What religion are you?

[Spec]

Originally posted by lord of the mark
I dont know about cars, but id ask about them before id set up a poll about them that required some knowledge of them.

You'd take that much time just to post a meaningless poll? Well, I dont do that.

Spec.

[KrazyHorse]

Originally posted by Spec


There are differences. Like they dont beleive that Mary was a virgin.

Spec.

You're mixing up Christian and Catholic.

[lord of the mark]

Originally posted by Azazel
I am a jew. What does have to do with God?

I DID say that Spec had a category error. Even to the most Orthodox jew - well especially to the most orthodox Jew - an agnostic can still be a jew

Oh, did i insult you by calling you an agnostic, instead of an atheist.

Beg pardon.

[Az]

It's the other side of the Jack Chick coin!

[Imran Siddiqui]

I DID say that Spec had a category error. Even to the most Orthodox jew - well especially to the most orthodox Jew - an agnostic can still be a jew

But the rest of us don't consider that a category error .

[Dis]

I wonder if the virgin mary was hot.

[KrazyHorse]

Goddamn it. You folks need to come up with a term for ethnicity which is different from the term for religion...

[KrazyHorse]

Originally posted by Dissident
I wonder if the virgin mary was hot.

If she was, she wouldn't have been a virgin. Duh.

[Dis]

good point

[KrazyHorse]

Although I guess she was good enough for God to **** her.

Maybe He just has low standards.

[Bereta_Eder]

krazyhorse out of curioxity whats your mother language? is it french or english?

[KrazyHorse]

English

But my mother's mother tongue is French.

[lord of the mark]

Originally posted by KrazyHorse
Goddamn it. You folks need to come up with a term for ethnicity which is different from the term for religion...

But as Abraham Joshua Heschel said, Israel is NOT one species of the genus "nation" it is the ONLY species of the genus "israel".


Am israel - the people israel - who are called to the worship the god of israel, and follow the Torah of Israel, which constiture Emunah Israel - the faith of Israel (not to be confused with the country from which Az hails - Eretz Israel - or the state of which he is a citizen - Medinat Israel)

But its ok KKH - jews have been wrestling with this religion ethnicity thing for the last 150 years or so - problem is "religion" as such is a Western category, not a Jewish one (and similarly for east asians, I think leading to issues with Taoism, etc)

[KrazyHorse]

Which means you believe that people aren't really free to choose what they believe, no?

You can't choose ethnicity, but you can choose religion.

[oedo]

Originally posted by Dissident
bah! this poll does not have agnostic

choose bananeist, just like I did. I think this is closest to agnostic.