Originally posted by Ned
Alireza, I'm having a hard time pinning down what you are for. You seem to be for everything that OBL is for except that you say you are against fundamentalism and OBL.
Are you in favor of democracies in Islamic countries? If so, you will find that the United States and Europe, for that matter, are on your side and are not your enemy.
The problem I see though is that you seem to place Islam and not democracy at the center of your political beliefs. This is why I think in the end you are in Osama bin Laden's camp.
Alireza, I'm having a hard time pinning down what you are for. You seem to be for everything that OBL is for except that you say you are against fundamentalism and OBL.
Are you in favor of democracies in Islamic countries? If so, you will find that the United States and Europe, for that matter, are on your side and are not your enemy.
The problem I see though is that you seem to place Islam and not democracy at the center of your political beliefs. This is why I think in the end you are in Osama bin Laden's camp.
Dont try to see everything in black and white.
If I prefer islam to be a political factor, I dont have to be ending up with Osama. Osama is a scandalous appearance and his beliefs are totally blasphemous when compared with the kuran. I am in favor of SECULARISM and DEMOCRACY in the islamic countries. But that doesnt mean I have to abandon my culture and religion or even give up my sympathy with other muslims and translate that sympathy into pragmatic political and economic cooperation. But I look further than the religious label. It is all about politics, about resources and strategy.
Read my words:
The west is AGAINST democracy and freedom in the islamic world. This might come as a shock but it is so. The west only acts as a guardian of democracy, but in fact, in only cares about its own. Why? Because the misery in the muslim world is good for western economies. Our weakness is very important for the continuing exploitation of our countries, if we were strong, the wests interests in our countries would not be the wests interests anymore, it would be OUR interests, and the west couldnt exploit them anymore but pay for them dearly. The last thing the west is waiting for, is the emergance of yet a new economic and political block which happens to be at a negative stance with the west. (not forgetting the historical factor) So our misery is your blessing.
Yes our misery produces terrorists, loose bullets who have lost all hope and patience and take the law in own hands. But the USA and Europe would rather have terrorists (which happen to help western PR in the world very very very much!) than a sophisticated power against her which would really endanger the western position in the world. Now, Asia (China) is fulfilling this role bit by bit, but we muslims will use this shifting of power for our own interests.
YOU are against democracy and freedom in our countries.
The fact is that everytime a great leader stood up to promote more institutional reforms towards more democracy and certainly secularism
(Nasser, Faysal, Mohammad Reza Shah,Arafat,Bourguiba,Qadaffi) you take stance against them because they have firm anti-western political beliefs (which is understandable after centuries of exploitation) without looking at the actual things they stand for. Well my advice to you is to take the bitter pill and understand that democracy in our countries will result in more anti-western governments.
But at least you will have real opponents and a more equal political and economical balance.
Or you may let the fundamentalists take over, like you did in so many countries
Think about it and then you will realize.
The media, your governments , your public opinion is all biased and focused on bashing islam and muslims, you dont have any positive criticism at all. Those people who really try to do something are bashed with the fundamentalists alltogether. No problem, we can take care for ourselves.
Comment