FG:Mafia 68: The Wedding Guest of Doom

[Adagio]

Originally posted by Spaced Cowboy
Yes, you were acting like the mafia, normally you enlighten us with some reason for your vote

It's been some time since I last did that, in the last few games I have mostly just voted without giving any reason (or just agreeing with other reasoning)

Just look at my voting in Mafia 66... In none of those I give a reason for my vote:

Originally posted by Adagio
Calypso is to be blamed for this

Originally posted by Adagio
Elizabeth Swann

Originally posted by Adagio
Jack Sparrow is the one we're looking for

Originally posted by Adagio
It's the Monkey

Originally posted by Adagio
Commodore Norrington

Originally posted by Adagio
Cutler Beckett it is

[rah]

Damn out of town again for the final weekend.

I loved all the red herrings.

Amusing that everyone would think it was the person that
1. Wasn't on the sign up sheet.
2. Didn't know he is the game till well after it was started.
3. was obviously absent from the site for most of the game (which is why i didn't sign up)

But I guess in a paranoid group like mafia, it could have been seen as a stratagy.

Good game, lots of clues but not obvious. Well done.
Congrats

[Adagio]

Originally posted by rah
Amusing that everyone would think it was the person that
1. Wasn't on the sign up sheet.
2. Didn't know he is the game till well after it was started.
3. was obviously absent from the site for most of the game (which is why i didn't sign up)

Yeah, I was pretty surprised that I managed to get the other play to vote for you in the last round

Originally posted by rah
But I guess in a paranoid group like mafia, it could have been seen as a stratagy.

Than God for that, otherwise I couldn't have won

[Rasputin]

Originally posted by rah
Damn out of town again for the final weekend.

I loved all the red herrings.

Amusing that everyone would think it was the person that
1. Wasn't on the sign up sheet.
2. Didn't know he is the game till well after it was started.
3. was obviously absent from the site for most of the game (which is why i didn't sign up)

But I guess in a paranoid group like mafia, it could have been seen as a stratagy.

Good game, lots of clues but not obvious. Well done.
Congrats

Yes once i saw rah was not around i made the decision to make all Red Herrings keep pointing at him in an obvious way, and yet use them to subtly point at the real mafia, it meant everyone either docpiled Rah or ignored Adagio (ADG/bADGer) clues. it worked well

Sorry for the incriminations Rich!

[Hercules]

Originally posted by Rasputin


Yes once i saw rah was not around i made the decision to make all Red Herrings keep pointing at him in an obvious way, and yet use them to subtly point at the real mafia, it meant everyone either docpiled Rah or ignored Adagio (ADG/bADGer) clues. it worked well

Sorry for the incriminations Rich!

Yes that's why you're such a clever GM RAZ .

[Kataphraktoi]

Well the first rah clues were obviously red herrings. When they continued i wondered if he was using the 'hide in plain sight' strategy.

So i never ignored the ADG clues. I never saw them I did see the secret briefcase and noted the method of death was unknown, but didnt connect it infact it was one of the first things i noticed, but i wrote it off as story flavor

[Spaced Cowboy]

Originally posted by Adagio


It's been some time since I last did that, in the last few games I have mostly just voted without giving any reason (or just agreeing with other reasoning)

Just look at my voting in Mafia 66... In none of those I give a reason for my vote:

Yes, but how many were 1st vote?

[Adagio]

Originally posted by Spaced Cowboy
Yes, but how many were 1st vote?

Probably none, but that doesn't mean anything. The reason I voted first was to get the game going (no votes for a long time), I would have done the same if I wasn't the mafia. The other game was a bit faster than this game as far as I remember

[Spaced Cowboy]

but my point is that to vote first and not arrouse suspicion, one must look to pur forward some type of clue that point to someone.

[Adagio]

While it might be the best thing to do, not everybody does it all the time
Specially not after more than a day since the kill was made, as that usually means that nobody has been able to find any clues at all

[Rasputin]

Originally posted by Kataphraktoi
Well the first rah clues were obviously red herrings. When they continued i wondered if he was using the 'hide in plain sight' strategy.

So i never ignored the ADG clues. I never saw them I did see the secret briefcase and noted the method of death was unknown, but didnt connect it infact it was one of the first things i noticed, but i wrote it off as story flavor

very little is usually story flavour, it is either RED HERRINGS or Clues!!

Just a little tip for next time