Israel's New Plan - Punish the families

[Ming]

Hmmm... let's see...

On one side, terrrorists blow up innocent people...

On the other side, the government throws their families out of their homes...

While both are in the wrong, you pick which side is more wrong

[Imran Siddiqui]

Lets say that Isreal withdrew to those borders today and did not reenter them. do you think that the viloence will stop? Do you think that Hamas and those like them be satisfied.

I think that MOST of the terrorist bombings would stop. I think some crazies would try to something, but it would be a rarity. Once the Palestinians have some hope, they won't kill themselves. That should be obvious.

[Solver]

Ming, since when are both wrong? Only ones are wrong. Though this time even I'm not quite happy, this will most probably cause all those brother and sisters to make belts of bombs and blow something up, too.

[Ned]

Originally posted by chegitz guevara
Ned, you are aware I'm not a Stalinist, and that real communism is punishable by death in most "Communist" countries?

OK, I apologize.

[Imran Siddiqui]

You really don't pay attention much, do you Ned?

Calling che a Stalinist? That's a newbie mistake .

[Ming]

Originally posted by Solver
Ming, since when are both wrong?

Hmmm... they call it "guilty" without proof or trial.
This is just wrong... period.

While I can understand why they are doing it, and what they "hope" to accomplish, it is still WRONG. And if you can't see that...

[TheBirdMan]

-->Chegitz.

Sure all know - or should know. Utopia exists only in the mind of folks - and as a game.

Real communism wouldn't be that bad at all - just a pitty it will not be anymore than a theory - because we (the socalled target talking marketing), are all humans (or close to anyway).

[Lord Merciless]

This is just another step in the escalation of violence. Let's see how worse things can still get.

[Solver]

Israelis call some people guilty, not looking at proofs. Palestenians call all Israelis guilty. What's better?

[Imran Siddiqui]

Neither.

[Lefty Scaevola]

Israel officilly stated policy of the possible deportations is
"A Justice Ministry official stressed the men could only be expelled if they were directly linked to acts of terrorism. "

of coursed 'linked" is a very vague term term and leave much wiggle room for abuse.

[Ming]

Originally posted by Solver
Israelis call some people guilty, not looking at proofs. Palestenians call all Israelis guilty. What's better?

You should learn how to read...

[Az]

Let's just say that I am not sure that this is the right way to go.

[Chris 62]

This seems like the inevitable responce to the the money given to the families of suicide bombers by Saddam and some others.

There had to be some reponce to that after time, the reward (in Israel's mind) system for murder.

[chequita guevara]

Couldn't they have just seized the money?