Rommel or Guderian?

[Imran Siddiqui]

i have yet to hear of a conqueror that gets all the hunnies and smokes alot of reefer.

Duh! Alexander, man .

[Mr. Harley]

Genghis Khan. Shared the same kind of sunny disposition as Alexander .

[Panag]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui

tankramps to get on the beach use about the same amount of concrete the wall till the top would need , ......

and as for the rest , get the facts first

So the tankramps would have taken the same amount of concrete that the wall did and you are saying since they weren't built he was a bad general? What?

I do have the facts, obviously you don't. Or you were dropped on your head as a child!

I do wonder who panag considers to be a good general in WW2, especially from the German side. Or does he think no German general was good at all? I wonder then how they had an empire that spread from close to Moscow all the way to Southern France.

he himself ( rommel ) ask the todd organisation to build them , yet when he signs himself the plans they are not there , later he after june 44 several people shall blaim him for that , ......

as for a german empire ,

resistance was everywhere and he never reached moscow , why , cause they where not prepared , ....... a good general prepares BEFORE he goes to war , ........

they never where able to control the med , they where never able to get rid of Malta and Gibraltar , huge mistakes on the tactical level , .......... any serious general would now this , .....

and since they did not went to the south of france from the start , pffffffff

one can fill pages with the german mistakes , they came , yeah , but is was over in no time , ..... if they where any good like in the battle of the bulge they would have stayed around for a bit more , .......

mistakes , one after an other is all the german high command ever did , .........

what a bunch of jokers , .........