Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Moral Arc

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Originally posted by Aeson View Post
    You're arguing a straw man. The Feds aren't the ones who want sodomy laws. It's states like Texas. And you don't have to regress to the point of jailing homosexuals before harm worthy of legitimate concern is being done.
    I would argue that you are arguing the straw man. You are saying that it is an extreme danger to have one person being in a position to make law who supports allowing others, if they choose, to use the government to attack homosexuals.

    If there was a great interest from the government (I mean police, state judges, federal judges) to do this, and their was other support on the Supreme Court (you mention Scalia, but he is dead) for this, I might agree. But there isn't. It is likely that he would have the same effect as my grandfather's neighbour when he voted for Bush. None.

    So the probability is minuscule and the damage is a lot smaller than other groups (the nightmare scenario is 1% damage, and as Elok said in that scenario other groups would be experiencing 10-100% damage).

    It is relatively unimportant, it is taking too much of the liberal speech space and that is one of the reasons why many people who voted for Obama didn't vote for Clinton v2.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    BTW, only 5.63/100,000 black people we're victims of hate crimes in 2013, so that's irrational fear.
    Hate crimes have nothing to do with the government assault on a group of people (or allowing the majority to assault them).

    For example you look at number of African Americans in jail for drugs crimes versus number of Whites and consider the fact that drug use is similar. See http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/0...n_3941346.html and links there in or google. Blacks are incarcerated at almost 20x the rate of whites for a crime that 2x more whites commit. That is a sustained government attack on African Americans (not completely open).

    That is why I put the probability for a sustained attack on African Americans to be approximately 100% and heavily support African Americans being a special class and having special protections.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    You're arguing a straw man. The Feds aren't the ones who want sodomy laws. It's states like Texas. And you don't have to regress to the point of jailing homosexuals before harm worthy of legitimate concern is being done.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Originally posted by Aeson View Post

    Your argument here isn't ever going to justify the government doing awful things to people.

    Obergfell and Lawrence were both rulings based on the equal protection clause of the 14th. They aren't about treating homosexuals differently ... but the exact opposite ... about treating homosexuals and their relationships the same as heterosexuals.

    It is not lunacy to continue with the current court's interpretation of the Constitution in regards to the equal protection clause

    Are you talking about individual attacks, or a broad "rights" attack such as a SCOTUS ruling? In either case, with around 10 million LGBT Americans, attacks on 1% (whether 1% of the population, or the whole population 1% of the time) is still an awful lot of expected horrible **** happening. We as a nation routinely (pretty much on a daily basis) "freak out" about far less.
    We aren't talking about the government doing awful things to people.

    We are talking about special protections and classes and so on.

    I am adamantly and entirely opposed to the government doing awful things to people. As I said, due to this thread I have went from near 0 certainty that homosexuals were not in danger of the government doing awful things to them to being 1% certain that homosexuals are not in danger of the government doing awful things to them. That is enough for a few letter campaigns/protests but not enough to panic and take up all of the speech space (liberal or otherwise). Particularly when other groups are near 100% certainty.

    JM
    (It is a 1% fear of a small number of attacks... there have never been an open, sustained and systematic attack on homosexuals in the US in US history, even when laws supporting it were on the books. There never was a case when even 0.1% of homosexuals (who make up roughly 10% of the population) had their lives or property under attack by the government.)

    (Even in the societies where homosexuals have been under an open, sustained and systematic attack by the government, the number of people attacked for such has been small. If we take 10% as the percent of the population that is homosexual, even in Nazi germany (67 million people) where there was an aggressive, open, sustained and systematic attack on homosexuals between 1933 and 1940 only had 100k people prosecuted (and only 10k of those sent to camps) out of an estimated homosexual population of 6 million. That is less than 2% of the gay population (so less than 0.2% of the overall population). If you are wanting to point to number of people, attacks on homosexuals are always going to be extremely rare versus other at risk groups.)

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    BTW, only 5.63/100,000 black people we're victims of hate crimes in 2013, so that's irrational fear.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    BTW, only 5.63/100,000 black people we're victims of hate crimes in 2013, so that's irrational fear.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Basically, for it to get to the point where the Feds were not only jailing gays, but throwing them from rooftops, society would have to change so dramatically for the worse that everyone, and not just gays, would be miserable. Which is possible, but only in the sense that a communist revolution is possible, or even hardcore persecution of Christians (which, to extend your argument, is roughly as common in the world today as the mistreatment of gays, and in much the same places). Certainly none of the three is plausible in the near term.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    Over 180 years of open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness and the rest of the years (since the founding of this country) they have experienced a combination of hidden and open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness.

    So yes, I am happy to forget equal rights. I don't hold 'equal rights' as sacred, rather as a first order optimum.

    JM
    What does 180 years ago matter? Are those people alive now that we should all make sacrifices for them?

    Jews and homosexuals are more likely to be the victims of hate crimes than blacks.

    Comparing the incidence of hate crimes per year, per 100,000 members of the targeted group in 2013.


    But I just can't believe that you are AGAINST equal rights. That's because you believe in group rights (your special favorite group) and not individual rights. You don't give a damn about the suffering of individuals, only the collective suffering of groups.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    Over 180 years of open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness and the rest of the years (since the founding of this country) they have experienced a combination of hidden and open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness.

    So yes, I am happy to forget equal rights. I don't hold 'equal rights' as sacred, rather as a first order optimum.

    JM
    What does 180 years ago matter? Are those people alive now that we should all make sacrifices for them?

    Jews and homosexuals are more likely to be the victims of hate crimes than blacks.

    Comparing the incidence of hate crimes per year, per 100,000 members of the targeted group in 2013.


    But I just can't believe that you are AGAINST equal rights. That's because you believe in group rights (your special favorite group) and not individual rights. You don't give a damn about the suffering of individuals, only the collective suffering of groups.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Aeson, again: gays are not a cohesive cultural group. It's biologically impossible to extirpate them. It is only possible to be vicious to individuals--and going back to jailing them for sodomy is extremely implausible, while Russian-style repression would require the entire culture of the country to shift radically. As of 2004, most of the anti-sodomy laws on the books were almost never enforced anyway, which is how they remained on the books in the first place.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    It is possible to think up an infinite number of laws to constrain an infinite number of possible terrible outcomes for an infinite number of groups. To consider the lack of those laws an attack on each group, and so a reason why that group needs special status, is lunacy. And an attack on our rights. And is an attack on the groups that do need special status.
    Your argument here isn't ever going to justify the government doing awful things to people.

    Obergfell and Lawrence were both rulings based on the equal protection clause of the 14th. They aren't about treating homosexuals differently ... but the exact opposite ... about treating homosexuals and their relationships the same as heterosexuals.

    It is not lunacy to continue with the current court's interpretation of the Constitution in regards to the equal protection clause.

    By the way, due to this thread, attacks on homosexuals are a bigger concern for me than they were previously (I previously had the probability of an attack on homosexuals being approximately 0, I have raised it to 1 in 100). So this is actually an example of a change in my position. A 1 in 100 is cause for some concern and it is reasonable to take action. Just not to freak out.
    Are you talking about individual attacks, or a broad "rights" attack such as a SCOTUS ruling? In either case, with around 10 million LGBT Americans, attacks on 1% (whether 1% of the population, or the whole population 1% of the time) is still an awful lot of expected horrible **** happening. We as a nation routinely (pretty much on a daily basis) "freak out" about far less.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Over 180 years of open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness and the rest of the years (since the founding of this country) they have experienced a combination of hidden and open sustained attacks on their lives, property, liberty and pursuit of happiness.

    So yes, I am happy to forget equal rights. I don't hold 'equal rights' as sacred, rather as a first order optimum.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    So forget equal rights so that the people whose racism you understand can be treated more special.
    Last edited by Kidlicious; January 17, 2017, 08:51.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Originally posted by Aeson View Post
    Putting people on SCOTUS who would allow states to imprison homosexuals for consensual sex in their own homes is not anything close to "an acceptable compromise".
    The point that isn't an acceptable compromise is if homosexuals are imprisoned for consensual sex in their own homes. That is the negative result.

    It is possible to think up an infinite number of laws to constrain an infinite number of possible terrible outcomes for an infinite number of groups. To consider the lack of those laws an attack on each group, and so a reason why that group needs special status, is lunacy. And an attack on our rights. And is an attack on the groups that do need special status.

    By the way, due to this thread, attacks on homosexuals are a bigger concern for me than they were previously (I previously had the probability of an attack on homosexuals being approximately 0, I have raised it to 1 in 100). So this is actually an example of a change in my position. A 1 in 100 is cause for some concern and it is reasonable to take action. Just not to freak out.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Aeson View Post
    It's not simply not agreeing. When it gets to blatantly disregarding the well-being of others is when it becomes an issue. And the problem isn't empathy, it's the blatant disregard for the well-being of others. Which generally requires a lack of empathy on the part of the person disregarding the well-being of others.
    People don't generally have a disregard for others. They have a different worldview. Example, people who are against allowing massive amounts of unvetted Syrian refugees into their country do not have a disregard for them. They are simply reasonable people who care about others but don't think that is a good policy.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X