Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine
Collapse
X
-
I agree with this. Reports on Russian tanks are that most of the reactive armor is actually filled with cardboard. I think the Russian military has been one of the largest victims of corruption in history. More importantly, I don't think Putin was aware of what poor shape his military was actually in. If Putin survives this, then I believe we will see a serious purge among the oligarchs and a serious retooling of Russian military procurement. Actually, we will probably see that even if he doesn't survive this.Originally posted by Proteus_MST View Post
It seems to be more likely, that Putin was blinded by his own delusio de grandeur.
And by underlings which reported wnhat their mayster wanted to hear instead of what was reality (a problem that was already the case in soviet russia)
And so he was lacking the information how poor the readiness level of his forces really are (due to oligarchs putting the military budget rather in their own pockets, than to buy manpacks and spare parts for the soldiers/vehicles) and also mistakenly assumed that the Ukrainians would wwelcome him (and that the war would be over in less than a week)
I am really sure that there is no master plan by Putin ... just an enormous amount of miscalculation
(and a Putin who cannot get out of the quagmire he created, without losing face and making himself vulnerable)
I think that the real counter argument to Geronimo's theory is that from an intelligence perspective we knew about how many front line weapons that Russia had at the start of the conflict and we know that a sizeable percentage of those have been put out of action. It is highly unlikely that Russia would launch an attack against NATO with second line equipment. I think we must also remember that the weapons that the west have drawn down are actually being used against Russia. Perhaps they would be more effective in NATO troops hands, but the Ukrainians certainly seem to be utilizing them well. It is not as if they are removed from the conflict (should it happen), it is more like they were forward deployed and fulfilled their purpose. Finally, I don't believe any of the Western Nations have so severely drawn down their arsenals as to put themselves into any kind of threat of not being able to defend themselves. Just the U.S, Reserves probably have more frontline equipment than many of them had equipment in total anyway. Just the Sierra Army Depot alone has over 26,000 armored vehicles in mothballs that many countries would consider frontline equipment...unlike Russia's mothball fleet of 1950's and 1960's armor.
Conclusion....Sorry Geronimo, but I think that theory just doesn't hold water.Last edited by PLATO; September 12, 2022, 17:14.
- Likes 1
-
It seems to be more likely, that Putin was blinded by his own delusio de grandeur.Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
Ukrainian has already demonstrated remarkable subterfuge. It doesn't seem like an enormous stretch to assume Putin would be capable of the same. Putin's Grand plan wouldn't require a large circle of clued in conspirators either.
And by underlings which reported wnhat their mayster wanted to hear instead of what was reality (a problem that was already the case in soviet russia)
And so he was lacking the information how poor the readiness level of his forces really are (due to oligarchs putting the military budget rather in their own pockets, than to buy manpacks and spare parts for the soldiers/vehicles) and also mistakenly assumed that the Ukrainians would wwelcome him (and that the war would be over in less than a week)
I am really sure that there is no master plan by Putin ... just an enormous amount of miscalculation
(and a Putin who cannot get out of the quagmire he created, without losing face and making himself vulnerable)
Leave a comment:
-
Ukrainian has already demonstrated remarkable subterfuge. It doesn't seem like an enormous stretch to assume Putin would be capable of the same. Putin's Grand plan wouldn't require a large circle of clued in conspirators either.Originally posted by Dauphin View PostOccam’s razor. Grand plan working perfectly with total subterfuge is much less likely than Russian field **** ups.
Leave a comment:
-
Occam’s razor. Grand plan working perfectly with total subterfuge is much less likely than Russian field **** ups.
- Likes 1
Leave a comment:
-
I think there is a very unsettling interpretation of Ukraine's recent battlefield success. There is in fact a way that all of these Russian misfortunes may in fact be in some sense consistent with Putin's original Feb 2022 plan all along. This could be the case if Ukraine was never really the target but the target instead was NATO. Putin has spent vastly more money on Russian Nuclear weapons and delivery systems than on conventional forces. If all he planned to do was conquer his non-nato neighbors with conventional forces those spending priorities would not have made sense. Instead, Putin may have committed what he judged to be a disposable fraction of his conventional forces to set the stage domestically for a campaign to break NATO with a strike NATO could not properly respond to. If the limited campaign went well he could consolidate conquered Ukraine and enact his master plan later. If it seemed difficult he could throttle the campaign sufficiently to entice NATO to part with significant conventional forces and rally domestic Russian support for a bold strike against NATO in response. He may believe Russians will endure the consequences of such a strike against NATO much more easily than they would if the strike had been made with limited NATO "provocation". The plan may even involve China and reports of limited Chinese support may even be intentional dis-information.
I suppose the good news may be we should know in a few weeks if this was really a risk. It is unlikely the time will ever be more ripe for Putin to enact the NATO-breaking component of such a plan. The bad news is that this explanation probably better explains Russian actions and mistakes better than the mainstream newly revealed in 2022 unlimited Russian incompetence explanation
which I otherwise favor.
Leave a comment:
-
I imagine that if Russia fully mobilizes that the US will respond by deploying more troops in Europe (much to China's delight I am sure) and that would hopefully mitigate any fears in the alliance. It is hard to judge what the Russian populace reaction would be imho. That is an interesting question that I am not sure anyone knows how it would play out. I think that with Marshall law he would be better able to control dissent so it might work out. Could this be part of the Russian playbook? A conventional "Escalate to de-escalate" type of thing?Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
I wonder how things will play out if he decides to impose martial law and full mobilization? That would put enormous pressure on Ukraine and might make Ukraine's allies afraid to send equipment that they fear they may need themselves. He might decide that the political downsides of that are far more manageable than the price of outright defeat in Ukraine.
The longer he is in power, the more I believe that Putin's thought process is drastically different than how westerners are used to. Excellent thought food Geronimo!
Leave a comment:
-
I wonder how things will play out if he decides to impose martial law and full mobilization? That would put enormous pressure on Ukraine and might make Ukraine's allies afraid to send equipment that they fear they may need themselves. He might decide that the political downsides of that are far more manageable than the price of outright defeat in Ukraine.Originally posted by PLATO View Post
I doubt he will leave without some severe internal violence. Not sure the Russian people are ready for that yet. They are certainly closer than they were a few months ago though!
Leave a comment:
-
I doubt he will leave without some severe internal violence. Not sure the Russian people are ready for that yet. They are certainly closer than they were a few months ago though!Originally posted by Egbert View PostPutin might be unemployed soon, if things don't improve in the Ukraine.
Leave a comment:
-
NATO Standards call for kicking off an offensive with no less than three full days of supplies. If Ukraine adopted this, then they may well have to take an operational pause to resupply. I agree that the maintaining sufficient supply lines to keep the offensive going is one of the bigger hurdles they have here. Getting over extended invites a Russian counterattack and any type of encirlcement of the Ukrainians would be devastating.Originally posted by N35t0r View PostAt this point the biggest thing holding Ukraine back is not the Russians, it is logistics.
(Edit: although let's be real, this just referring to the NE; in Kherson the Russians seem to be better resisting, if only because of the telegraphed offensive on Ukraine's part. Now they're all on the wrong side of the river with 'tight' logistics, so in all, Ukraine's plan was brilliant, but it will take some time for further advances to be made.
Leave a comment:
-
Let's not forget that it is not just the equipment. There has probably been a lot of much needed ammunition taken as well.Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
Makes me wonder why they weren't being used by the Russians. I suspect the vast majority of these 'donations' had stopped being useable without substantial resupply and repair.
Leave a comment:
-
Even Russian Pro Putin Milbloggers now don't hesitate to criticise the Russian leadership
And Pro Putin TV Hosts (who still insist that everything is a planned move by the Kremlin) sound more and more noncredible (at least for everyone with at least half a brain)
https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/11/e...ont/index.html
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: