Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
The Moral Arc
Collapse
X
-
It's not simply not agreeing. When it gets to blatantly disregarding the well-being of others is when it becomes an issue. And the problem isn't empathy, it's the blatant disregard for the well-being of others. Which generally requires a lack of empathy on the part of the person disregarding the well-being of others.
-
The thing about empathy is that people are actually suffering because people don't agree with them. That's what the whole safe space thing is about. If you rely solely on empathy for making decisions you will make the wrong decisions.
Leave a comment:
-
Yeah, like the All Lives Matter thing (not really a movement). It's mindless too.Originally posted by Aeson View PostThat is part of it for many people most likely. It's also part of why Trump won, because Ds don't display empathy for white working class who are struggling, often deriding their suffering as illegitimate.
Leave a comment:
-
That is part of it for many people most likely. It's also part of why Trump won, because Ds don't display empathy for white working class who are struggling, often deriding their suffering as illegitimate.
Leave a comment:
-
I could be wrong but I think this has to do with exactly what you said, empathy. Democrats are upset because people don't have empathy with homosexuals etc.. I've noticed this recently when a friend of mine got very upset when I suggested that I thought some people exaggerate when they tell stories about their oppression.
Leave a comment:
-
I thought it was about how some democrats are acting crazy about the inauguration.Originally posted by Aeson View PostStrawman.
This is about SCOTUS, and the fact that Trump highly regards Scalia who voted to allow states to throw homosexuals in jail, and has listed Pryor as a potential nominee, who also supports letting states do so.
Leave a comment:
-
Strawman.Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
I don't think you should expect Christians to feel bad for homosexuals who aren't allowed to sodomize each other or to feel empathy for them when they have an irrational fear of being thrown in jail. No one here is for throwing homosexuals in jail.
This is about SCOTUS, and the fact that Trump highly regards Scalia who voted to allow states to throw homosexuals in jail, and has listed Pryor as a potential nominee, who also supports letting states do so.
Leave a comment:
-
"An injustice anywhere is an injustice everywhere."Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
And the apparent zero-sum nature is why protected classes should not multiply.
African Americans and Native Americans did (and still do) have it much worse then other possible groupings in an open an sustained way (And now in a hidden and sustained way). This is why race should be a protected class and people get their rights curtailed in respect to race.
JM
-MLK Jr
So you've decide not to give me satisfaction? Very disappointing.
Leave a comment:
-
I don't think you should expect Christians to feel bad for homosexuals who aren't allowed to sodomize each other or to feel empathy for them when they have an irrational fear of being thrown in jail. No one here is for throwing homosexuals in jail.Originally posted by Aeson View Post
That's your interpretation of the Constitution. Other people (including a majority of SCOTUS in recent decisions) view various homosexual rights as Constitutional. It was until quite recently not upheld as Constitutional by SCOTUS.
Hypothetically at some point Christians could find themselves in a situation where SCOTUS changes it's view on the 1st amendment, like they have on several other amendments at several other times (inc the 1st at times) in the past. The question was to help you understand what it would be like to be in that situation, so you can perhaps develop empathy for those who have recently been, and may soon be again, in that type of situation.
There's no need for "mass anti-gay pogroms" to be unacceptable. I don't think it's ok for even one person to be jailed for having sex with a consenting adult in the privacy of their own home.
Leave a comment:
-
As for "the violence would be hard to push any further" ... look at history. Hell, look at today! The Middle East is rife with examples. Russia is another. It's obvious that homosexuals can be oppressed in horrible ways. It's not like something that's never happened. It's happening in the world today!
Leave a comment:
-
Rights are always "zero-sum", in that to protect one's action you must limit another's potential action.Originally posted by Elok View PostOkay? No. Cause for panic? Not except insofar as it was precedent for further erosion of liberties. Like I said, gay people do not exist as an organic community, so the analogy falls apart; the violence would be hard to push any farther.
As events post-Obergefell indicated a zero-sum game--their rights must necessarily come at the expense of ours in the current, addled political climate--I am admittedly somewhat biased, but I would prefer that both sides calm down and find an acceptable compromise.
Yes, by not allowing states to put homosexuals in prison for consensual sex in their own homes you are curtailing the rights of states so that they can't put homosexuals in prison for consensual sex in their own homes. On the other hand, by allowing states to put homosexuals in prison for consensual sex in their own homes you are curtailing the rights of homosexuals.
There is an obvious answer as to who's rights should be respected in that regard. Trump, via his nominees and praise of Scalia, is at best oblivious to it ...
Putting people on SCOTUS who would allow states to imprison homosexuals for consensual sex in their own homes is not anything close to "an acceptable compromise".
Leave a comment:
-
And the apparent zero-sum nature is why protected classes should not multiply.Originally posted by Elok View PostAs events post-Obergefell indicated a zero-sum game--their rights must necessarily come at the expense of ours in the current, addled political climate--I am admittedly somewhat biased, but I would prefer that both sides calm down and find an acceptable compromise.
African Americans and Native Americans did (and still do) have it much worse then other possible groupings in an open an sustained way (And now in a hidden and sustained way). This is why race should be a protected class and people get their rights curtailed in respect to race.
JM
Leave a comment:
-
Okay? No. Cause for panic? Not except insofar as it was precedent for further erosion of liberties. Like I said, gay people do not exist as an organic community, so the analogy falls apart; the violence would be hard to push any farther.
As events post-Obergefell indicated a zero-sum game--their rights must necessarily come at the expense of ours in the current, addled political climate--I am admittedly somewhat biased, but I would prefer that both sides calm down and find an acceptable compromise.
Leave a comment:
-
Would you feel it's ok if in the hypothetical situation only an occasional Christian here or there would be jailed for practising their religion?
Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: