Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Originally posted by kentonio View Post


    That was her betrothal or wedding to Alexios you uneducated idiot (she was 8 years old at the time, which says a lot about Christian values back then). She married Andronikos in 1183, a year AFTER the massacre.


    maybe he realized that catholics are false subsequent believers and he was glad that there was a reducement of their numbers?

    Seeing as he was trapped in muslamic catholics land and couldn't really express his gratitude any other way, he gave his daughter to Andronikos as thanks

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    How can Ben be so wrong?

    It is because of his victimization method of argumentation?

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    So why not arrest, expel, hang the perpetrators? Are you suggesting that he approved of ethnic cleansing so long as it was the Catholics? After day one, perhaps, "maybe I should really do something about this massive ethnic cleansing? You don't kill 80k people in one day. It went on for about a month.
    I'm saying he didn't really care, especially as the wave of violence helped sweep him into power. He then proceeded to murder a ****load of people and try and murder a ****load more. He was a total *******, pretty much like all the other total *******s running countries back then.

    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Uh, the reality is that is *exactly* how it was perceived by the Venetians (who saw it as a casus belli), and by the Hohenstaufens (who wanted to crusade in response).
    Which didn't happen, because no-one gave a **** about 'innocent lives' back then, they cared about money and power. The popes as much (if not more) than everyone else.

    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    The massacre was two years after the marriage.
    The ceremony took place in the Trullo Hall, in the Great Palace, on 2 March 1180
    That was her betrothal or wedding to Alexios you uneducated idiot (she was 8 years old at the time, which says a lot about Christian values back then). She married Andronikos in 1183, a year AFTER the massacre.

    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Still a better historian than you.
    He said, immediately after making yet another humiliating mistake.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Could it have been homeopathy?

    Show the catholics how they were treating jews, witches, pagans and all that good stuff, up to then and make them realize the errour of their ways?

    Has it been beneficial?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Why would they? The ruler who allowed (bear in mind it was a spontaneous massacre that Andronikos I Komnenos allowed to continue
    So why not arrest, expel, hang the perpetrators? Are you suggesting that he approved of ethnic cleansing so long as it was the Catholics? After day one, perhaps, "maybe I should really do something about this massive ethnic cleansing? You don't kill 80k people in one day. It went on for about a month.

    Uh, the reality is that is *exactly* how it was perceived by the Venetians (who saw it as a casus belli), and by the Hohenstaufens (who wanted to crusade in response).

    It's highly predictable of you to try and paint the massacre of Latins as some kind of Greek plot you can use as justification to defend Catholicism again, but it doesn't actually fit into the reality. The Catholic world was so furious incidentally, that King Louis VII of France proceeded to marry one of his daughters to Andronikos.
    Which,

    The ceremony took place in the Trullo Hall, in the Great Palace, on 2 March 1180
    The massacre was two years after the marriage.

    You are literally the worst 'historian' I've ever seen.
    Still a better historian than you.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Seems pretty clear to me, and I was a prot.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    That did not give Peter any authority to lord over people, declare holy wars etc... There's nothing in that verse that says what you are saying that it says. Peter had the authority of an apostle, and he still does, just like the other apostles.
    "I give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven"!= God given authority of St Peter?

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    (I'm mainly saying these things to piss off Ben. Which is noble I think)

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Re-establishing the Roman Empire starting as Byzantium is the best way to play Europa Universalis. <3

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    Byzantium managed to last for 1.000 years making it the longest standing empire in europe ever, because it combined the military expertise of greeks/romans/arabs and also inherited a mixture of greek and roman law.

    The main source of its wealth were regions like syria and the middle east. Its military might primarely came from asia minor and the vast open fields were war horses and the suchs were groomed and trained.

    There were factors that led to its decline. The foremost was its rigidity that got worse as years went by (its weakly adversary "rome" had fallen far before), the other was the loss of the vast horse training plains of asia minor and of course the crusades of the catholics which acted as perfect allies to the muslims.

    As said, muslims were far more civilized than catholics and the latter always had a knack of going against christianity probably because they hate the word of god.
    Last edited by Bereta_Eder; January 19, 2016, 04:48.

    Leave a comment:


  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    It was restrained. Where did the Pope issue a crusade for Byzantium? Where did the Hohenstaufens launch an invasion of the Empire? They could have, they did not.
    Why would they? The ruler who allowed (bear in mind it was a spontaneous massacre that Andronikos I Komnenos allowed to continue, rather than actually organized and was a result of the previous ruler allowing the Latins to control much of the power in the city) was actually attacked by an army of the Norman Sicilians and was later tortured in the street for 3 days before being executed by Latin soldiers.

    It's highly predictable of you to try and paint the massacre of Latins as some kind of Greek plot you can use as justification to defend Catholicism again, but it doesn't actually fit into the reality. The Catholic world was so furious incidentally, that King Louis VII of France proceeded to marry one of his daughters to Andronikos.

    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Ironically, the 4th Crusade would never have been able to do much without the assistance of Alexios IV. The Crusaders had insufficient forces to breach the walls. They were brought in by Alexios IV in his coup attempt. It was only after they were already inside the city that the sack happened.
    What the actual fuck are you talking about? You are literally the worst 'historian' I've ever seen.

    Originally posted by Wiki
    Siege

    By the end of March, the combined Crusader armies were besieging Constantinople as Emperor Alexios V began to strengthen the city's defences while conducting more active operations outside the city. By the first week of April, the Crusaders had begun their siege from their encampment in the town of Galata across the Golden Horn from Constantinople.[8]

    On 9 April 1204, the Crusader and Venetian forces began an assault on the Golden Horn fortifications by crossing the waterway to the northwest wall of the city, but, because of bad weather, the assault forces were driven back when the troops that landed came under heavy archery fire in open ground between Constantinople's fortifications and the shore.

    Capture of the city

    On 12 April 1204 weather conditions finally favoured the Crusaders as the weather cleared and a second assault on the city was ordered. A strong north wind aided the Venetian ships near the Golden Horn to come close to the city wall, which enabled the attackers to seize some of the towers along the wall. After a short battle approximately 70 Crusaders managed to enter the city. Some Crusaders were eventually able to knock holes in the walls small enough for a few knights at a time to crawl through; the Venetians were also successful at scaling the walls from the sea, although there was extremely bloody fighting with the Varangians. The Crusaders captured the Blachernae section of the city in the northwest and used it as a base to attack the rest of the city, but while attempting to defend themselves with a wall of fire they ended up burning down even more of the city. Emperor Alexios V fled from the city that night through the Polyandriou (Rhegium) Gate and escaped into the countryside to the west.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    I see Ben once again didn't say he wasn't gay for Hitler.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Matthew 16:19
    That did not give Peter any authority to lord over people, declare holy wars etc... There's nothing in that verse that says what you are saying that it says. Peter had the authority of an apostle, and he still does, just like the other apostles.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Deriding condemnation of mass rape and genocide while claiming it was "justified" and a "refrained response" ...
    It was restrained. Where did the Pope issue a crusade for Byzantium? Where did the Hohenstaufens launch an invasion of the Empire? They could have, they did not.

    Ironically, the 4th Crusade would never have been able to do much without the assistance of Alexios IV. The Crusaders had insufficient forces to breach the walls. They were brought in by Alexios IV in his coup attempt. It was only after they were already inside the city that the sack happened.

    Now you just need to drop your stupid strawman. No one is claiming the massacre of Catholics isn't horrific and evil, we all know it is. You were the only one trying to paint mass rape and murder as "justified" and a "refrained response".
    I never asserted that 'no one believed that the massacre of Catholics wasn't horrific and evil, I simply stated that I waited for someone to condemn the massacre. Those are two different things.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    All I said is that the death of 80k Catholics in Constantinople amounted to a provocation and a casus belli to the entire Catholic world at the time. If Byzantium wants to avoid being invaded by all the Catholic powers, perhaps they should refrain from ethnic cleansing. This isn't a high bar.

    Yes, it was horrific. I've never denied that.
    Let's look at what you actually said:

    If we want to get into Papal judgment, Innocent III refused to give his blessing to a Crusade against the Byzantine Empire in response to the slaughter of the Catholics. Not because such was not justified ...
    It is easy with the gaze of the 21st century to condemn the actions of 12th century Catholics. Personally, I would rather quote Innocent III who was there. But that doesn't serve your narrative that the culpability was on the Catholics who had a rather restrained response.
    Deriding condemnation of mass rape and genocide while claiming it was "justified" and a "refrained response" ...

    It's good to see you have finally run away from such moronic statements and can finally admit that the Sack of Constantinople was horrific and evil.

    Now you just need to drop your stupid strawman. No one is claiming the massacre of Catholics isn't horrific and evil, we all know it is. You were the only one trying to paint mass rape and murder as "justified" and a "refrained response".

    I'm still waiting for anyone to state that the slaughter of 80k Catholics was wrong.
    I'm still waiting for you to say you aren't gay for Hitler. Why is it so hard for you to not be gay for Hitler? YOU MUST LUST FOR HITLER UP YOUR ASS.[/ridiculouslystupidbenlogic]

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X