Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    I "want to put forward" is at least a little misleading. More like I would be grateful to hear contrary evidence to help dismiss the possibility. You seem to laboring under the assumption that I want such a scenario to be corroborated by evidence rather than dismissed by evidence to the contrary.

    Again, I don't expect such a plan to produce much if any evidence and for the record the idea of a Russian first strike nightmare scenario has been thoroughly discussed and apparently not dismissed by plenty of credible experts.
    To sum up, maybe something happens, maybe not.

    Why should anyone bother to provide "contrary evidence" for something that is - at this moment - a mere possibility?


    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    commented on 's reply
    I'd love to see some of the links about this if it's not too much trouble. I agree that the more valuable the equipment that Russia deploys in large scale in Ukraine the more likely it seems that Putin was committed to winning using conventional forces. On the contrary, the larger the fraction of T-62's and defective crap we find deployed there the more likely a reliance on tactical nukes seems to become. How certain are we for instance, that the reason we don't see T-14 Armatas and stealth fighters is because Russia didn't have any vs holding the best in reserve for the big surprise?

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBMan View Post

    It's not my job to provide or define evidence for something you want to put forward.
    I "want to put forward" is at least a little misleading. More like I would be grateful to hear contrary evidence to help dismiss the possibility. You seem to laboring under the assumption that I want such a scenario to be corroborated by evidence rather than dismissed by evidence to the contrary.

    Again, I don't expect such a plan to produce much if any evidence and for the record the idea of a Russian first strike nightmare scenario has been thoroughly discussed and apparently not dismissed by plenty of credible experts.

    https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/ar...sponse/661315/ - establishes credibility of Russia escalating to a tactical nuclear first strike and the difficulties in a NATO response

    https://nuclearnetwork.csis.org/why-...late-strategy/ - CSIS explaining why we shouldn't expect evidence for any "escalate to descalate" strategy on the part of Russia.

    For starters...

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    what level of evidence would you expect if something like this was actually occurring? It's not at all clear what mix of crap filler equipment and the good stuff Putin would think appropriate for such an operation. Western leaders have already accused Russia of false flag operations. What kind of evidence supports that?
    It's not my job to provide or define evidence for something you want to put forward.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBMan View Post
    I take that as a "no" in regard to my question about evidence.
    what level of evidence would you expect if something like this was actually occurring? It's not at all clear what mix of crap filler equipment and the good stuff Putin would think appropriate for such an operation. Western leaders have already accused Russia of false flag operations. What kind of evidence supports that?

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    I take that as a "no" in regard to my question about evidence.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBMan View Post

    Other than a number of "if" points -- is there any evidence for this grand plan, like a 'disposable' conventional force, etc. etc?

    It rather looks like lotsa text for something that can safely be summed up as "wild speculations" at this point.
    I thought drunken posts and/or wild speculation was the entire point of poly OT?

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    It would purely be directed to the russian audience. The idea being that directly nuking NATO with no 'provocation' would be much too risky to Putin, whereas hand-picking a 'disposable' conventional force to attack along with hand picking filler equipment to pad it out (ie cardboard inserts in armor blocks in tanks that would not have been deployable) would be substantially safer for Putin.

    I don't think this would require super genius of any kind. Just paranoia, extreme confidence (possibly totally unjustified) in Russia's strategic forces and in his assessment of NATO's reaction to the strike as well as a psychotic level of indifference to human suffering. I think Ukraine has demonstrated planning of at least that level of sophistication, minus the depravity so the 'genius' doesn't seem so far fetched for Russia. On the contrary I think such a plan would be one of the stupidest gambles in human history.

    If this really was anything like Putin's plan I'm sure he's realizing that there is no point in wasting much if any more time delaying pulling the trigger...if he values his health.

    For the record I've generally been more likely to dismiss any 'master plan' in favor of the stupidity/incompetence explanation. But that does leave a couple loose ends. Why, for instance if he was planning to do all of the heavy lifting with conventional forces spend so much more money padding out Russia's first strike strategic nuclear forces instead?
    Other than a number of "if" points -- is there any evidence for this grand plan, like a 'disposable' conventional force, etc. etc?

    It rather looks like lotsa text for something that can safely be summed up as "wild speculations" at this point.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    commented on 's reply
    The equipment destroyed (and/or captures) in Ukraina is no filler equipment, but state of the art.
    Actually, in the beginning month, there have even devices been captured which, for russian standards, have been high technology (and AFAIK have been sent to the USA for analysis)

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBMan View Post
    If the grand plan is to trash Russian conventional forces in Ukraine to be perceived as a more credible threat on the nuke front the first part is working really well so far
    It would purely be directed to the russian audience. The idea being that directly nuking NATO with no 'provocation' would be much too risky to Putin, whereas hand-picking a 'disposable' conventional force to attack along with hand picking filler equipment to pad it out (ie cardboard inserts in armor blocks in tanks that would not have been deployable) would be substantially safer for Putin.

    I don't think this would require super genius of any kind. Just paranoia, extreme confidence (possibly totally unjustified) in Russia's strategic forces and in his assessment of NATO's reaction to the strike as well as a psychotic level of indifference to human suffering. I think Ukraine has demonstrated planning of at least that level of sophistication, minus the depravity so the 'genius' doesn't seem so far fetched for Russia. On the contrary I think such a plan would be one of the stupidest gambles in human history.

    If this really was anything like Putin's plan I'm sure he's realizing that there is no point in wasting much if any more time delaying pulling the trigger...if he values his health.

    For the record I've generally been more likely to dismiss any 'master plan' in favor of the stupidity/incompetence explanation. But that does leave a couple loose ends. Why, for instance if he was planning to do all of the heavy lifting with conventional forces spend so much more money padding out Russia's first strike strategic nuclear forces instead?

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    We really need Serb in order to convincingly convey Putins great plan to us

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    If the grand plan is to trash Russian conventional forces in Ukraine to be perceived as a more credible threat on the nuke front the first part is working really well so far

    Leave a comment:


  • pchang
    commented on 's reply
    While you do not oppose supporting Ukraine, you are prone to think Putin is some sort of super genius.

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by PLATO View Post


    Conclusion....Sorry Geronimo, but I think that theory just doesn't hold water.
    Definitely not something I want someone to apologize for. I hate the theory. I just don't dismiss it yet. A month from now, especially if Ukrainian gains continue, then I will more easily dismiss it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Tucker Carlson IIRC has a reputation for opposing support of Ukraine. I could not disagree more. If Ukraine is allowed to lose, then nuclear arms backed blackmail will surely happen again and again until it finally fails and possibly even after that with this successful precedent.

    Ukraine, if at all possible must not be allowed to lose. That doesn't mean I think it will be possible to prevent them losing, much less easy to do so.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X