Hobbit Reivews

[Robert]

They could at least go to the damn border or something, then try to get in.

That'd be like: "Woooohoooo Sauron, here are a couple of Hobbits with a ring but we're only dropping them at your border! No worries pal!"

[Alexander's Horse]

all I know is the wizards are holding out on the heroes.

[Straybow]

With the knowledge of behind it's easy to talk.
But at that moment it was nothing more then just walking ahead ;-)

It isn't hindsight, it is map reading. You said, "but that would only have saved some couple of days walking." It was not a "couple days" to go.

The eagles flew them nearly a hundred miles, and it was another 250+ miles to Erebor. From Hobbiton to Rivendell took them 38 days at about 10 miles a day, so it was about another month of foot travel from there.

[Ogie Oglethorpe]

Not to mention they lost their ponies by that point, so survival via foraging on foot was assured.

[Alexander's Horse]

lazy eagles

[Ogie Oglethorpe]

they were from philly. They can never close the deal.

[Alexander's Horse]

Speer been talking to em