A Game of Thrones - TV Show Discussion Thread

[Lorizael]

Okay, I finally finished A Feast for Crows. That was... long... but it was worth it just to see

Spoiler:

Cersei finally get her comeuppance (however temporary it may be).

Someone tell me A Dance with Dragons has more going for it.

[self biased]

Okay, I finally finished A Feast for Crows. That was... long... but it was worth it just to see

Spoiler:

Cersei finally get her comeuppance (however temporary it may be).

Someone tell me A Dance with Dragons has more going for it.

Spoiler:

the bits with princess perkytits in are basically Mereen, 90210. Barristan the bold gets a few good scenes, though.

[Guynemer]

See, I'm in a significant minority in that I think book 4 is the second-best one. But, folks who discount 4 tend to think 5 is a step up; it certainly gets more action-focused later in the book. One storyline in 5, in particular, is absolutely fantastic, and it is a character you wouldn't expect.

[Lorizael]

I didn't dislike 4, but it wasn't a page-turner the way the previous books were. All of the books so far have had wide-ranging storylines, but with the first 3 there were always intersections that made it come together into a coherent whole. This book just felt too disconnected, as if I were reading half a dozen different, very long stories simultaneously.

[Guynemer]

I think of it as the necessary deep breath after the nonstop bat**** insanity that is the last half of book 3.

I love it. I think we need to see how all the war and turmoil has affected the average schmuck, and Brienne's story, especially, is critical to that.

[OzzyKP]

I'm just glad that Bran & Arya finally got somewhere. I was definitely getting tired of 2-3 seasons of them wandering around in the wilderness.

[Jon Miller]

I have tried reading other 'popular' fantasy books like Book of the Fallen. My problem with many is that they are non-stop insanity all the way through. I don't see how anyone could survive that (mentally).

I think that Martin puts his characters through as much as is possible and still have it ring 'true'.

I liked book 4 and thought it was important.

JM

[Bosh]

As for book five, reading it is far far far more enjoyable if you come into it knowing (very mild and vague spoiler):

Spoiler:

That certain large plot elements are going to end with cliffhangers that get resolved in book six instead of with large flashy conclusions at the end of book five. Being very annoyed that certain plot threads never got tied up poisoned a lot of my enjoyment of the book for me but if you come into it willing to let a good heap of fireworks that Martin trucks onto stage left un-exploded it has some good stuff, a certain plot-line may be the best one-character plot-line in the series that concludes with a marvelous set-piece that I really am looking forward to the TV adapting, although some of the others really could've lost a few chapters and been fine.

This blog (read the posts oldest to newest) also does an excellent job of analyzing the fifth book: http://meereeneseblot.wordpress.com/ and is well worth a read after you've read it.

[Guynemer]

You have to remember your name, Bosh.

[Dauphin]

Would be a good troll if Martin has actually written all the remaining books and has decided to only have them published after his death, after all the wailing and gnashing.

[Dinner]

The Queen's Guard playing the Game of Thrones theme song.


The season 4 blooper reel.


These are the new actors for season 5.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Jonathan Price as High Sparrow

[Dinner]

I'm glad they didn't cut out the Sand Snakes like they were rumored to be considering but they're all supposed to be half sisters so how is it they got actresses who don't like anything alike and are even different races? Surely even half sisters should have some basic family resemblance?

[Dr Strangelove]

Yay! Dr, Bashir!

Shouldn't Macella Baratheon be pre-adolescent?

[Imran Siddiqui]

All the kids were aged up. Robb and Jon should have been 15 in Game of Thrones (as should have Joffrey) for instance.