Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Moral Arc

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Upending people's lives, forcing them to choose between being able to get married or keeping their jobs, homes, land, or proximity to family/friends is not acceptable.
    Really? Tell that to Barronelle Stutzmann. Apparently it's perfectly a-ok to force people to choose between their conscience and keeping their business.

    If this was a "might" for heterosexual marriages there would be barricades in the streets. You'd be firmly against it. Anyone sane would be.
    Actually, it has already happened. There's been cases where the actual mother has lost custody to her 'partner' who has no biological relation to the child. Look at the Miller vs Jenkins case. Miller, thankfully has managed to keep her daughter.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    He'll rescind Obama's transgender school stuff for sure, and . . . well, gay marriage might get rescinded, which would push it back to the states, half of whom would suddenly absorb a certain number of marriage-minded gay people. I'd say "a lot" of marriage-minded gay people, but let's get serious, there ain't that many of them all together, and if you whittle it down to those who are actually interested in getting married in the near future that puts their numbers somewhat too low to be noticed against the background noise of population growth.
    Upending people's lives, forcing them to choose between being able to get married or keeping their jobs, homes, land, or proximity to family/friends is not acceptable. Adoption goes along with marriage (as ruled), so it would also affect whether or not homosexuals can adopt, and may even mean homosexuals losing custody of their adopted children. It's not acceptable. Not even as a "might".

    If this was a "might" for heterosexual marriages there would be barricades in the streets. You'd be firmly against it. Anyone sane would be.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Being arrested and jailed for no good reason is persecution. As is having a criminal record for no good reason. As is having to live in fear that if you're found out those things will happen to you.
    Uh, it was his homosexual lover who called the cops on him by filing a false police report. I'm not quite sure why he would live in fear of persecution.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Republicans specifically designed those laws so as to keep as many black Americans from voting as they possibly could. That is racist, regardless of who else does similar and for what reason.
    Jim Crow was a Democrat. There's nothing racist about requiring photo ID when voting. Unless of course you believe that black people are less capable of obtaining ID.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    The case should never have gotten to trial.
    Yes, we're all agreed that sodomy laws are horrible and stupid. Which makes it all the more appalling that people like you want to justify bringing them back.

    Seems pretty clear to me that if the worst thing was spending a night in jail, that's hardly persecution.
    Being arrested and jailed for no good reason is persecution. As is having a criminal record for no good reason. As is having to live in fear that if you're found out those things will happen to you.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Canada has voting laws that require obtaining an ID. Are you arguing that Canada is racist? Sheesh. ID is not hard to get.
    Republicans specifically designed those laws so as to keep as many black Americans from voting as they possibly could. That is racist, regardless of who else does similar and for what reason.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Given that it kills about 500 thousand girls a year, I hardly see how opposition to Roe is anti-women. Say what you will, there are plenty of prolife ladies.
    strawman

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post

    Like I said before, that heroine that was taken off the street sometimes prevents new addicts. That junky that get's busted again sometimes gets clean finally even in jail.
    that heroin was replaced and murder rates soon doubled under Reagan's drug war

    What was the homicide rate in poor black neighborhoods over the 20 years following WWII (or the 20 years before it, like under alcohol prohibition)? What was the level of gang activity? Were the jails filled with younger black people? The drug war brought us more murder, more gangs, and more crime.

    You never did respond to that

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    it's voter IDs and closing polling places and other roundabout ways to the same end.
    Canada has voting laws that require obtaining an ID. Are you arguing that Canada is racist? Sheesh. ID is not hard to get.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Trump's stated goal for SCOTUS is to overturn Roe v Wade. Regardless of whether you agree or disagree whether it should be overturned or not, it is obviously an issue which affects women.
    Given that it kills about 500 thousand girls a year, I hardly see how opposition to Roe is anti-women. Say what you will, there are plenty of prolife ladies.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Lawrence in 2003 (though there were probably others in the interim between the trials). Thus Lawrence v Texas. Which ended state sodomy laws.
    You might want to read about the case. It's an interesting one. Lawrence's homosexual lover filed a false police report in 1998. Lawrence spent the night in jail and was released in the morning.

    The case should never have gotten to trial. It went to trial because Lawrence's lawyers wanted to attack the Texas laws. Seems pretty clear to me that if the worst thing was spending a night in jail, that's hardly persecution.

    Especially given the six figure fines that have been levied against Christian bakers.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post

    You mean this guy?



    So you think he's lying... are the results lying too?
    Like I said before, that heroine that was taken off the street sometimes prevents new addicts. That junky that get's busted again sometimes gets clean finally even in jail.

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post

    I don't believe because...
    1) It's an incredible claim demanding much evidence
    2) The person who said that they heard that from someone said it after it couldn't be confirmed.
    You mean this guy?



    So you think he's lying... are the results lying too?

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    What? No, they don't have to let them do anything. My neighborhood is not exactly sparkly-clean. There's a trailer park a short distance from my work that gets visited by cops several times a month. We're not talking bloods and crips, but if these people were doing anything that really offended the prevailing values, they'd have good cause to keep it quiet. They do not, which strongly indicates to me that nobody really cares whom they schtup. The left likes to focus a lot on the religious right since they've largely forgotten how to fight anybody else, but Trump represents the post-religious right. He's a filthy lying gambling magnate who can't be bothered to even pretend Christianity properly. He may throw his religious constituents a bone now and then, but only the most utterly delusional seriously think he's going to make their interests a priority.

    He'll rescind Obama's transgender school stuff for sure, and . . . well, gay marriage might get rescinded, which would push it back to the states, half of whom would suddenly absorb a certain number of marriage-minded gay people. I'd say "a lot" of marriage-minded gay people, but let's get serious, there ain't that many of them all together, and if you whittle it down to those who are actually interested in getting married in the near future that puts their numbers somewhat too low to be noticed against the background noise of population growth.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    For further context: Remember what I said about living in Trump country? There used to be Trump signs in every fourth yard here, scarcely a Hillary sign in sight. Customers routinely assume that I--a bespectacled, transparently bookish white guy who looks like Trotsky--am looking forward to the President smashing Obamacare. Yet gay people are not hiding at all. At least, not all gay people. Lesbians in particular are quite prominent, I've stopped being at all surprised by women who walk up and casually say they're picking things up for their wives or girlfriends. A few months ago, shortly before the election, I had an unusually trashy pair engage in PDA in the middle of the bloody store in a way I've never seen a straight couple do. I suspect that this confidence is due to their not belonging to Blue. I don't think these women are Trump fans, but they're frequently on public healthcare and don't talk or act like the upper middle class. People here know they can be as queer as they like, and most of the good old boys around here won't much care, as long as they don't give any sign of being class enemies.
    They have legal protection now. Of course they are happy to have it. Of course even those who are homophobic have to let them live their lives. It wasn't that long ago that homosexuals were afraid (even in liberal places) to even tell anyone they were homosexual. Trump's stated and implied SCOTUS goals threaten that legal protection. We shouldn't even consider allowing the slightest possibility of regression on that regards.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X