Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Moral Arc

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • DaShi
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    This thread is an example of some of the problem I was talking about.

    I voice support for gay rights positions (oppose the supreme court candidate, in favor of gay marriage), but I lack some of the reasons (I don't think that gay rights (as defined by gay marriage and so on) is as important as african american rights and so on, I don't support a bunch of special protections for LBGTQ?? people, or other groups that aren't African Americans (or Native Americans), I don't think that gay marriage is a right rather I think it is a good social law, etc. And this makes me a person non-grata to many on the left. And they have trouble with African American churches that preach that homosexual activity is a sin and so on....
    Your problem is not only do you rank the rights of people, you also think that you are an authority on what rank people should have.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    This thread is an example of some of the problem I was talking about.

    I voice support for gay rights positions (oppose the supreme court candidate, in favor of gay marriage), but I lack some of the reasons (I don't think that gay rights (as defined by gay marriage and so on) is as important as african american rights and so on, I don't support a bunch of special protections for LBGTQ?? people, or other groups that aren't African Americans (or Native Americans), I don't think that gay marriage is a right rather I think it is a good social law, etc. And this makes me a person non-grata to many on the left. And they have trouble with African American churches that preach that homosexual activity is a sin and so on....

    I am never going to be on the right, but let's consider the right.

    I am in favor of increased restrictions on abortion ('pro-life') but not for the right reasons: I think that life begans with brain waves at 16 weeks or so and not conception and I think that the key way to change thing is to change hearts and minds and not make draconian laws. Yet to my knowledge few on the right are going to get upset with me over this (it might be that I interact so little with people on the right, I have seen this last month).

    That is so much 'nicer'. So much more tolerant than many of the vocal left.

    And probably a significant part of the reason Trump is now president.

    JM
    (It is actually on BLM that I would get clear condemnation from many on the right.)

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Hard to say, really. You have a certain knack for keeping your head down, you know. That's as good a survival skill as any other. And of course you'd be welcome at the earthy homestead commune I don't doubt my wife would set up under the circumstances. My older son would ask you all sorts of questions about science. You would step in a lot of sheep poop. There would be almost no technology. On second thought, perhaps you might prefer to take your chances with the war zone.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    I think we're having two different conversations here. I am concerned that our deeply fractured and dysfunctional country is replacing the sober, cautious Obama with the raging, effortlessly inflammatory jackass Trump. This is like an unstable reactor having its mildly defective control rods pulled out and replaced with strings of firecrackers wound around giant rubber dildos. It is entirely conceivable that the results of this will be what is sometimes called "civil unrest" or "disturbances" or "crazy *******s blowing **** up and mounting terror raids." I have no means of evaluating the likelihood of this possibility, but it would seem to be the natural endpoint of Trump's behavior and temperament. I would be much more panicky about this if I didn't live in a location that was about as safe as any territory could reasonably be under such a scenario.
    Well Obama cries a lot in public which is what it means to be a man according to snowflakes.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lorizael
    replied
    Yeah, I share that concern. And in that case, you do have more to worry about than I do. If such a future comes to pass, I'll probably die.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Lorizael View Post

    Heh. I knew you'd go kids next. My thinking there is... you don't really know how your kids will turn out. Maybe one will be gay and the other a Buddhist. You can influence them, but you cannot control them, especially as adults. So instead, take the Rawlsian approach of attempting to create a world that will be good for your children no matter who they turn out to be.
    It's not that simple. We have to create a strong America. That means a nation that is united, that stands together and doesn't fight each other.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    I think we're having two different conversations here. I am concerned that our deeply fractured and dysfunctional country is replacing the sober, cautious Obama with the raging, effortlessly inflammatory jackass Trump. This is like an unstable reactor having its mildly defective control rods pulled out and replaced with strings of firecrackers wound around giant rubber dildos. It is entirely conceivable that the results of this will be what is sometimes called "civil unrest" or "disturbances" or "crazy *******s blowing **** up and mounting terror raids." I have no means of evaluating the likelihood of this possibility, but it would seem to be the natural endpoint of Trump's behavior and temperament. I would be much more panicky about this if I didn't live in a location that was about as safe as any territory could reasonably be under such a scenario.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lorizael
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    I think this is generally good advice, though it should be noted that I have children and that it is therefore, to some extent, my job to worry about the future. You do not. Check your existential privilege.
    Heh. I knew you'd go kids next. My thinking there is... you don't really know how your kids will turn out. Maybe one will be gay and the other a Buddhist. You can influence them, but you cannot control them, especially as adults. So instead, take the Rawlsian approach of attempting to create a world that will be good for your children no matter who they turn out to be.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Lorizael View Post

    Oh, trouble? I mean, yeah, I don't expect any trouble for me, unless I guess there's some crackdown on non-believers or the mentally ill or Jews. But like, man, the universe is a cold and unforgiving place and it doesn't owe you ****, and people are just a part of the universe. I try (and fail, but I do try) to be as angry at *******s whose beliefs conflict with mine (even violently) as I am at earthquakes: not at all. No matter what institutions exist or what people say they believe, you have no control over whether or not the world is going to **** you over.

    The only power you have is to live according to your own principles. If your principles don't really map well onto the weird ass political spectrum that exists in the US or other countries, then **** all that. Don't get caught up in some game where you start to see yourself as part of a persecuted group or trying to defeat the other side, because the more you do that, the more you are forced to erode your own moral code to fit in the game.

    If some element of this society doesn't respect some of your beliefs or identity (say, about religion), then disagree with them vociferously on that and continue to agree with them on the stuff you do see eye to eye on, but don't take sides in some fight. If you think you have to oppose them as part of some long-term survival strategy, remember that humans are spectacularly bad at predicting the future and that your actions now might be just as likely to have the opposite effect down the line.
    Sartre would say that everyone does live by their own principles. Some people just believe that they need to work collectively for the common good. That's a principle.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    I think this is generally good advice, though it should be noted that I have children and that it is therefore, to some extent, my job to worry about the future. You do not. Check your existential privilege.

    (also with Trump at the helm I think the time may come when this will assume practical significance insofar as it will determine who is shooting at me, but even the odds of that are low due to local demographics)

    Leave a comment:


  • Lorizael
    replied
    Originally posted by Elok View Post
    I have a very hard time picturing your transhumanism getting you in trouble, except in some impossibly far-fetched scenario wherein you somehow get involved in the vanguard of some eugenic experiment to produce an organic hivemind which goes horribly wrong, and even then I'd picture you as the Albert Speer (Nazi, not Polytubby) of the group. And that would be somewhat incidental to the main political conflict of our time. Christianity is not and cannot be extrinsic to the story. One side are scheming goblins who will not suffer us to live with any manner of integrity, while the other are straight-up orcs but will leave us alone if we don't rock the boat. Which is horrible, because they're even worse than the goblins in many respects, but there you are.
    Oh, trouble? I mean, yeah, I don't expect any trouble for me, unless I guess there's some crackdown on non-believers or the mentally ill or Jews. But like, man, the universe is a cold and unforgiving place and it doesn't owe you ****, and people are just a part of the universe. I try (and fail, but I do try) to be as angry at *******s whose beliefs conflict with mine (even violently) as I am at earthquakes: not at all. No matter what institutions exist or what people say they believe, you have no control over whether or not the world is going to **** you over.

    The only power you have is to live according to your own principles. If your principles don't really map well onto the weird ass political spectrum that exists in the US or other countries, then **** all that. Don't get caught up in some game where you start to see yourself as part of a persecuted group or trying to defeat the other side, because the more you do that, the more you are forced to erode your own moral code to fit in the game.

    If some element of this society doesn't respect some of your beliefs or identity (say, about religion), then disagree with them vociferously on that and continue to agree with them on the stuff you do see eye to eye on, but don't take sides in some fight. If you think you have to oppose them as part of some long-term survival strategy, remember that humans are spectacularly bad at predicting the future and that your actions now might be just as likely to have the opposite effect down the line.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Elok, where do you stand on school choice. We have a real shot here and liberals are foaming at the mouth. They know where their vulnerability is.

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Jon Miller I'd just like to mention that my reason for not taking apart your poorly reasoned and antagonistic posts earlier in the week was purely due to a bout of flu (and now an unwillingness to bother trawling back though 16 pages). I just want to reassure you that you are, yet again, wrong.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Of course you may be right; in such a complicated situation with no way of predicting what will happen, I may simply be falling back on morbid paranoia. Then again, I expect a grossly unqualified president to come into office in two days. There will almost certainly be riots in multiple cities, unless I am very much mistaken. He lacks the tools to defuse tension or conciliate. Things are going to get a lot worse before they get better, one way or another.

    But hell, I could be wrong.

    EDIT: I am wrong. It's tomorrow, not two days. This is what happens when I take closing shifts at work. Blech.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elok
    replied
    Originally posted by Aeson View Post
    There are a lot of progressive Christians.
    At present. Depending how one defines "progressive" and "Christian." Even I could qualify by some definitions. But the leadership class of progressivism--colleges, the media, associated donors--are hostile to religion. As the bifurcation of our society continues, I expect the hostility to become less latent. It's like climate change; I think we're locked into course and we'll have extreme difficulty moving from it as time goes on, even after diagnosing the problem.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X