Greatest Civilization in the World - Hurt or Heal?

[aneeshm]

And I propose that once a winner is decided, we play the game again, but without that Civ in the list. That way, the results won't be affected by the politicking going on around that candidate.

[aneeshm]

Originally posted by Kataphraktoi


Thats what i hate about the arab\muslim thing. Dozens of cultures, religions, and other groups are steamrolled and the entire areas historical culture is annihilated. Cool empires like persia, egypt, and the like come to an abrupt and final ending here. Sure other countries have destroyed in the same way but few in so large an area. Ofcourse USA did this to the NA, but 1million NA continents qould be worth 1 Mediterainiens IMO in terms of being interesting

Hit the nail on the head.

But India was also affected. Ever wonder why India didn't produce much in the way of revolutionary ideas, new paradigms, or massive shifts in human thought, in the last thousand years, whereas this was regular occurrence before the consolidation of Muslim rule (prior to that, it was a general rule that, every fifty years or so, India would come up with something which would completely kick ass, and totally change forever some or the other field of human endeavour)?

But precisely because India was affected, and I thus have a bias, I will not vote against Arabia or for India.

My vote is as follows:

11 - USA
14 – Germany +2
23 - England/Britain
18 - France -2
12 - Spain
29 - Rome
28 - Greece
25 - Egypt
9 – Persia
6 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
6 - Japan

[EPW]

11 - USA
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome +2
28 - Greece
25 - Egypt
9 – Persia
6 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
4 - Japan -2

[Hueij]

9 - USA -
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
28 - Greece
27 - Egypt +
9 – Persia
6 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
4 - Japan

[OzzyKP]

10 - USA +1
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
28 - Greece
27 - Egypt
9 – Persia
7 – Arabia +1
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
2 - Japan -2

[RGBVideo]

10 - USA
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
28 - Greece
27 - Egypt
9 – Persia
5 – Arabia -2
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
4 - Japan +2

[Nikolai]

12 - USA +
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
28 - Greece
27 - Egypt
9 – Persia
5 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
2 - Japan -

[Patroklos]

14 - USA
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
28 - Greece
27 - Egypt
9 – Persia
5 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India
0 - Japan

[Will9]

14 - USA
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
31 - Rome
26 - Greece -2
29 - Egypt +2
9 – Persia
5 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India

[LordShiva]

14 - USA
14 – Germany
23 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
29 - Rome -2
26 - Greece
29 - Egypt
11 – Persia +2
5 – Arabia
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India

[Maquiladora]

14 - USA
14 – Germany
25 - England/Britain +2
18 - France
12 - Spain
29 - Rome
26 - Greece
29 - Egypt
11 – Persia
3 – Arabia -2
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India

[Nikolai]

Keep away from my Arabs!

[Kuciwalker]

16 - USA +2
14 – Germany
25 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
29 - Rome
26 - Greece
29 - Egypt
11 – Persia
1 – Arabia -2
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India

[OzzyKP]

[Wernazuma III]

14 - USA -2
14 – Germany
25 - England/Britain
18 - France
12 - Spain
29 - Rome
26 - Greece
29 - Egypt
11 – Persia
3 – Arabia +2
10 – Babylon
19 - China
20 - India

Take that GW, yours truly, OBL.