Torain is worthless because you don't know if he's ever going to see the field in a Shanahan offense, he's hurt a lot (injured now, in fact), and he's behind Hightower and Helu.
Austin Collie has Kerry Collins throwing to him. Lee Evans (I'm assuming) will be erratic. He's more of a good sell high when he has a breakout 150 yard 2 TD game hopefully soon. DeAngelo Williams looks terrible. I don't know what happened to him.
Don't know the size of the league or the rules but looks to me like you're giving up a WR2/borderline WR1 and a RB who shouldn't be rostered for a borderline RB2 in a platoon, and two borderline WR3's. There's more upside with Williams, Evans, and Collie, but Santonio Holmes is a safe weekly starter. Torain is worthless, though.
Brees
Desean
Santonio
MJD
SJax
Floyd
As the big five. Trading away Cutler fixed one weakness of the team. The depth is really shallow.
If you're hurting all over, trading for more guys with upside is a good idea but if you're in a strong position, you hold on to your weekly starter
If Deangelo returns to form, it gives me SJax, MJD and Deangelo, which is a power trio.
I'm reluctant to trade away the strength of the team, which is that it is a powerhouse with everything clicking. All the starters can beast.
Anyways, I made a counter offer. FJax + Collie + Deangelo for Floyd + Santonio + Torain. It actually helps his team, as he is really weak on WRs.
His deal actually hurts my team as it replaces a starter with weaker depth which isn't what the team needs at this point.
I hope he accepts the revised deal. That would give me Fjax, Deangelo, MJD and SJax, with Brees and Desean, leaving me weak at WR2, and that's it.
Comment