Originally posted by Ned
Drogue, Perhaps your characterization of Austro-Candian-European politics is accurate. But I think you say to much when you characterize this axis as the "rest of the world." By any standard, the Muslim world is far more conservative than any Republican. Ditto the Hindus of India. Even the Communist Party in China is more conservative than the Republican Party.
Drogue, Perhaps your characterization of Austro-Candian-European politics is accurate. But I think you say to much when you characterize this axis as the "rest of the world." By any standard, the Muslim world is far more conservative than any Republican. Ditto the Hindus of India. Even the Communist Party in China is more conservative than the Republican Party.
Originally posted by Ned
It would be better to define your frame of reference before you start calling the Republicans far-right.
It would be better to define your frame of reference before you start calling the Republicans far-right.
The main difference between the US political specturm and the Europe/Aus/Canada one is that the Democrats would be a centre-right party, although they are progressive. They believe in a lower tax and less regulated system than centre opinion in Europe, Australia and Canada, whereas in the US they seem to be a centrist, even slightly leftist party.
I don't believe the Republicans are far right in the sense of Facism. I do believe they are economically quite far right, in that the levels of tax, welfare and regulation they desire is lower than the centre right parties of Europe.
The Democrats remind me a lot of our New Labour (progressive, the leaders of which being centre-right, on our scale, but the opinion of individual party members being from far-left to centre-right) while the Republicans seem like our Conservative party, but with lower tax, lower welfare, less regulation and stronger in their conservative views. The point I was making is not that the Republicans are far right and authoritarian, but that the Dems are not a leftist party by the standards which most of the developed world lives. Thus, at least for Euro/Aus/Canada, AH's comments were true.
I just want you to stop strawmanning people who say that the Dems are centre-right and the Republicans are right but saying that they believe they are a far right party. I doubt many here would think of the Repugs as a Fascist style, far-right party. But economically, as the linear right-left would usually mean when accompanied by a conservative/progressive that would explain their social views.
Comment