Actually, doing such a thing wouldn't be without precedent. In 1959, Willie McCovey won the NL award with only 192 AB (in which he hit 354/429/656).
I think the combo of not overwhelming advantages in offensive stats for Youklis, combined with the much lower number of ABs, and the much greater defense by Crosby, swings it for Crosby easily.
That doesn't mean Youklis won't be the better player... he just didn't get enough time in with the big boys this year.
Comment