That's something that old people say.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
The Prophecy
Collapse
X
-
To be slightly contrarian yes the Middle East is a war ravaged hell hole and it seems that many people there are anti-American/anti-western, Islamic radicals and in no way do I think that the trillions of dollars spent on Iraq was worth it, but is it really that much worse than it was in 2003? (or 1993? or 1983? or 1973? or 1963? or 1953?)
Parts of Iraq that are under governmental control have a nominally democratic government instead of a totalitarian dictatorship. Iraq and Iran are on better terms now than they've been since maybe 1978 before the Iranian revolution. Relations between Iraq and Kuwait are also much improved than when Saddam Hussein was in power. Iraq instead of being an international pariah, is now your average Middle Eastern nation. Is it a model of democracy, stability, human rights, economic equality and technological innovation? No it is not, but I want an example of a nation that has had a war fought on it's soil in the past 25 years that is all of those things.
Did the invasion of Iraq cause the Arab Spring? Possibly. Still despite the many setbacks after the Arab Spring's hope of brining peace and democracy to the region (in Syria, Egypt, Yemen, Libya and others) it does have the possibility that Tunisia may turn into a stable democracy in the future.
So in 2013 the Middle East is a bad place. Dictators in Syria and Egypt (and others), rights trampled on in Saudi Arabia and Iran (and others), conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, anti-American/anti-western civilization terrorists groups bombing planes and killing people in other countries (ISIS/ISIL). Syria in civil war. Plus I'm sure we could list many other bad things, but compare this year to past years in the Middle East.
2003. Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria, Yemen (plus other). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations, conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, active terrorist organizations (Al Qaeda, Hamas, Hezbollah) and war in Iraq.
1993 Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria, Yemen (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations, conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, active terrorist organizations (Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad), a civil war in Afghanistan and the region was on the brink of a civil war amongst the Iraqi Kurds and the beginning of an insurgency in Yemen, both of which would begin in 1994.
1983 Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations - especially the brutal way Al-Assad crushed an uprising in Syria in 1982. Israel and the Palestinians are still at odds, Russia is involved in a war in Afghanistan, Lebanon is in a civil war and Iran and Iraq are at war. Active terrorists organizations (PLO, PLF, PKK, Quds Force)
1973 Dictators in Egypt and Iran (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations. Israel and Palestinians still fighting. Active terrorists organizations (PLO, PKK). Yom Kippur War.
As you can see the Middle East has always been a war torn place for quite a while.Last edited by korn469; November 17, 2015, 22:38.
Comment
-
I don't think it's fair to compare now and then in a vacuum assuming then would have continued to be then forever. Technology was going to promote populist movements eventually. It could very well be that those populist movements were less successful because of the West's long history of ****ing around with the Middle East. We've made democracy and capitalism (which both have amazing potential) look bad.
Comment
-
Originally posted by rah View PostHillary supported the war and seems to have survived supporting it.
Also, hopefully her political survival is short lived.
And no more cabinet positions for her either. Take a vacation. Go on some speaking tours. Maybe decorate the Bill Clinton libraryTo us, it is the BEAST.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Aeson View PostI don't think it's fair to compare now and then in a vacuum assuming then would have continued to be then forever. Technology was going to promote populist movements eventually. It could very well be that those populist movements were less successful because of the West's long history of ****ing around with the Middle East. We've made democracy and capitalism (which both have amazing potential) look bad.
Comment
-
Originally posted by korn469 View PostTo be slightly contrarian yes the Middle East is a war ravaged hell hole and it seems that many people there are anti-American/anti-western, Islamic radicals and in no way do I think that the trillions of dollars spent on Iraq was worth it, but is it really that much worse than it was in 2003? (or 1993? or 1983? or 1973? or 1963? or 1953?)
Parts of Iraq that are under governmental control have a nominally democratic government instead of a totalitarian dictatorship. Iraq and Iran are on better terms now than they've been since maybe 1978 before the Iranian revolution. Relations between Iraq and Kuwait are also much improved than when Saddam Hussein was in power. Iraq instead of being an international pariah, is now your average Middle Eastern nation. Is it a model of democracy, stability, human rights, economic equality and technological innovation? No it is not, but I want an example of a nation that has had a war fought on it's soil in the past 25 years that is all of those things.
Did the invasion of Iraq cause the Arab Spring? Possibly. Still despite the many setbacks after the Arab Spring's hope of brining peace and democracy to the region (in Syria, Egypt, Yemen, Libya and others) it does have the possibility that Tunisia may turn into a stable democracy in the future.
So in 2013 the Middle East is a bad place. Dictators in Syria and Egypt (and others), rights trampled on in Saudi Arabia and Iran (and others), conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, anti-American/anti-western civilization terrorists groups bombing planes and killing people in other countries (ISIS/ISIL). Syria in civil war. Plus I'm sure we could list many other bad things, but compare this year to past years in the Middle East.
2003. Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria, Yemen (plus other). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations, conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, active terrorist organizations (Al Qaeda, Hamas, Hezbollah) and war in Iraq.
1993 Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria, Yemen (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations, conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, active terrorist organizations (Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad), a civil war in Afghanistan and the region was on the brink of a civil war amongst the Iraqi Kurds and the beginning of an insurgency in Yemen, both of which would begin in 1994.
1983 Dictators in Libya, Iraq, Syria (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations - especially the brutal way Al-Assad crushed an uprising in Syria in 1982. Israel and the Palestinians are still at odds, Russia is involved in a war in Afghanistan, Lebanon is in a civil war and Iran and Iraq are at war. Active terrorists organizations (PLO, PLF, PKK, Quds Force)
1973 Dictators in Egypt and Iran (plus others). Rampant human rights violations across a number of nations. Israel and Palestinians still fighting. Active terrorists organizations (PLO, PKK). Yom Kippur War.
As you can see the Middle East has always been a war torn place for quite a while."Ceterum censeo Ben esse expellendum."
Comment
-
Originally posted by dannubis View PostSummary: the place was a ****hole but they didn't hate us. We went in for the glory and profit of a few. Now the place is still a ****hole, and they hate us.
Comment
-
Originally posted by korn469 View PostThat's not what I said. But since it's so simple, please name a year when a group from the Middle East didn't hate one of the nations (US, UK, France, Ottomans, Germany, Italy) that have meddled in that region.Tamsin (Lost Girl): "I am the Harbinger of Death. I arrive on winds of blessed air. Air that you no longer deserve."
Tamsin (Lost Girl): "He has fallen in battle and I must take him to the Einherjar in Valhalla"
Comment
Comment