Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Uncle Sparky
    replied
    In Russia, Windows crash YOU!

    Leave a comment:


  • dannubis
    replied
    He criticized Putin but had such remorse he felt/was compelled to jumping out of a window.

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Looks like people who do this...

    Shortly after Russia invaded Ukraine, the Lukoil board called for the conflict to end as soon as possible, expressing its sympathy to victims of "this tragedy".
    ...should be particularly careful with any windows

    Lukoil boss Ravil Maganov is the latest Russian businessman to die in mysterious circumstances.




    Leave a comment:


  • N35t0r
    replied
    Ravil Maganov, chairman of Russian oil producer Lukoil, killed in fall from window at Moscow hospital - REU


    Just what is wrong with Russian windows?

    Leave a comment:


  • pchang
    replied
    Berzerker, BeBman, and EPW were quite prescient.

    Leave a comment:


  • Buster Crabbe's Uncle
    replied
    Try clicking on the figure to the right of each option...

    Leave a comment:


  • pchang
    replied
    Is there a way to see who actually voted for which option in the poll?

    Leave a comment:


  • pchang
    replied
    Or cancelling because they want better stuff

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
    Apart from energy and raw materials arms sales are the major revenue source for Russia. I wonder how the war is effecting that? On the one hand buyers like combat proven systems but on the other, AFAIK none of Russia's indigenous arms is demonstrating anything other than disappointing performance. Further, while ordinarily production of arms for domestic use can be increased by greatly scaling up production with an export component, supply chain issues will surely mean exports will often compete for domestic production.

    My guess is Russia will attempt to sell production contracts but deliveries will be greatly delayed in deference to domestic needs.

    Perhap this war will have a long term impact on Russia's presence in the arms market?
    I think that it already is. While the reasons you have given are definitely valid, it seems that sanctions are causing a lot of countries to be hesitant to work with Russia on arms sales and some even cancelling existing orders to avoid being sanctioned themselves.

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBMan View Post

    I certainly thought Russia would make more, and faster progress. How wrong I was

    IIRC there were military folks before the war who thought the war would turn into an endless guerilla style thing when Ukraine's regular military had been defeated.

    But many also pointed out that the estimated no. of troops Russia had on Ukraine's borders in late Feb would simply not be enough to occupy a country of the size of Ukraine, since the invader would need a large numerical advantage over the defender.
    I think those beliefs were based on the U.S. Iraq experience. The U.S. sent in to few troops to offer a real occupation and had to constantly combat an insurgency. The overwhelming firepower advantage made quick work of large scale organized resistance. I think most analyst were assuming that Russia would have a similar experience with Ukraine due to their "on paper" advantages in firepower and doctrine. It turns out that Russia's army was nowhere near the capability that it showed on paper. I guess the opposite could be said of Ukraine's military. Western training for 8 years appears to have made as significant a difference as Western arms supplies at this point to me. I continually see the U.S. military talking about how skillfully the Ukrainians are utilizing what they have.

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    commented on 's reply
    I stand corrected. Thanks EPW!

  • Dauphin
    commented on 's reply
    Quite. The logic would otherwise imply that any assymetric warfare will lead to victory for the bigger and better armed side.

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Apart from energy and raw materials arms sales are the major revenue source for Russia. I wonder how the war is effecting that? On the one hand buyers like combat proven systems but on the other, AFAIK none of Russia's indigenous arms is demonstrating anything other than disappointing performance. Further, while ordinarily production of arms for domestic use can be increased by greatly scaling up production with an export component, supply chain issues will surely mean exports will often compete for domestic production.

    My guess is Russia will attempt to sell production contracts but deliveries will be greatly delayed in deference to domestic needs.

    Perhap this war will have a long term impact on Russia's presence in the arms market?

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    You know things are running well when you buy drones from Iran, and get assault troops from Syria.

    Leave a comment:


  • N35t0r
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    The problem for Ukraine and the enormous advantage for Russia that makes a Russian victory continue to seem inevitable is that while Russia can reach out and destroy almost any part of the Ukrainian economy and infrastructure, Ukraine can barely scratch Russia in return. Russia can maintain an entire large economy with a large military sector and keep sending it into Ukraine but Ukraine is almost totally dependent on foreign aid.

    If Russia out-waits the foreign aid, Ukraine collapses as a state.
    Russia's military industry, even at the beginning of the year, was a shadow of what it was before 2014. And now it's even more degraded. They were supposed to be pumping out T-14s, Su-35s and Su-57s, and they barely have a handful.

    Their industry is running on what they have and can produce, and for a lot of things they lack the capacity to replace or repair, their output and ability to produce will start degrading; and while they might prioritize some industries, it will necessarily be at the expense of others.
    And they can't really roll back to 1970s or 1980s levels of tech, since the equipment and more critically the people who knew those processes are not there anymore.
    It's been barely over 6 months since the heavy sanctions hit, so a lot of the impact isn't being felt yet, but if they keep this up for longer, it will.
    Russia is also showing a marked difficulty in striking at Ukrainian logistics - a lot of missile strikes are hitting civilian targets, and the amount of PGMs launched has been going down constantly since the beginning stages of the war. Which makes sense: Russia lacks the required technology to produce a lot of the state-of-the-art parts in modern (and not-so-modern) precision munitions.

    Of course Ukraine is completely lost without foreign support, but it doesn't seem like that is going away soon. The White House looks eager to throw a lot of money at it, which compared to the overall military budget is not that much, and the Pentagon seems ecstatic to have their weapons be thoroughly field-tested (and against the military they were designed to fight, to boot). With the increasing evidence of Ukraine not folding, they are even getting more comfortable about sending more advanced weapon systems over.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X