Police Department kills 4 students...

[Donegeal]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
Your post confuses me.

My LOL was a gut reaction to yours and Wiggys post at 39 and 40. Namely for the reason that Ming stated and then that Wiggy seems to be thinking I'm making things up.

Now your question about wether she had a valid ID in 2006 is unanswerable. Most likely, it would appear that she did not, but the article does not state either way, so I'm inclined to not assume anything. You may continue to do so if you wish.

[Ming]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
@ Ming: If she didn't have a valid ID in 08, what do you think the odds of her having a valid ID to present to the officer in 06 were?

I was only refering to the specific instance that you quoted.

[Arrian]

Thanks, Donegeal.

The 2006 incident is the one that was potentially a screwup.

My department has a policy that requires everyone issued a traffic citation of this type to be arrested and booked into jail.

-Arrian

[DinoDoc]

Originally posted by Arrian
The 2006 incident is the one that was potentially a screwup.

I'm glad that I finally got someone to admit that.

[Arrian]

Potentially a screwup =! "Police Department kills 4 students by not doing their jobs."

And I still think this was mostly about you whining about illegal immigrants.

-Arrian

[DinoDoc]

Ones that have runs in with police, yes. I've already given my opinion on what I think of the straw man you're begging to bring up.

[Arrian]

You keep saying it's a strawman, yet you harp on the illegal immigrant issue enough that it gives me reason to believe it's more accurate than you claim.

But ok, I'll drop it it and simply say that I agree with Donegeal's department's policy. If the woman was unable to present ID that was reasonably valid-looking (obviously it wouldn't have actually been valid) to the cop who let her go in 2006, that was a screwup. We don't know for sure, but it seems likely.

-Arrian

[DinoDoc]

Originally posted by Arrian
You keep saying it's a strawman, yet you harp on the illegal immigrant issue enough that it gives me reason to believe it's more accurate than you claim.

I don't really care what you do or do not believe but at least have some evidence to back up the assumption. It's just annoying when I've specifically gone on the record here and in other threads that I don't support what you keep alledging I do. If you want more info on what I do and do not believe, I started a whole thread for people to ask that stuff if they were so inclined.

[Arrian]

I remember that thread, which shouldn't be surprising since I actively participated in it.

I failed to ask for your position on immigration, which in retrospect is odd. Perhaps my impression of you being knee-jerk anti-immigrant developed after that thread. Of course, my first question in that thread remains valid despite your response, and is one possible reason that someone might get the wrong idea about you...

-Arrian