The Dance of Civilizations [Diplo Game] [Organization Thread Pt1]

[Rasputin]

I agree with Ras.

and especially now it must be open vote otherwise everyone wil know woh blackknight is in game.

[Black Knight 427]

I agree with Ras.

[Rasputin]

why ws vote done in DoC accoutnts.

I firmly believe all Rule Votes needs to be out in the open, especially so any rule changes can not be responded to as an in game action

forget that everyone klnows who i am, and i know for this change it wont happend, but wha tif a no voter one time gets peeved off and decides to take out on a in game yes voter.

i firmly think RULEs changes need to be by apolyton accounts.

[Arabia (DoC)]

I vote yes to the rule change and ask that when ever there are important votes that a PM and or email is sent saying check thread vote required.

[mzprox]

@St Jon: when I was Greece in BtP I wrote 'honour', etc. only to mislead others Perhaps I'm doing it again
I just installed an english spell checker on Firefox

Don't try too hard, I have a good guess on every BtP's player identity in DoC.. only assumptions ofc so suprise me

[Persia (DoC)]

I don't care and abstain.

[Robert]

Vote: (use DoC account to vote) Do you agree with the suggested rule change? (explained more then lengthy in the posts above)

YES: 9 (100% of voters)
- India
- Byzantium
- Mali
- England
- Egypt
- Rome
- Greece
- Inca
- Natives

NO: 0

Abstain: 2
- unknown civ
- unknown civ


@St Jon: when I was Greece in BtP I wrote 'honour', etc. only to mislead others Perhaps I'm doing it again
I just installed an english spell checker on Firefox

[St Jon]

Everyone else seems to know who Raz is anyway. I don't, but then I reckon I can work it out without too much trouble.

There will always be the problem in anonymity that it's quite easy to tell who people aren't. Priest and I are English, and literate, which means that simply by using 'our' rather than 'or' with 'honour' or 'neighbour' etc, makes it easy to remove us from the American players. It's a matter of trying harder to keep anonymity than trying to crack it even though the latter is far easier.

[Native America (DoC)]

I voted Yes, but seems to have disappeared.

[Robert]

That's why I asked to vote only using the DoC id.
I can't undo it that they didn't
Leaving their names out will most probably not help.

Not to mention that we can't be sure that they didn't vote using their DoC account, but just didn't tell us to not reveal their ID. After all their posts weren't much more then "I don't care".

But I'll leave their names out of the results from now on.

[Byzantium (DoC)]

RP - I think you need to be careful with the publishing teh lists of teh votes because gradually we are all learning which nations Raz and Black Knight aren't

[Inca (DoC)]

Take my name from no's and put it with yes's as I dont care much. I dont understand why gmail is better as voting is secret already and results are public. I will never logon to gmail so nothing that is important posted there will be read by me. I will vote and maybe i will look at the result sometimes but PM's are OK for me in all game chat.

[Robert]

Vote: (use DoC account to vote) Do you agree with the suggested rule change? (explained more then lengthy in the posts above)

YES: 8 (100% of voters)
- India
- Byzantium
- Mali
- England
- Egypt
- Rome
- Greece
- Inca

NO: 0

Abstain: 2
- Black Knight*
- Rasputin*

[Greece (DoC)]

we can........

[Rome (DoC)]

Yes