Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • N35t0r
    replied
    Originally posted by PLATO View Post
    I think the nuke threat is to keep NATO out of the war as Russia pours 300,000 more troops westward from their boarders. Putin is scared s**tless about what NATO troops would do to his ragtag army and is doing what he can to make sure there is no intervention in force. He is doing what he can at this point to keep it a Ukraine-Russia affair.
    This.

    Originally posted by PLATO View Post
    As poorly as I expect these new troops to perform, simply throwing 300,000 bodies at the Ukrainian positions is likely to break them somewhere. This is when the opportunity for a Russian proposed cease fire would be most likely imho.
    Poorly coordinated waves of untrained, under-equipped conscripts during the mud season or in the middle of winter? Seriously doubt they will accomplish much.

    If they get deployed immediately, I expect they will try and shore up the defense around Kherson, but their main issue there are supplies, not men IMO.

    Maybe holding the line so that what is left of Russia's more competent troops can concentrate on one point, but Ukraine will see it coming, so I don't really know what's the final goal. I highly doubt that Ukraine will accept any kind of crease fire, at least in the near term (especially now they have gained the initiative).



    Originally posted by PLATO View Post
    I think Putin wants out of the war and would be willing to keep the lines where they are for it to stop, but in his mind it must stop on a positive to be able to declare victory.
    If he really wanted out, he should have declared Ukraine denazified when Mariupol fell, and then withdrawn. The longer Russia keeps this up, the more difficult it will be for them to sell the victory internally.

    But as long as they have minorities and criminals to conscript and send to the front, they don't really care about the losses.

    The other critical issue is the economy. Oil is down to January price levels, and Russia has just imposed export tariffs for a lot of products (including oil and gas). This is not the sign of a healthy budget. Mobilization will also put another damper on the economy, accelerating the effect sanctions have caused.

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post
    Sooooo... this could have been over in April but the British PM undoubtedly with Biden's support killed the peace deal
    Sure...Ukraine could have just said "Yes, of course! You can have 20% of our territory for peace!" Instead they chose to say, "With the West's help, we will take back all of our land and defend our people from becoming your victims of torture and murder."

    How stupid of them to think they should defend their country! How stupid of the West to help their ally when they are unjustly attacked! How utterly unfathomable that anyone should challenge Russia!

    Good Grief....

    Leave a comment:


  • N35t0r
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post
    Sooooo... this could have been over in April but the British PM undoubtedly with Biden's support killed the peace deal
    lol, no

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    I think the nuke threat is to keep NATO out of the war as Russia pours 300,000 more troops westward from their boarders. Putin is scared s**tless about what NATO troops would do to his ragtag army and is doing what he can to make sure there is no intervention in force. He is doing what he can at this point to keep it a Ukraine-Russia affair.

    As poorly as I expect these new troops to perform, simply throwing 300,000 bodies at the Ukrainian positions is likely to break them somewhere. This is when the opportunity for a Russian proposed cease fire would be most likely imho.

    I think Putin wants out of the war and would be willing to keep the lines where they are for it to stop, but in his mind it must stop on a positive to be able to declare victory.

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    replied
    Sooooo... this could have been over in April but the British PM undoubtedly with Biden's support killed the peace deal

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    commented on 's reply
    Russians dont need Putin to educate them about Nazis

  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by BlackCat View Post
    Some more reasonable talk



    It would be interesting to hear Serbs comments to it
    Re brinkmanship, there are some comments now from Ru officials which seem to retract/clarify some of Putin's nuke comments:

    Reuters is carrying a little more detail on those quotes from Russian deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov. It quotes him saying:
    We are not threatening anyone with nuclear weapons. The criteria for their use are outlined in Russia’s military doctrine. We hope the Biden administration is also aware of the danger of an uncontrolled escalation of the conflict in Ukraine.

    Reuters notes that under Russia’s nuclear doctrine, use of nuclear weapons is permitted if Moscow feels it faces as “existential threat”.
    This is from the Guardian's news stream since people can only read limited amounts of stuff at Reuters directly without subscription or so.

    However, I think ramping up the nuke rhetoric makes less sense as long as they think mobilization etc. is going to have a positive effect (if they really think that is another q'). Also India and China don't seem to be amused in recent times about the whole situation.

    If that changes again to get more hot I dunno. Me thinks if the guy from the vid is right, and mobilization was not Putin's first choice, rather something to keep militarist ultra right wing bloggers onboard I could also see how he's uncomfortable with the nuke card, as these guys are calling for it mostly (well they and Medvedev, which seems to be obsessed now to prove that he's reaaaaally tough, and not "liberal" as he was described as years ago).

    Unless he's so weak now that he has to give ground on this point too. But it's easy to call for nukes when you're a blogger, not so easy to do it when you're the one facing the consequences.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    That might work if attempted in an empire of mindless zombies but until now the Russian government has been quite obsessed with convincing a decisive majority of the population that its strategies made some kind of sense in serving the interests of the population.
    I think that has been abandoned or is being abandoned in favour of serving the interest of keeping Putin in power. The mask is falling now because it is only now that the two are in direct empirical contradiction.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by PLATO View Post

    It is being sold at the end of a
    That might work if attempted in an empire of mindless zombies but until now the Russian government has been quite obsessed with convincing a decisive majority of the population that its strategies made some kind of sense in serving the interests of the population.

    Leave a comment:


  • BlackCat
    replied
    Some more reasonable talk



    It would be interesting to hear Serbs comments to it

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
    I just can't see how mobilization can be sold to the Russian population purely to secure land from Ukraine and to defeat it militarily.
    It is being sold at the end of a gun barrel

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    What is the official explanation for how not defeating Ukraine could constitute an existential crisis for a country the size of Russia? If it's just an explanation that Russia next to free hostile ukraine would be easier to attack than Russia next to occupied hostile ukraine wouldn't a campaign of global conquest be the logical extension of such reasoning?

    I just can't see how mobilization can be sold to the Russian population purely to secure land from Ukraine and to defeat it militarily.

    Leave a comment:


  • N35t0r
    replied
    And workers at rocket factories (the Krunichev center, which builds the Angara and Proton medium-lift rockets), airline employees and apparently college students (although not a lot of evidence for this last one, the info I got was that it was in Siberia).

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by N35t0r View Post
    Not only protestors, but also pro-putin counter-demonstrators were arrested and forcibly conscripted
    That sounds great ...
    I hope the Pro-Putin counterdemonstrators enjoy, that they now have the opportunity to directly serve their lord and master on the battlefield

    Leave a comment:


  • N35t0r
    replied
    Not only protestors, but also pro-putin counter-demonstrators were arrested and forcibly conscripted

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X