to go with several others, including MM: DOTT, IJatFoA, S&M, and either of the first two MI games. Hell, even Loom might sneak in there, just for being so ambitious and groundbreaking.

[self biased]

as close to my heart as the secret of monkey island is, i had to go with Day of the Tentacle. wasn't it one of the first adventure games with a full-on voice cast?

[Guynemer]

One of the first, I think. But they did release a full voice-over version of Fate of Atlantis, too.

I love Day of the Tentacle. Every so often, the satanic electronic laughter of the weeble-clown goes through my head, even to this day.

[DrSpike]

I'd go with the original MI if you held a gun to my head. But it's really hard as DoTT, Grim Fandango and Sam and Max all count amongst my favourites.

And loads of others on the list are great.

[Nikolai]

Definitely DOTT. DOTT is fun, crazy and thoroughly enjoyable.

[Ben Kenobi]

I've played Loom, Full Throttle and Indiana Jones and his Desktop Adventures.

Seriously, I'm surprised Full Throttle hasn't been mentioned, or Indy in the search of the Holy Grail. I would probably say Indy's desktop adventures. Amazing game.

[Skanky Burns]

The original MI. DoTT was a close second, but a game without a giant monkey head just isn't complete.

[Nikolai]

I've played Loom, Full Throttle and Indiana Jones and his Desktop Adventures.

Seriously, I'm surprised Full Throttle hasn't been mentioned, or Indy in the search of the Holy Grail. I would probably say Indy's desktop adventures. Amazing game.

Indy and his Desktop Adventures? Never heard of that game...

[Guynemer]

Oh holy **** Ben.

Indiana Jones and His Desktop Adventures?

You just had to prove me wrong, and pick a wrong answer. That's not even a true adventure game!

[Ben Kenobi]

"Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade: The Graphic Adventure"

I misrecalled 'Graphic' for Desktop.

[DrSpike]

Last Crusade is a very good game that never had the following it perhaps deserved. But it's no MI/DoTT.

[Guynemer]

Last Crusade

Fate of Atlantis

His Desktop Adventures

[Boris Godunov]

It was a close call between Maniac Mansion: Day of the Tentacle and The Curse of Monkey Island. But in the end, DOTT just barely wins. Both awesome and hilarious though.

[Boris Godunov]

I'm surprised so many went for the original Monkey Island when the third one (Curse) is clearly the best of the whole series.