Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Oh look, Apolyton is on Wiki...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by Thue View Post
    I see that Grandpa Troll has added some text to the Wikipedia article. But it will have to be rewritten or deleted, because of its wrong style. Articles must be written in Neutral Point of View, so formulations like "Expansion packs for many games have kept our fanbase growing" are right out. Wikipedia is not Apolyton's online advertising space.

    Also, because of the importance of being able to assume good faith, The login "Grandpa Troll" has been blocked. It is kind of hard to assume good faith when the login clearly says the editor is a troll. Yes, I realize that Grandpa Troll had no intention of trolling Wikipedia, and that we are not assuming good faith in blocking his username .

    Really?

    So I need to sayneutral instead of our, my bad

    I will go to see about fixing it

    thanks for the headsup, my first attempt.

    Gramps
    Hi, I'm RAH and I'm a Benaholic.-rah

    Comment


    • #17
      Originally posted by Thue View Post
      I see that Grandpa Troll has added some text to the Wikipedia article. But it will have to be rewritten or deleted, because of its wrong style. Articles must be written in Neutral Point of View, so formulations like "Expansion packs for many games have kept our fanbase growing" are right out. Wikipedia is not Apolyton's online advertising space.

      Also, because of the importance of being able to assume good faith, The login "Grandpa Troll" has been blocked. It is kind of hard to assume good faith when the login clearly says the editor is a troll. Yes, I realize that Grandpa Troll had no intention of trolling Wikipedia, and that we are not assuming good faith in blocking his username .

      Thue, I tried sending unblock but seems they didnt like GrandpaT eiether

      Im alittle confused, do you know much about Wiki?

      I guess I need to changed completely away from Grandpa then?

      In addition, yes, i see now my phrasing should be neutral

      Do you know anything else I may have done inadvertently incorrect?

      Also, am i to assume one cannot link to Poly?

      How abouthe the Podcasts we do here, is it allowed to share that Apolyton has them (three) as long as it is in the neutral verbage?

      Thanks, I tried to contact someone but my IP is blocked

      Bruce
      Hi, I'm RAH and I'm a Benaholic.-rah

      Comment


      • #18
        Everything has to be verifiable on wikipedia.

        NO GOOD

        Apolyton is the most LEET Civ 2 site on the interwebs.

        GOOD:

        Sid Meier in an interview with gamespy said, "Apolyton is the most LEET Civ 2 site on the interwebs" [1]

        [1]: www.gamespy.article_71234.com
        Scouse Git (2) La Fayette Adam Smith Solomwi and Loinburger will not be forgotten.
        "Remember the night we broke the windows in this old house? This is what I wished for..."
        2015 APOLYTON FANTASY FOOTBALL CHAMPION!

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
          bad link
          Order of the Fly

          Comment


          • #20
            Or in another example.

            BAD:

            Calgary fans are the worst bandwagoners in the NHL

            GOOD

            On CBC April 16th, 2009, Coach Mike Keenan was quoted as saying, "Calgary fans are the worst bandwagoners in the NHL" [1]

            NPOV doesn't really matter so long as it is verified. If you wanted to pull the quote, you'd have to argue that it was peripheral to the subject matter at hand. If the page were 'Calgary Flames', then yes, you could do that. But if there was a page called 'Calgary Flames Fans', then yes it would be pertinent.
            Scouse Git (2) La Fayette Adam Smith Solomwi and Loinburger will not be forgotten.
            "Remember the night we broke the windows in this old house? This is what I wished for..."
            2015 APOLYTON FANTASY FOOTBALL CHAMPION!

            Comment


            • #21
              Originally posted by Grandpa Troll View Post
              Thue, I tried sending unblock but seems they didnt like GrandpaT eiether

              Im alittle confused, do you know much about Wiki?

              I guess I need to changed completely away from Grandpa then?
              It seems you have been caught in a bit of overzealous automated blocking, because you are using the IP of a recently blocked account. The admin who blocked GrandpaTroll used too strict settings, IMO. I am an administrator on the English Wikipedia, and have just unblocked GrandpaT, so it should work now.

              In addition, yes, i see now my phrasing should be neutral

              Do you know anything else I may have done inadvertently incorrect?
              Much of the content seems ok, but the tone is all wrong

              Expansion packs for many games have kept our fanbase growing, modders busy expanding game play and players involved in Pitboss games, Democracy Games, PBEM as well as single player epic struggles to dominate the world.

              Would be much more acceptable (I think) as

              Apolyton and the Apolyton forums also covers game expansions, hosts game modders, Pitboss games, Democracy games, PBEM games, and single player challenges.

              Now it doesn't sound like an ad created by an Apolyton staffer .

              Same with the other three paragraphs. They just need a bit of change of tone.

              Also, am i to assume one cannot link to Poly?
              Links to poly should be fine. Normally (but not strictly always), you should use the same format as in the trivia section where the [2] points to a link in the "references" section. Look at the source of the trivia section to see how this is done.

              Alternatively, links to poly belongs in the "external links" section.

              How abouthe the Podcasts we do here, is it allowed to share that Apolyton has them (three) as long as it is in the neutral verbage?

              Thanks, I tried to contact someone but my IP is blocked

              Bruce
              Linking to the podcasts sounds fine to me.
              http://www.hardware-wiki.com - A wiki about computers, with focus on Linux support.

              Comment


              • #22
                I never knew you're a Wiki admin, Thue

                Gramps, many thanks for the effort. As we've mentioned even a couple of years ago, improvements to the Wiki article would certainly be much welcome.
                Solver, WePlayCiv Co-Administrator
                Contact: solver-at-weplayciv-dot-com
                I can kill you whenever I please... but not today. - The Cigarette Smoking Man

                Comment


                • #23
                  Ok, I am in, posted a short blurb about the three podcasts we are involved in, hopefully this is ok, I am sure someone is watching me since I just got unbanned


                  Funny thing, I saw Thue's comments yesterday, so i went to action, tried many different names to see if one would be acceptable (including first choice which thanks to you Thue is ok) but anyhow, today i went to get on as MrCiv was an alternate choice and someone had bklocked me because, of all thing, abuse of too many accounts?/

                  But Im sure they dont know me, I was merely trying to work around Grandpa Troll

                  Ok

                  I hope Thue, you could share, im not trying to cause a problem, i promise slow and sure, just trying to help out Apolyton certainly not spam or undermine Wiki

                  Thanks again for assisting Thue

                  Gramps
                  Hi, I'm RAH and I'm a Benaholic.-rah

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X