Greatest Conquerors in History - Hurt or Heal

[Zoid]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui
Rule 1 says:

You can add 2 points and deduct 2 points each vote.

It doesn't say must. It says can. So I choose to deduct but not add .

You're using the letter of the rule to defeat the spirit of the rule...

[Imran Siddiqui]

"I have come not to abolish [the laws] but to fulfil them"

[LordShiva]

50 Genghis +
70 Alexander -

[Nugog]

52 Genghis ++
68 Alexander - -

[Heraclitus]

50 Genghis -2
70 Alexander +2

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui
Rule 1 says:

You can add 2 points and deduct 2 points each vote.

It doesn't say must. It says can. So I choose to deduct but not add .

That also throws off our nifty power graphs

[EPW]

52 Genghis +2
68 Alexander -2

[Imran Siddiqui]

Originally posted by Geronimo
That also throws off our nifty power graphs

Call it Nappy's revenge .

[LordShiva]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui


Call it Nappy's revenge being a sore loser .

Fixed

[Geronimo]

Might just as well call an end to this contest then. We didn't bother deciding between the last two for the greatest civs thread either. We can add back the points imran removed for teh purposes of teh power graph.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Oh, stop being silly, it allows the game to end quicker .

Then again, you can call it for Alexander as he has most points and is almost certainly going to win if you go all the way to the end (unless most of the pro-Alexander people suffer horrible accidents which prevents posting).

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui
Oh, stop being silly, it allows the game to end quicker .

Then again, you can call it for Alexander as he has most points and is almost certainly going to win if you go all the way to the end (unless most of the pro-Alexander people suffer horrible accidents which prevents posting).

I'm not certain which is teh "greater" of the two anyway. It depends on how I compare them. So I'd be ok with it getting called for alexander.

[Zoid]

Alexander!

[EPW]

54 Genghis +2
66 Alexander -2

[LordShiva]

56 Genghis +2
64 Alexander -2